Many trucks driving in motion blur on the freeway at beautiful sunset. Rush hour on the motorway near Belgrade – Serbia.

What can architecture learn from logistics

Architect Jesse LeCavalier discusses what city planners could learn from Walmart, Amazon and other influential retailers

Read intro

An interview with Jesse LeCavalier

An interview by Mihailo Popović

A discussion about relevance of logistics for architecture and city planning with Jesse LeCavalier, an architect with special interest in logistics and retail infrastructure. Discussing the trends in city planning, their evolution and possible future paths.

Jesse LeCavalier is an assistant professor of architecture at New Jersey Institute of Technology and a member of Co+LeCavalier, a senior researcher at the Singapore–ETH Center’s Future Cities Laboratory. His work has appeared in Cabinet, Public Culture, and AD, among others. LeCavalier’s essay, 'The Restlessness of Objects' was the recipient of a 2013 Core77 Design Award and his article 'All Those Numbers' was named by the Atlantic as one of 'Nearly 100 Fantastic Pieces of Journalism' in 2011. LeCavalier has a Doctor of Science from the ETH Zurich, on retail logistics, a Master of Architecture from the University of California, Berkeley, and a Bachelor of Arts from Brown University.
Hide intro

What brought you to questions of logistics? Why Walmart?

It started with an interest in changing the nature of public space in the United States. I was interested in different kinds of sites of political engagement. For example, the shopping mall as a site of disputed public territory, where you need a permit to distribute flyers or to get signatures for petitions. That has been a debated site of public engagement. Different parties claimed different. The owner would say it’s private, but people wanted to use it as public. And there has been a number of supreme court cases about that. From there I was curious about how something like a Walmart store, which is one of the few places that is open for 24 hours in smaller towns became an urban hub. Then I was simultaneously interested in subjects of infrastructure, and how larger scale design operations have repelling effects, in terms of setting certain processes in motion. I realized that they are the part of a much larger network, but what really started to distinguish this company in terms of its capacity, was its relationship to logistical network and logistical expertise. Its awareness and deliberate investments in logistics as a site of potential competitive advantage.

picture1

UPS launches ‘We Love Logistics’ campaign, September 2010

Why is logistics interesting and relevant to contemporary discussions of urbanism, architecture and design?

We can think about early industrialization and what happened to cities with the growth of factories and that kind of material-​intensive investments in locations where goods would be brought in and consolidated. And I am mostly talking from an American point of view. In the US, for example, some places like the north-​east is where all sorts of trade routes brought raw materials into cities, and then those cities consolidated around giant industrial processes. You could think about Ford or General Motors as a paradigmatic company of early industrialization. Then there was the shift toward the information age of the IBMs and the CISCOs and things like that. I have been thinking whether we can call the age that we are in now the age of circulation, where industrialization and communication are brought together uncomfortably. I think that’s what’s interesting about this moment. If you look into an advertising image of logistics by companies like UPS or FedEx, they present it as an immaterial thing. It looks like a seamless process of movement when in fact it’s intense and quite heavy.

So it is basically combining the two: trying to deal with communication while simultaneously managing the physicality. What you get as a result is a weird duality between a tendency toward abstraction and concreteness simultaneously. Amazon and Walmart for example, the more they try to deny space by claiming that things can be delivered instantaneously, the more they have to encumber huge territories in order to make that happen.

The more Amazon and Walmart try to deny space by claiming that things can be delivered instantaneously, the more they have to encumber huge territories to make that happen

I have been trying to think about logistics at different scales and I’ve been trying to look at the Walmart story in basically three scales: scale of the body, scale of the building and scale of the city. Mostly I have been talking about the scale of the city and how these different dynamics are acting in the city. The other is the building scale. Walmart says it’s a retailer, but I think they are really a logistics company in a sense that mostly what they are concerned about is moving material around in a fast and reliable way. The way they think about their buildings differ: not as a capital investments but as operating costs, as equipment. They don’t see them in the same way previous corporations have seen their buildings. And this is true for any kind of large retailer like IKEA. What does it mean to be designing these kinds of buildings? What can we learn from the way these buildings are designed? It might suggest the opportunity to make architecture itself more nimble. I think we might be seeing another gap that needs to be filled in terms of these questions of infrastructure logistics.

Can you explain a bit more about Walmart’s attitude towards their buildings?

