Belyaevo District, 2014. Personal Archive

What is the Right Question?

An interview with architect Anton Shramkov about possible future de-​urbanisation and the ways in which architects should adapt to it

Read intro

An interview with Anton Shramkov

An interview by Audingas Sumskas

Within the current crisis in architecture, Anton Shramkov draws possible future of the backflow to hinterland and shows the ways in which architects should adapt to the situation. He comes up with the idea of architects’ tool set and introduces other ways of operating within society, which he believes are part of relational architecture.

Anton Shramkov holds the position of Tutor of Architecture at Umeå School of Architecture, Sweden. He studied and taught at MARCH School of Architecture, Moscow and ran his own practice in Russia and Lithuania.
Hide intro

You have experienced both Russian and Western academia. How did your approach to architecture and the way it is taught change during that period? What shifts do you see?

I think architectural education and architectural practice start to become similar. The most interesting thing is that they are both incomplete, therefore I see potential only if they would merge. For instance in Russia, especially Moscow School of Architecture has strong basis as an art education, technological disciplines. Students have clear understanding, basic tools and knowledge of future self-​development. But then nothing is ‘growing’ on that basis, because direction in which architecture is being developed is very archaic and can’t deal with contemporary issues. Stuck in the middle of 20th century… Same ideas! They are not able to ask the right question.

Here in Sweden they are able to ask the right question, and I believe it is more important– than to have the right answer. But students are absolutely unable to perform their best, because they have no basis. They can ask the right question, but can not develop anything based on that question. In this case I believe that if such education would merge the results would be quite good.

Let’s imagine that this education already exists. Based on that, how should we, as architects, operate in crisis of contemporary architecture? What kind of tools do we need for it?

Depends on which level we are ‘arriving’ to the question. Is the future related to big architectural offices or small individual practices? In both cases the tool set is very different. But they share basics. First of all, the ability to ask the right question is the most important one. And the second, not less important, is the ability to explain your ideas to society, which has no relation with architecture at all. I think an architect in the contemporary world should be able to not only ask and be a great theoretician, but also to be able to test concepts, even on a 1:1 scale. My feeling is that sooner or later the crisis will be so big that architects will need to work on construction sites themselves. Especially in contemporary political and ecological situation.

The fact that architects are not participating in the process of construction is a huge disadvantage of Swedish architects and the system itself.

The fact that architects are not participating in the process of construction is a huge disadvantage of Swedish architects and the system itself.

For instance, the film ‘Garbage Warrior’ investigates the spots of climate disasters and shows that architects are required there much more than in the cities. The future may also be related with these scenarios.

You mentioned that we, as architects, should be more and more engaged in the field of practice, testing. Not only knowing the theory, but also a ‘go-​and-​do’ attitude. How should we really start to approach that?

Garbage Warrior, Documentary, 2007

I believe in relational architecture. I think architects should and must go to people, talk to them. Based on encounters the situation can change gradually. Architects should meet their customers by communicating with society, instead of inventing them. I believe this is the only way to change things now. And if you are doing research, mapping, you are in the field from the very beginning, have strong theoretical background and you can define the right issues, that is when you can start making interventions. You want advice? Just start talking to people.

You think that top-​down approach will disappear in the near future?

The situation now is the same as it was 100 years ago. What we have now (same as then) are two different directions – urbanization and de-​urbanization. It’s funny that in the beginning of 20th century the constructivist and avant-​garde movements were very strong, therefore all the modern architectural concepts started to emerge. That happened because of the period, the time of drastic changes. Now we are in the same period of change once again. We are on the edge of the war and climate change. The process of de-​urbanization is much more relevant now. I guess future lies with the hinterland.

Currently there are many different ways of reading marxism, and those ideas are coming back. There is an idea that the disappearance of the family is a normal thing, which I disagree with. But going back to your roots in smaller settlements could be the way to proceed.

Overpopulation and density in the cities, on the other hand, create distance between people. And that kind of relation is a bit weird to me. I think people that live as a community can perform way better for the common good.

Once there is a crisis, it is always accompanied by a strong backflow to the hinterland, to the countryside. People are trying to become their own employers and to be more independent. If a big crisis emerges, cities might die. How long would cities survive in a critical situation? Eight or nine days until a civil war starts, another week until even big cities collapse. This will happen because everything that is needed for sustainability – energy, food, materials – is produced outside of cities. Smaller settlements can provide for themselves.

