Cosmonauts Oleg Kotov and Sergei Ryazansky on the historic spacewalk / NASA TV / AFP / Getty

Volumetric transfer system: the path to real innovation in transport infrastructure

An interview with Vladimir Pirozhkov on the future of transport by Irina Eremenko

Read intro

An interview with Vladimir Pirozhkov

An interview by Irina Eremenko

We pay a great deal of attention to transport in contemporary cities. Traffic jams, the problems of public transport, improving transport systems in urban areas - these topics rarely leave the front pages of local newspapers. The reason is obvious: a city’s transport system forms a space in which each citizen will spend many years of his life. We asked the famous expert in the field of industrial and car design Vladimir Pirozhkov how he sees the future of cities in terms of transport infrastructure development. Vladimir graduated from the Sverdlovsk Architectural Institute, where he specialised in "Transportation Design", and from the Art Centre College of Design in Switzerland. In 1994 he joined Citroen, where he worked as a developer on the interiors of several car models. In 2000 he was appointed senior designer at the Toyota design centre in Nice. Back in Russia, Vladimir has founded and headed the Astra Rossa centre of industrial design and innovation. At the moment, our expert is in the process of creating a joint educational centre at the National University of Science and Technology MISIS in collaboration with MIT.
Hide intro

You grew up in Togliatti. This is a special city in Russia in terms of car production: it has the largest automobile manufacturing plant in the country – AvtoVAZ. In this case, it is interesting to note that the city itself and its transport system were designed in such a way that Togliatti is geographically divided into three separate parts, loosely connected by transport infrastructure. If the city was designed nowadays, with the current achievements in technology, how do you think it would be organised differently?

Yes, you’re right. Togliatti is really divided into three parts : the Komsomolsky, Central, and Avtozavodsky districts. The Avtozavodsky district, was, in my opinion, very well designed: with wide streets, up to 600 metres across, where the width of the roadway can reach 40 – 50 metres. On the one hand, nowadays, when we have more cars than people, this is very much in demand. On the other hand, I can understand the problems of the city authorities who have to maintain such a large amount of space – this is a colossal investment. In Soviet times it was financed by the government, but this is not considered now – it’s all commercialised and is worth a hundred times more. The city was designed, in my opinion, very well.

If I was in process of Togliatti planning now I would pay more attention to the cultural zones of the city… I would have done more “pixel”, would create several centers. This must be done so that people firstly, could freely reach public spaces by foot, and, secondly, want to go there.

If I was involved in the process of planning Togliatti now, I would pay more attention to the cultural zones of the city. As is well known, cities were designed by large “strokes” in Soviet times. The House of Culture, for example, could take up a huge area of the city: Togliatti’s was under construction for over 10 years, and then for another 10 years the interior decoration was carried out. Nowadays I would use more “pixels”, I would create several centres. This must be done so that people, firstly, are able freely to reach public spaces on foot, and, secondly, will want to go there. Because there are no clear centres now, the social sphere of everyday life is underdeveloped. People actually have no place to meet each other, they have to do this either at home, in small groups, or rent some huge urban space. Originally there was no place provided in the city for the creation of cafes or various social events. Commercial premises were also not provided and now this all has its effect on the psychology of the people. Having lived in Europe, and seen those cities that weren’t demolished by the War, I can say that they are much more comfortable and have a balanced centre in which people can always come and spend time comfortably, even if they live outside the city.

In general, I would not create a city along a highway, as these form a bottleneck, which has a very low transport capacity. Originally, the city of Stavropol-​on-​Volga (Togliatti’s early modern predecessor) was built right at the intersection of several historical transportation routes. The city had to be somewhere near. It just needed a few exit roads of an appropriate scale linking it to the federal highway. And this was what was actually done during the city’s construction.

If we want to be powerful, bright and desirable from the urbanist point of view, we must attract foreigners by means of powerful historical places, sites to stick in the memory of visitors and make them to return. For example, any pub that has stood there for 400 years. as they have in England. This would be an attraction point – a “social magnet”. If I designed the city, I would like it to have some kind of central, active part, but at the same time a residential area in which people would want to settle down.

Courtesy of Vladimir Pirozhkov

Courtesy of Vladimir Pirozhkov

You have being working in Europe for the leading car production companies for more than 20 years. Do these companies understand and forecast the future of transport infrastructure in general? Are some of them coming into the urbanistics area with the aim of developing urban service infrastructure in general, by offering solutions to improve the quality of life? What do you think, for example, about the “Harmonious Beijing” project, which proposes to create a transport infrastructure that will move cars by itself, thereby reducing the amount of harmful emissions into the environment?