What’s interesting to me is how Walmart’s attitude towards buildings is not about preciousness of an object, nor architecture as enclosure, it’s really about architecture as interface and mediation. The building itself is a way to connect the shipping network to shoppers and their local sites. They are built to be flexible to adapt to a range of surprising conditions, to absorb the risks of Walmart’s operations.

And how is this new age of circulation taking shape?

The ability to automate information management has been part of this technological shift. The barcode has enabled instantaneous recording and monitoring of information in a way that was not possible before. The barcode is really dramatic because it allows different kinds of organizations to keep track of the movement of goods with all sorts of different data sets. In Walmart’s case, consumer purchasing behavior, linked to location and linked to season and linked to demographic trends, allows them to predict consumer behavior.

Are they really predicting consumption demands and desires so well? Because, as you showed, they need less and less storage rooms in their shops as result of sophisticated system that is feeding the demand?

There is a distinction between pushing and pulling the market. The old model of motor companies like a pre-​lean production car company would push their inventory to the market. They would make a certain number of cars and force their dealers to sell them. With the abandonment of lean production it became a pull model based on consumer demand. The consumer has a lot more power, because they are able to engage production based on their desire, but that’s also linked to the company itself nurturing and cultivating that desire.

It’s not so much that there is this autonomous consumer desire that Walmart is just responding to. There is a coproduction of that. They have a relationship with private weather companies that allow them to track weather patterns and respond more quickly. In US, the national weather service has a duty to the public to not be risky or alarmist, so they tend to be very conservative in their predictions and wait as long as they can before making an announcement. When hurricane Katrina made fall to New Orleans Walmart’s weather service, having the obligation only towards their client, was able to risk earlier prediction that it would hit land sooner. And they did that. As a result Walmart itself could mobilize more quickly than public services. There are these different kinds of scales based widening the gap between public services and private services. Because Walmart is able to develop their own set of various kinds of intellectual expertise, they are able to also operate in different kind of way. 

Walmart’s attitude towards buildings is not about preciousness of an object, nor architecture as enclosure, it’s really about architecture as interface and mediation

The other example how they use their data is about how they choose locations, and this is where it intersects with urbanism. They have these marketing protocols linked to growth, saying where and how they need to expand, so they use processing software. In one they look at the locations that are currently available and how these compete with other locations. In the other one they do it in an opposite way. They say: ‘This is the kind of demographic we want to reach, so where should we build a building?’ If you extrapolate, there is implication that eventually building of cities becomes automated. There is an increasingly absent set of design choices.

picture 2

Walmart distribution center scheme. Designed to be flexible to adopt and keep Walmart’s operations going. Courtesy of Jesse LeCavalier

Through logistics systems we can see encapsulated future versions of cities. If location strategies can be optimized, and if Walmart does it well, there is a tendency to say we can do something similar. The idea of a city as something to be optimized should be taken seriously, but we should also be careful about it. We have to find ways to remember that a business is different from a city.

As we are talking about city and a building, I want to add one more thing, which is about the scale of a body. I think one of the reasons to look at logistics, is logistics buildings themselves. The large distribution centers and things like that, could stand in for a future and not implausible future environment, that we all may be inhabiting. One that is automated and incredibly data rich but also basically eligible to us. The more those systems become automated, the more we, who have to engage with those systems, are not equipped to read them. And so we have to get all these mediating devices to access this information. Those large data and distribution centers serve as a proxy for the environment that we might all be living in the future. So what future environments might be, as things become increasingly automated?

It is interesting what you said about Walmart buildings, that they can’t be seen as single objects, as they are part of one big thing. It in a way answers the rising questions of how more and more buildings that are built today have no local specificities and could be planted anywhere in the world. Should Walmart stores have local specificities?

One of the things that is interesting about Walmart is the means by which they build their buildings. They develop a series of prototypes and those prototypes are never built. The prototype describes certain configurations and set of requirements. When they have a new site and need to build it, they determine which kind of prototype works for that site and do this process called ‘site-​adopt’. The prototype gets modified in the field and becomes a different version every single time, even though it’s the same building. In a way it is locally adopted. It doesn’t have symbolic local relationships. They are basically copies without originals. They use that effectively because they can build them very quickly. WalMart is building several hundreds of stores a year, which means one opens every few days.

There other non-​geopolitically aggressive ways that building or architecture could be used. Any kind of corporate expansion processes is about securing territory and finding strategic location to ensure future growth. Is that capacity of buildings useful for other reasons? Is there something else that is good for that, other then getting locational advantage? I think it’s something to think about.