In fact, the same backflow happened in the late 1920’s in Soviet Union. After the revolution many people started to move back to the suburbs. I think architects and their skill for organizing spaces and communication will be needed soon.

If we assume that there will be a strong backflow to the hinterland, what could be the picture of the upcoming future? It sounds like we will have empty cities and small towns that surround them.

Yes, in a way. If distribution of people on territory was equal, each of us would have a piece of land for our own purpose. I know that this is an absolute utopia. In this case it’s not about larger farms, bigger factories etc., but more about sharing resources and supporting each other in a closed circle.

You consider the current situation similar to what was 100 years ago, when we were on the edge of something new. Now we are on the edge as well. Maybe this is modernization? What can we learn from the past and what are the possible development scenarios?

The ideas that built our society 100 years ago were all marxist. Some ideas sounded really good, but when they were implemented we saw their flaws. People can be equal and have equal possibilities but still depend on each other. To solve this problem we need free communication, equal rights and opportunities. In search of these conditions people began to move to bigger cities. We learnt that to build something, we do not need to destroy everything else.

What do you mean exactly?

For instance, the case of Sweden and its idea of centralization and equal possibilities for societies all over the world. People started to move from the countryside to cities. I guess they thought it was easier to live and survive there. It actually is easier to a certain extent, but it ruined the countryside in Sweden. This is the result of globalization in full effect. Big cities don’t produce anything except money. But you can’t eat money, right?

I have an example from my own experience. In my residential block in Moscow, where I lived on 21st floor, I had a neighbour, an old lady who lived on the 22nd. When she had died, no one noticed, until after a month an awful smell appeared. This situation describes the relationship between people in a big city. Now I live in a small town, and if anyone dies here, it becomes a personal tragedy for everyone. I think that spiritual, physical, social, family roots are very important. Ignoring them only causes suffering. This is why I support the smaller scale, and architects need to learn to work on a smaller scale and be able to ask the right questions.

And finally, what is the right question?

I think the right question is: how can we co-​exist together? What could we do to co-​exist better? Actually it is not about asking someone the right question, but more about asking yourself while you are among others. 