First of all, ”Harmonious Beijing” is a student project; such projects are often carried out within the framework of educational programmes for designers, architects and urbanists. Implementation of such abstract projects is always a big problem. Therefore, the whole system is usually built based on the existing infrastructure of the city by developing it. For example, the road traffic system evolved from the rules of movement at mediaeval tournaments: in the right hand – a spear, in the left – a shield.

Any new transport system will take the previous one as the starting point for its development. For example, if we were to create a transport system of movement in three dimensional space, it is likely that it would be based on the previous one – the flat plane system. This scheme is very similar to the history of mobile phones system development, which uses a similar principle to wired telephones: to place the “box” to your ear, because there is existing infrastructure: hearing, speech organs. It’s the same here, where first of all we consider the fuel and housing infrastructure. When planning to build transport infrastructure in any city you need to understand how this city operates, its organs of speech, hearing, its waste disposal system. After that, natural routes of movement of people appear and this then forms a road. One might fantasise about a suspended road over the VDNKh exhibition park, but it wouldn’t work, because such road would be unnatural.

In my opinion, moving in a plane is inefficient. It is perfectly illustrated by the ants and bees; they just like people are forming the social communities. In this case the ants move in the plane and their habitat is 1 kilometer, and bees have volumetric system of movement, their habitat is 300 kilometers. That says it all.

In my opinion, moving along a plane is inefficient. This is perfectly illustrated by ants and bees; they form social communities just like people. In this case the ants move in a plane and their home range measures 1 square kilometre, while bees have a volumetric system of movement, their range reaching 300 square kilometres. That says it all. The possibility of organising an effective transport system grows significantly thanks to the use of a volumetric system of movement. The prevalence of planar movement arises naturally from basic things: the force of gravity and our inability to rise up into the air. But now the technology is already on such a level of development, that we can try to create a system in which we will move in space and not across the plane. The same thing happened with phones: previously we called wherever the wire led, and now we’re going to where the road goes. We need to create roadless transport, which can move in space. This is “Freedom 2.0”. If you can move around in space from point A to point B on several levels – that would be the most natural way to move. The sky consists of several levels – echelons – levels of moving, while the road is just one level – and there’s a traffic jam. You don’t need to go around the city, you can fly over it.

Courtesy of Vladimir Pirozhkov

Courtesy of Vladimir Pirozhkov

You are putting in doubt the future of cars for the roads? How long will the concept of road cars exist? What will happen to the contemporary concept cars, such as unmanned vehicles?

I realised at some point, like many other professional designers who have been engaged in the business of inventing new technologies for a long time, the absurdity of the car, because we have been building cars and developing the same piece of metal which was created by Daimler and Benz for the last 100 years, giving it many different forms. I think it’s a purposeless modernisation of previous achievements. But the idea of the car for road travel will last for some time, as heavy loads are still very hard to tear away from the ground. Until we will invent antigravity or something like that.

Unmanned vehicles are very promising, because “Why do we need a carriage driver, if the horse knows where to go?” The level of safety in using robotic systems for transportation is 1,000 times higher. I believe that heavy freight can be fully replaced with unmanned technology, and this will form self-​adaptive infrastructure. From the urbanist point of view, to improve the quality of life in the city, we must deal with human things. I believe that the work of the Metro driver is not human. This task can easily be handled by a robot. Human work should lead us towards the development of our intellectual abilities.

Professionals understand design not simply as a way of working with form and colour, but as a tool of a much higher abstract level. How can a designer be involved in the process of improving the quality of the urban environment? How must he act in a system where there are also urban planners, architects and urbanists? What role in this process can and should a designer play?

In the first place, for really young designers – it’s about shape and colour. Experienced professionals can already deal with this and want to think somehow broader. Integrating into the existing system is very difficult all over the world, not only in Russia. Moscow is difficult in this sense. If you know how to and want to set up, for example, a system of comfortable bus stops, you will need to go through all the paper arrangements dealing with the transport department of the Moscow government, and in the end you will not succeed. Because you just don’t have access to the people who make the decisions. They have already made all the decisions before and have already found the money for it. A designer, for example, could offer to review the trolleybus transport system. Now trolleys are unreasonably large and occupy 50 square metres of city space, taking into account safety distances from other vehicles and turning space, and they typically carry a mere 1 or 2 people. The huge size of the trolleybus is a echo of the USSR. The potential size of the trolleybus or wireless electrobus comes under the jurisdiction of the factory’s senior manager. You know his name and are forced to communicate with him in person. But in the end the potential decision would be to replace the huge trolley buses with compact electrobuses, which are widely represented in the foreign market. Here we have no place for industrial design anymore. When a country doesn’t have competitive industry, neither does it have industrial design. When industry develops again, then this conversation would be relevant and the designers will become an essential part of industry. In my unbiased opinion, Moscow needs to be decentralised, we need to make a few city centres, creating comfortable pedestrian zones – magnets, to stop people using a single central point for walking. These areas have to compete among themselves. Such “sub-​cities” might have their own special centres, for example, railway stations could be transformed into cultural hubs, as all traffic in such cities is concentrated there. We need to implement the concept of cultural polycentricism, we can not reduce everything to Red Square.