Could you say or speculate how logistical systems will look in near or more distant future?

The question is what’s the nature of logistical space. I wonder if you can connect it to these ideas of prediction and anticipation. So maybe we can talk about logistical space as being anticipatory. Maybe then communication space was reactive? Maybe we can think about future ideas of distribution that would have things that will people likely want, suspended in some kind of state of readiness. For example, you could imagine at any given moment there was a truck within one mile of you that has a book that you want, you order it and receive it immediately. That’s a different kind of attitude towards distance. It’s less about point to point and maybe more about kind of suspended state of readiness and anticipation.

You have probably heard about the KIVA company. Amazon recently purchased them, and it was the largest takeover since they bought Zappos – they spent 775 million on it. Kiva produces small robots that can bring the shelf to a person instead of having a distribution person do it. What that means for Amazon is huge, because there is a different kind of relationship to labor. It’s increasingly automated and the layout of the stores themselves start to conform to desires, so the more popular items stay closer to the people picking the orders, and less desired things get pushed and pushed further away. The building itself is changing. The previous model of distribution center is incredible materially intensive thing. Imagine 1 million square feet of conveyor belts and mechanized loaders and all of these things… And automation does away with a huge amount of that because all you need is simply the most basic enclosure. So the architecture becomes even more dematerialized. It requires the thinnest possible membrane to keep the weather out. I think that starts to suggest larger sets of tendencies towards suspension, towards anticipation.

When hurricane Katrina made fall to New Orleans, Walmart’s weather service was able to risk earlier prediction that it would hit land sooner

What happened to production itself?

Externalization, pushing costs further and further away. And a part of it is because they have command of information. They have proprietary software system that allows their suppliers to see what’s selling. So, if you are toothpaste manufacturer, you can see how many units are being sold and where but, Walmart can also see around inventory. As a result they can also push back and force other kinds of externalization. Sites of worst kind of labor are pushed to the places where it’s cheapest. And that brings up issues about humanitarian concerns. There is a recent book from Deborah Cowen called The Deadly Life of Logistics that talks about this. 

picture3

Automation of site selection. One of two software models that Walmart uses. This is where logistics intersects with questions of urbanism. Courtesy of Jesse LeCavalier.

This is why I wanted to bring up this question of behavior. One of the versions of this story is, that those externalities will just keep going to the places where they are going to, and as they will then bring up quality of life slightly at each place. And gradually middle classes emerge, and gradually labor costs rise, and gradually that labor gets externalized elsewhere… And how far it would take to get to some point when that wouldn’t be possible anymore? What’s the limit of that dynamic? And will there always be other kind of cheaper source of labor, or there will be a point when it will loop back on itself? Or will it reach a point when automate labor will be cheap enough? And then how people will be living? 

Amazon vs. Walmart? Which model will prevail?

It would be more interesting to ask what would happen if one or the other one succeeded? What would be the consequences of one prevailing? If some kind of hybridization occurs? For me, that would be the way I would try to answer it.