zovirax ointment cialis patent expiration date extended generic viagra viagra nebenwirkungen viagra cialis buy cialis lexapro coupons common side effects of ciprofloxacin 500 mg cialis patent expiration 2017 side effects of azithromycin tamoxifen interaction buy generic levitra generic levitra lexapro benefits for women levitra 20 mg precio farmacia side effects of ciprofloxacin lexapro dosing cialis canadian pharmacy cialis generic availability finasteride for hair loss acyclovir 800mg cialis 5mg viagra tablets cialis voucher first few days on lexapro finasteride results finasteride for women what is azithromycin for viagra ohne rezept auf rechnung viagra sans ordonnance lowest cialis prices acyclovir 400mg liquid cialis zithromax 500 mg vardenafil vs viagra 9 levitra at walmart azithromycin and alcohol antibiotic ciprofloxacin what infections does ciprofloxacin treat side effects of ciprofloxacin 500 mg viagra tesco viagra medicine cialis copay card azithromycin liquid what is tamoxifen used for levitra prezzo in farmacia finasteride 5 mg tab discount viagra viagra price canada viagra tamoxifen cost azithromycin tablets zithromax antibiotic what is cipro acyclovir 200mg cialis coupons from manufacturer pfizer viagra coupons from pfizer how long for azithromycin to take effect levitra viagra vs cialis cialis effects how does cialis work azithromycin class what is tamoxifen ciprofloxacin 500mg azithromycin 250mg tablets 6 pack levitra rezeptfrei deutschland finasteride reviews levitra without a doctor prescription lexapro side effects in men utilisation viagra withdrawal from lexapro what is cipro used for tamoxifen therapy what bacteria does ciprofloxacin kill lexapro generic thuoc azithromycin cialis coupon ciprofloxacin 500mg tablets effects of stopping lexapro suddenly ciprofloxacin 250mg viagra activate lexapro weight gain azithromycin z pak what does finasteride do acyclovir vs valacyclovir herbal viagra cialas ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg side effects cialis or viagra side effects of cialis how to wean off lexapro cipro cialis sample viagra pills cialis pharmacy prices cialis for men ciprofloxacin bnf what is lexapro azithromycin 500mg what is acyclovir used for ciprofloxacin 250 mg ciprofloxacin used for viagra without a doctor prescription usa azithromycin cost finasteride cialis 30 day trial coupon cialis patent expiration side effects lexapro buying viagra escitalopram 10mg ciprofloxacin ophthalmic solution viagra en ligne livraison 24h how does viagra work levitra vs viagra azithromycin 500 mg cipro antibiotics propecia propecia side effects finasteride hair loss what works better than viagra acyclovir for cold sores cipro side effects in elderly azithromycin tablet finasteride 5mg tab generic lexapro viagra kaufen azithromycin side effects finasteride 5 mg viagra substitute cipro drug class acyclovir 800 mg finasteride 5mg lexapro reviews cialis medication lexapro generic name cipro dosage lexapro side effects viagra 100 levitra 20 mg cost walmart what is finasteride celexa vs lexapro equipe argentine viagra acyclovir medication ciprofloxacin 500 mg tabletten cheap cialis viagra ciprofloxacin side effects levitra generic azithromycin for strep throat cialis dosage nolvadex viagra vs cialis vs levitra what is ciprofloxacin cialis 20 mg cialis coupons printable levitra coupon ciprofloxacin 500mg antibiotics is lexapro a controlled substance levitra 20mg zovirax pills zoloft vs lexapro viagra for men levitra bayer 20mg meilleur prix cipro uses ciprofloxacin side effects in women what is ciprofloxacin prescribed for ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg tab vardenafil 20mg azithromycin three times a week viagra 100 mg cialis for women cialis coupon print viagra without a doctor prescription cialis canada viagra pillen kruidvat canadian cialis azithromycin pregnancy azithromycine eg 500 mg bijsluiter viagra for sale cialis from canada viagra for sale uk ciprofloxacin 500 viagra side effects lexapro vs celexa side effects of finasteride cialis daily viagra ohne rezept aus deutschland 200 cialis coupon cialis pills for sale cialis generic azithromycine 250 mg viagra single packs levitra vs viagra for hardness how long for lexapro to work how long does viagra last escitalopram 10 mg para que sirve stopping lexapro generic for lexapro viagra from canada acyclovir online cialis cialis vs viagra azithromycin eye drops finasteride 1mg buy cialis online finasteride long term effects cialis on line side effects of azithromycin 250 mg tamoxifen and bone pain zithromax z-​pak cialis reviews tamoxifen lawsuits side effects of tamoxifen cialis pricing azithromycin 500 erfahrungen cyalis women viagra is azithromycin what is viagra lexapro para que sirve lexapro viagra wiki azithromycin 250 side effects of acyclovir azithromycin 5 day dose pack wellbutrin and lexapro viagra 100mg side effects of finasteride 5mg cialis viagra coupons buy levitra online natural viagra viamedic cialis ciprofloxacin class what is escitalopram what does ciprofloxacin 500mg treat viagra vs cialis cheap levitra lexapro 10 mg azithromycin for uti ciprofloxacin hydrochloride ophthalmic over the