Courtesy of Vladimir Pirozhkov

Courtesy of Vladimir Pirozhkov

Let us suppose the concept of 3D transport – a flying car – has become dominant, how do you think this would change the driving culture in general? Will it development in line with the cult of the car – the car as a “second home”, a unique space, such it was in the USA in the 1960s?

A very important point here, which only few people are enough courageous to talk about, there is still the Northern Sea Route, where we have no transport infrastructure at all. There will be very crowded soon, because of the rapidly melting Arctic snow and “winter roads”, turning land into a swamp. It is impossible to drive there, you need to fly. This is still our territory and our jurisdiction. Still ours… 3D transport and self-​efficent households form the strategy of monitoring and developing our own territory. And not ply ours.. We can get a very competitive product from it.

There would be fundamental changes, things that will fundamentally change the world. Nowadays, the car is a real extra room in your apartment. This is your living space, in which you move from home to office. Suppose 3D transport could transfer a part of your home, a whole room, for instance. Let’s assume that this is a modular room, so we can fly back and move a second room. So you can live wherever you want. And here we go to a new urban level. This is the so-​called self-​sufficient household. Your home may be completely self-​sufficient and work on the self-​energy or solar or underground energy sources and could be located wherever you want. Such developments already exist. They will be produced on a mass scale – it is only a question of time. In 30 years, the world will have approximately 10 billion people and 70% of them will live in cities, with 50 % of the population forming a middle class. We will need vast natural resources for the maintenance of so many people. Now we have begun work on small motors to process our household waste. So many people requires so much energy. If we can create such things, then we will be able to live and survive in those vast areas of our country that we have not yet researched and inhabited. If we don’t do that, these territories will be developed by someone else. 3D transport allows us to reach any point on the globe, unlike the 2D form. This will be the next level of freedom, which we are so enamoured of! A very important point here, which only a few people are courageous enough to make, is that we still have the Northern Sea Route, where we have no transport infrastructure at all. This will be very crowded soon, because of the rapidly melting Arctic ice opening up the sea lanes and turning existing northern road systems into swampland. It is impossible to drive there, you need to fly. This is still our territory and our jurisdiction. Still ours… 3D transport and self-​efficient households provide the strategy for monitoring and developing our own territory. And not only ours.. We can get a very competitive product out of this. I think now we need to look very carefully at certain promising developments that could make Russia competitive with the other countries that are moving toward global leadership. And what about design? It could be done beautifully. Trying from the very beginning. So that OUR children will live better in OUR land than ourselves!