finasteride efectos secundarios side effects of cialis generic levitra what does azithromycin treat lexapro dosing viagra for sale uk viagra single packs is azithromycin penicillin sophia viagra cialis pills what is acyclovir viagra for men cialis for men cipro dosage azithromycin z pak levitra dosage how much does cialis cost acyclovir dosage for cold sores liquid cialis levitra vs viagra how long for lexapro to work escitalopram 10 mg para que sirve viagra alternative what is ciprofloxacin prescribed for viagra tablet ciprofloxacin 500 cialis medication how does acyclovir work azithromycine 250 mg cialis 10 mg cialis 5mg daily cheap cialis viagra without a doctor prescription azithromycin coverage viagra coupon generic viagra cilias finasteride hair loss buying viagra canadian viagra side effects of finasteride 5mg what infections does ciprofloxacin treat cialis coupons from manufacturer cialis coupon 20 mg viagra without a doctor prescription usa is azithromycin erectile dysfunction cialis cipro antibiotic viagra vs cialis vs levitra ciprofloxacin drug class viagra natural azithromycin tablet viagra en ligne livraison 24h levitra erfahrungen tamoxifen side effects side effects of finasteride cialis online cialis side effects viagra 50mg levitra 20 mg precio farmacia azithromycin pregnancy female viagra levitra 20 mg von bayer viagra cialis azithromycin for strep throat viagra generic side effects of azithromycin 250 mg azithromycin and alcohol side effects of azithromycin generic cialis at walmart viagra prices cialis pharmacy prices escitalopram 20 mg azithromycin acyclovir 800 mg for shingles escitalopram oxalate discount cialis common side effects of ciprofloxacin 500 mg how does lexapro work levitra 20 mg cost walmart cialis 20mg how does cialis work ciprofloxacin ophthalmic solution ciprofloxacin coverage cost of viagra ciprofloxacin uses best price viagra lexapro manufacturer website viagra generico finasteride 1mg vardenafil 20mg ciprofloxacin hydrochloride antibiotic ciprofloxacin tamoxifen interaction cialis coupons 2017 lexapro overdose ciprofloxacin drops levitra vs viagra viagra uk viagra for sale tamoxifen langzeitfolgen propecia side effects ciprofloxacin 500 mg finasteride tablets online cialis over the counter viagra 200 cialis coupon azithromycin eye drops escitalopram nebenwirkungen finasteride side effects in men azithromycin 5 day dose pack does lexapro cause weight gain acyclovir 800 mg viagra 100 cialis canada levitra 20 mg is ciprofloxacin a penicillin cialis samples effects of stopping finasteride where to buy viagra lexapro and weight gain in women ciprofloxacin side effects buy viagra online side effects of ciprofloxacin azithromycine lexapro side effects men cialis voucher levitra coupon azithromycin for uti acyclovir dosage buy levitra buy levitra online cialis coupon lexapro bula what is lexapro pfizer viagra ciprofloxacin class viagra canada cialis prices ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg tamoxifen and weight gain escitalopram effets secondaires levitra bayer 20mg meilleur prix azithromycin drug class vardenafil vs viagra finasteride 5mg cipro and tendonitis withdrawal from lexapro equipe argentine viagra cialis daily acyclovir dosing canadian cialis levitra prices side effects of viagra escitalopram 10mg lexapro and wellbutrin combination therapy is tamoxifen chemotherapy cialis pills for sale azithromycin dosage 9 levitra at walmart cyalis viagra 100mg ciprofloxacin 500mg finasteride side effects acyclovir 800mg celexa vs lexapro cipro side effects in elderly lexapro dosage ciprofloxacin hydrochloride ophthalmic herbal viagra zithromax ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg side effects viagra nebenwirkungen cipro drug class cipro for uti what is cialis what does viagra do viagra wiki daily cialis what bacteria does ciprofloxacin kill ciprofloxacin lexapro vs zoloft sex viagra for women lexapro vs celexa what is azithromycin used for free cialis cialis generic tadalafil how long for azithromycin to take effect escitalopram side effects acyclovir for cold sores lexapro side effects cialis coupons printable azithromycin 500mg tamoxifen therapy lexapro medication lexapro lexapro 20mg cialis website levitra 20mg cost per pill zoloft vs lexapro utilisation viagra cialis alternative side effects of ciprofloxacin 500 mg tamoxifen what is cipro lexapro withdrawal symptoms lexapro and weight gain what is lexapro for cialis reviews buy viagra cealis lowest cialis prices revatio vs viagra what is ciprofloxacin used for cialis discount lexapro 10mg finasteride for hair loss viagra pillen kruidvat ciprofloxacin 250 mg how to use viagra tamoxifen and foods to avoid azithromycin medscape what is cipro usually prescribed for what is ciprofloxacin levitra 10 mg prezzo cialis for daily use cialis samples overnight what is azithromycin ciprofloxacin side effects in women what works better than viagra what is lexapro used for lexapro benefits for women acyclovir for shingles what is tamoxifen used for ciprofloxacin 500mg antibiotics side effects cialis for bph cialis cialis patent expiration acyclovir 200mg cost of cialis viagra from canada zovirax ointment