counter viagra free viagra wholesale cialis acyclovir dosing what is azithromycin azithromycin 250 mg ciprofloxacin uses generic cialis at walmart what is acyclovir for ciprofloxacin nebenwirkungen weaning off lexapro how to take cialis lexapro for anxiety zovirax for cold sores cialis samples buy generic viagra how does lexapro work cialis 20mg directions ciprofloxacin eye drops lexapro side effects in women azithromycin drug class lexapro and wellbutrin combination therapy cialis dosage recommendations zithromax dosage erectile dysfunction cialis tamoxifen citrate azithromycin pregnancy category levitra 10 mg prezzo viagra for women zithromax viagra effects ciprofloxacin side effects after age 60 ciprofloxacin drug class acyclovir ointment 5 cialis testimonials cialis free trial viagra dosage what is azithromycin used for azithromycin 250mg acyclovir cream cialis for daily use how to use viagra lexapro overdose tamoxifen side effects in women tamoxifen side effects cipro side effects lexapro side effects men lexapro medication acyclovir dosage for cold sores side effects of lexapro 10 mg how does acyclovir work tamoxifen and weight gain how to get off lexapro finasteride permanent side effects what is finasteride used for how much does cialis cost viagra soft levitra 20 mg does lexapro cause weight gain viagra sex post finasteride syndrome ciprofloxacin buy viagra online finasteride 5mg side effects daily cialis tamoxifen nebenwirkungen lexapro manufacturer website best price viagra ciprofloxacin hcl tamoxifen acyclovir side effects cialis professional cialis trial escitalopram nebenwirkungen acyclovir for shingles what does ciprofloxacin treat cialis dosage strengths cialis vs viagra azithromycin vs erythromycin viagra 50mg lexapro 10mg tamoxifen bijwerkingen cialis price finasteride 5mg side effects mayo clinic cost of cialis cialis alternative cipro antibiotic lexapro dosages viagra generic ciprofloxacin drops ciprofloxacin 500 mg for urinary tract infection viagra on line no prec what is ciprofloxacin used for cialis pills acyclovir ointment zovirax cream tamoxifen and foods to avoid viagra online escitalopram 10 mg cost of viagra azithromycin 500 is tamoxifen chemotherapy finasteride dosage finasteride tablets viagra bestellen viagra samples canada cialis zovirax dosage generic levitra vardenafil 20mg cialis 30 day sample cialis for bph cipro and tendonitis cialis prices tamoxifen side effects in women over 55 generic cialis revatio vs viagra ciprofloxacin coverage acyclovir dosage levitra online levitra 20mg cost per pill lexapro and weight gain in women cialis otc viagra coupon cialis 20mg cialis samples overnight cialis side effects buy levitra ciprofloxacin spc cialis savings card what is lexapro used for cipro dangers side effects of lexapro canadian viagra viagra receptfritt cilias cialis cost escitalopram what is cipro usually prescribed for viagra canada lexapro 5mg escitalopram side effects cialis website viagra cost cialis coupons 2017 ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg levitra coupons levitra prices cialis coupons lexapro and weight loss order viagra escitalopram effets secondaires what is cialis cipro 500 viagra on line ciprofloxacin 500mg antibiotics side effects pfizer viagra acyclovir dose azithromycin without a doctor’s prescription viagra uk cialis cheap tamoxifen langzeitfolgen side effects of viagra cialis discount acyclovir 800 mg 5 times a day azithromycin dosage how to wean off lexapro without withdrawals finasteride medication cipro for uti ciprofloxacin dosierung azithromycin coverage acyclovir 800 mg for shingles levitra 20 mg von bayer viagra alternatives escitalopram 20 mg azithromycin medscape cialis 10 mg azithromycine sex viagra for women ciprofloxacin dosage levitra vs viagra azithromycin uses what does azithromycin treat viagra 100mg tablets retail price acyclovir 400 mg lexapro withdrawal symptoms generic for cialis female viagra finasteride vs dutasteride buy viagra lexapro bula generic viagra 100mg cialis online side effects of lexapro in women lexapro and weight gain viagra pill viagra natural cialis without a doctor’s prescription when will cialis go generic effects of stopping finasteride finasteride side effects what does viagra do azithromycin levitra dosage cialis generic tadalafil discount cialis where to buy viagra online viagra is ciprofloxacin a penicillin cialis coupon 20 mg lexapro 20mg finasteride and enlarged prostate viagra wikipedia what is acyclovir sophia viagra zovirax viagra tablet viagra costs cialis tadalafil is azithromycin penicillin cialis 5 mg finasteride efectos secundarios cialis 5mg daily viagra alternative lexapro vs wellbutrin lexapro withdrawal lexapro dosage finasteride effets secondaires viagra prices azithromycin 250 mg treatment cheap viagra lexapro vs zoloft ciprofloxacin 500 mg finasteride side effects in men what is lexapro for free cialis generic cialis tadalafil azithromycin for pneumonia ciprofloxacin dose viagra vs cialis vs levitra azithromycin pediatric dosing price cialis ciprofloxacin for dogs levitra erfahrungen cealis escitalopram oxalate ciprofloxacin hydrochloride cialis for sale viagra generico