acyclovir dose levitra online lexapro what is tamoxifen used for what is azithromycin for escitalopram effets secondaires buy cialis tamoxifen lawsuits ciprofloxacin coverage daily cialis generic cialis cialis cheap generic lexapro ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg what is cialis what is lexapro used for cipro for uti side effects of ciprofloxacin 500 mg what is viagra levitra 20 mg cost walmart ciprofloxacin nebenwirkungen levitra 20 mg von bayer tamoxifen interaction generic cialis at walmart lexapro vs celexa what is ciprofloxacin how does viagra work what is escitalopram antibiotic ciprofloxacin azithromycin side effects cyalis escitalopram 10 mg para que sirve ciprofloxacin 500 mg tabletten ciprofloxacin 500mg side effects of azithromycin 250 mg levitra 20mg cost per pill viagra sans ordonnance azithromycin 250mg tablets 6 pack herbal viagra zithromax dosage finasteride medication cialis patent expiration date extended revatio vs viagra cialis coupons printable cialis for sale zovirax for cold sores lexapro manufacturer website cheap viagra ciprofloxacin 500mg tablets levitra 20mg cialis pharmacy prices viagra natural azithromycin viagra tablets azithromycin cost over the counter viagra cialis testimonials cipro drug class levitra rezeptfrei deutschland viagra tablet ciprofloxacin uses acyclovir 800mg natural viagra what is cipro used for finasteride results viagra substitute cialis 30 day trial coupon lexapro side effects ciprofloxacin 250 mg cipro antibiotic ciprofloxacin 500 mg for urinary tract infection women viagra lexapro generic ciprofloxacin spc tamoxifen therapy celexa vs lexapro cialis coupon print acyclovir side effects erectile dysfunction cialis azithromycine eg 500 mg bijsluiter buy generic levitra ciprofloxacin side effects in women cialis website how to wean off lexapro cialis daily azithromycin pregnancy weaning off lexapro ciprofloxacin drops what does finasteride do effects of stopping finasteride finasteride 200 cialis coupon buy generic viagra cialis for men finasteride reviews acyclovir for shingles buy viagra online finasteride long term effects utilisation viagra acyclovir medication what is tamoxifen cialis price levitra lexapro 5mg buying viagra free viagra pfizer viagra viagra vs cialis is tamoxifen chemotherapy escitalopram 20 mg cipro 500 stopping lexapro viagra wiki propecia side effects viagra cialis coupons azithromycine 250 mg tamoxifen cost cheap cialis lexapro bula zovirax ointment acyclovir 800 mg 5 times a day generic for cialis levitra without a doctor prescription escitalopram oxalate lexapro and weight loss finasteride effets secondaires tamoxifen side effects generic levitra cialis canadian pharmacy thuoc azithromycin ciprofloxacin dosage viagra generico ciprofloxacin hcl viagra coupon price cialis finasteride 5mg viagra tesco lexapro medication cialis on line azithromycin class levitra dosage what is lexapro for tamoxifen side effects in women over 55 cialis side effects levitra prices finasteride 5 mg tab how long does viagra last azithromycin pediatric dosing finasteride side effects in men viagra 100mg tablets retail price is ciprofloxacin a penicillin viagra on line no prec lexapro coupons does lexapro cause weight gain ciprofloxacin for dogs cialis coupon zovirax how does acyclovir work what is ciprofloxacin prescribed for generic viagra cialis coupons from manufacturer viagra side effects cialis patent expiration viagra without a doctor prescription usa cipro antibiotics viagra medicine zithromax viagra vs cialis vs levitra azithromycin drug class viagra samples azithromycin 500 erfahrungen cialis samples levitra coupon cipro side effects lexapro for anxiety levitra vs viagra zithromax z-​pak lexapro overdose cipro dosage what does azithromycin treat ciprofloxacin 500 acyclovir ointment generic cialis tadalafil viagra costs azithromycin tablet ciprofloxacin hydrochloride ophthalmic is azithromycin penicillin acyclovir 400mg levitra erfahrungen azithromycin pregnancy category lexapro side effects men azithromycin three times a week cialis vs viagra effects of stopping lexapro suddenly acyclovir vs valacyclovir acyclovir ointment 5 what is acyclovir viagra on line lexapro para que sirve viagra pills viagra alternatives viagra for sale uk cialis tadalafil viagra coupons is azithromycin viamedic cialis what is finasteride used for finasteride efectos secundarios viagra 100 mg lexapro vs wellbutrin viagra pill vardenafil vs viagra cipro side effects in elderly azithromycin uses viagra for men cialis generic ciprofloxacin used for cialis pricing how to take cialis lexapro withdrawal symptoms sophia viagra what is azithromycin used for female viagra viagra for sale free cialis cialis 20 mg viagra wikipedia cialis pills cialis prices levitra 10 mg prezzo buy levitra cealis canada viagra canadian cialis cialis savings card escitalopram 10mg escitalopram side effects cialis generic availability viagra sex acyclovir lexapro dosage side effects of lexapro zoloft vs lexapro viagra 50mg ciprofloxacin 500mg antibiotics viagra nebenwirkungen azithromycin for pneumonia tamoxifen and weight gain cialis copay card where to buy viagra acyclovir cream