cialis otc what is cipro used for finasteride effets secondaires viagra receptfritt viagra kaufen how to wean off lexapro without withdrawals tamoxifen cost finasteride vs dutasteride ciprofloxacin dosage viagra 100mg tablets retail price side effects of lexapro in women acyclovir 800 mg 5 times a day cialas ciprofloxacin dose cialis generic availability generic cialis tadalafil cialis 5 mg lexapro para que sirve cialis professional effects of stopping lexapro suddenly tamoxifen nebenwirkungen viagra wikipedia zithromax dosage cialis 20mg directions azithromycin for pneumonia viagra soft azithromycin side effects ciprofloxacin 500mg tablets how to wean off lexapro cialis for women women viagra azithromycin tablets acyclovir medication generic cialis side effects of tamoxifen cialis trial zithromax antibiotic cialis copay card finasteride 5mg tab finasteride reviews cialis dosage recommendations cialis coupon print lexapro vs wellbutrin ciprofloxacin dosierung viagra vs cialis cialis dosage viagra on line viagra 100 mg viagra substitute azithromycin 250 viagra vs cialis cialis 20 mg viagra samples cialis patent expiration date extended generic levitra vardenafil 20mg cipro 500 when will cialis go generic canada cialis levitra prezzo in farmacia first few days on lexapro viagra bestellen lexapro generic name cipro dangers what is finasteride used for how to take cialis levitra online cipro uses viagra ohne rezept aus deutschland levitra coupons wellbutrin and lexapro buy generic viagra acyclovir ointment viamedic cialis finasteride 5mg side effects mayo clinic ciprofloxacin spc finasteride 5 mg cialis 5mg thuoc azithromycin levitra vs viagra for hardness price cialis cialis testimonials cialis sample cialis dosage strengths ciprofloxacin side effects after age 60 lexapro and weight loss tamoxifen bijwerkingen what is azithromycin for zithromax z-​pak zovirax dosage side effects lexapro cialis 30 day trial coupon zovirax lexapro withdrawal cialis 30 day sample ciprofloxacin 500mg antibiotics side effects of lexapro cheap levitra buy cialis cialis from canada viagra vs cialis vs levitra ciprofloxacin bnf cipro viagra ohne rezept auf rechnung viagra pill what is tamoxifen tamoxifen citrate azithromycin three times a week cialis coupons what does finasteride do viagra dosage viagra cost lexapro side effects in men cialis cheap what does ciprofloxacin treat azithromycin cost acyclovir ointment 5 stopping lexapro discount viagra finasteride lexapro reviews tamoxifen lawsuits what is acyclovir used for lexapro 5mg acyclovir vs valacyclovir finasteride results viagra pills ciprofloxacin 500 mg tabletten cialis on line viagra for women azithromycin without a doctor’s prescription viagra side effects azithromycin 500 mg viagra viagra alternatives lexapro 10 mg buy cialis online finasteride and enlarged prostate acyclovir cialis vs viagra zovirax cream levitra rezeptfrei deutschland viagra medicine cialis effects cialis canadian pharmacy acyclovir 400mg cialis cost what is escitalopram ciprofloxacin 500 mg for urinary tract infection online viagra finasteride 5 mg tab post finasteride syndrome natural viagra cialis for sale acyclovir side effects what is viagra viagra coupons pfizer viagra coupons from pfizer cialis free trial viagra sans ordonnance zithromax 500 mg finasteride long term effects azithromycin vs erythromycin escitalopram cialis vs viagra acyclovir cream cialis pricing lexapro generic generic lexapro finasteride dosage side effects of acyclovir what is acyclovir for generic for lexapro azithromycin 250mg tablets 6 pack lexapro coupons lexapro weight gain azithromycine eg 500 mg bijsluiter azithromycin 250 mg generic viagra 100mg azithromycin 250mg azithromycin liquid finasteride medication how does viagra work how long does viagra last viagra tesco tamoxifen side effects in women ciprofloxacin nebenwirkungen cialis or viagra levitra 20mg viagra effects cialis patent expiration 2017 cialis without a doctor’s prescription what is finasteride azithromycin 250 mg treatment cialis price finasteride permanent side effects viagra online viagra price lexapro for anxiety finasteride for women escitalopram 10 mg buy generic levitra azithromycin class side effects of lexapro 10 mg propecia generic for cialis azithromycin 500 erfahrungen nolvadex zovirax for cold sores cipro antibiotics levitra free viagra what does ciprofloxacin 500mg treat cialis tadalafil is lexapro a controlled substance azithromycin 500 azithromycin pediatric dosing cialis savings card levitra without a doctor prescription cheap viagra how to get off lexapro viagra sex ciprofloxacin for dogs finasteride 5mg side effects acyclovir 400 mg viagra on line no prec cialis generic ciprofloxacin 250mg tamoxifen side effects in women over 55 ciprofloxacin hcl weaning off lexapro viagra activate zovirax pills canada viagra tamoxifen and bone pain cipro side effects lexapro side effects in women azithromycin uses azithromycin pregnancy category acyclovir dose ciprofloxacin eye drops levitra generic viagra tablets ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg tab ciprofloxacin used for viagra costs order viagra lexapro dosages wholesale cialis

Share