pfizer viagra coupons from pfizer cialis for bph side effects of viagra zovirax dosage cialis pills for sale ciprofloxacin dosierung what works better than viagra levitra 20 mg lowest cialis prices what does ciprofloxacin treat cheap levitra lexapro generic name viagra bestellen viagra online cialis medication tamoxifen nebenwirkungen finasteride for hair loss what infections does ciprofloxacin treat order viagra cialis patent expiration 2017 tamoxifen langzeitfolgen generic viagra 100mg azithromycin and alcohol cialis 30 day sample cialis discount viagra activate cialis trial propecia buy viagra lexapro and weight gain in women cialis 20mg directions what is acyclovir used for cipro dangers when will cialis go generic viagra cost cialis dosage cialis dosage strengths lexapro weight gain what is acyclovir for viagra price tamoxifen side effects in women azithromycine finasteride 5mg side effects ciprofloxacin drug class discount viagra acyclovir for cold sores acyclovir 200mg lexapro 20mg cipro uses cialis sample generic for lexapro lexapro 10mg best price viagra wholesale cialis azithromycin 500mg equipe argentine viagra lexapro benefits for women cialis generic tadalafil cialis for daily use what is cipro online cialis how much does cialis cost lexapro dosing viagra en ligne livraison 24h ciprofloxacin bnf side effects of azithromycin levitra generic how long for azithromycin to take effect side effects of lexapro 10 mg finasteride 5mg side effects mayo clinic cialis 5mg what is finasteride azithromycin 250mg cipro and tendonitis lexapro and weight gain tamoxifen citrate side effects of acyclovir cialis coupon 20 mg canadian viagra side effects of ciprofloxacin viagra receptfritt azithromycin coverage lexapro and wellbutrin combination therapy how does lexapro work azithromycin without a doctor’s prescription ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg side effects finasteride permanent side effects azithromycin dosage viagra soft azithromycin 250 mg treatment finasteride dosage cialis otc zithromax 500 mg finasteride side effects azithromycin liquid cialis canada tamoxifen bijwerkingen viagra from canada viagra vs cialis vs levitra ciprofloxacin dose acyclovir 400 mg ciprofloxacin eye drops viagra alternative lexapro side effects in men zovirax cream sex viagra for women lexapro withdrawal cialis samples overnight tamoxifen and bone pain viagra effects side effects of finasteride 5mg escitalopram nebenwirkungen what does viagra do liquid cialis generic levitra vardenafil 20mg escitalopram what is ciprofloxacin used for viagra uk what is azithromycin viagra dosage ciprofloxacin class how does cialis work zovirax pills cialis free trial azithromycin 5 day dose pack zithromax antibiotic cialis cost finasteride tablets azithromycin 500 mg cialis professional levitra bayer 20mg meilleur prix lexapro vs zoloft viagra generic viagra without a doctor prescription how to wean off lexapro without withdrawals viagra ohne rezept auf rechnung common side effects of ciprofloxacin 500 mg cialis from canada lexapro side effects in women is lexapro a controlled substance 9 levitra at walmart acyclovir dosage for cold sores side effects lexapro side effects of cialis cost of viagra finasteride vs dutasteride viagra single packs cialis dosage recommendations cialis effects how to use viagra finasteride 5mg tab canada cialis cialis 5 mg azithromycin for uti acyclovir dosage cialis vs viagra ciprofloxacin 500mg antibiotics side effects cialis 20mg how long for lexapro to work side effects of lexapro in women viagra 100mg levitra prezzo in farmacia azithromycin medscape ciprofloxacin hydrochloride wellbutrin and lexapro azithromycin for strep throat what bacteria does ciprofloxacin kill cost of cialis side effects of tamoxifen what is cipro usually prescribed for cialis 5mg daily viagra canada viagra prices buy cialis online azithromycin vs erythromycin nolvadex azithromycin eye drops cialis or viagra cialis without a doctor’s prescription ciprofloxacin 500 mg cialis coupons 2017 cialas buy levitra online ciprofloxacin side effects what does ciprofloxacin 500mg treat cilias ciprofloxacin viagra kaufen ciprofloxacin ophthalmic solution withdrawal from lexapro first few days on lexapro cialis for women vardenafil 20mg finasteride 5 mg tamoxifen and foods to avoid viagra cialis acyclovir 800 mg viagra vs cialis acyclovir 800 mg for shingles finasteride and enlarged prostate post finasteride syndrome side effects of finasteride ciprofloxacin side effects after age 60 lexapro dosages finasteride 1mg cialis voucher cialis online what is lexapro online viagra lexapro reviews cialis 10 mg tamoxifen cialis alternative levitra 20 mg precio farmacia azithromycin 500 azithromycin 250 mg how to get off lexapro ciprofloxacin 250mg viagra pillen kruidvat azithromycin 250 viagra for women cialis levitra coupons escitalopram 10 mg viagra ohne rezept aus deutschland lexapro 10 mg discount cialis cialis reviews azithromycin tablets ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg tab finasteride for women azithromycin z pak viagra 100 acyclovir dosing levitra vs viagra for hardness cipro finasteride hair loss levitra vs viagra