Perm Masterplan, 2008-2010, KCAP Architects&Planners

Urbanized Landscape

An interview with Kees Christiaanse on the future of urbanisation by Giulio Margheri

Read intro

An interview with Kees Christiaanse

An interview by Giulio Margheri

Kees Christiaanse (1953) is a Dutch architect, founder and partner of the office KCAP Kees Christiaanse Architects & Planners. He studied architecture and urban planning at the TU Delft.

From 1980 until 1989 he worked for OMA, Office of Metropolitan Architecture in Rotterdam, becoming a partner in 1983.

In 1989 Kees Christiaanse founded his own office in Rotterdam: KCAP, since 2002, which expanded to Zurich and Shanghai. KCAP Zurich was established in 2006 after winning two international design competitions in Zurich. KCAP Shanghai was established in 2011, and supports KCAP’s growing portfolio in China.

During the last 20 years KCAP has established itself as one of the leading international practices in the fields of architecture and urbanism.

From 1996 until 2003 Kees Christiaanse taught architecture and urban planning at TU Berlin. Since 2003 he is professor at the ETH in Zurich.

In 2009 Kees Christiaanse was curator of the International Architecture Biennale Rotterdam entitled “Open City. Designing Coexistence” where he raised the question how can architects and urbanists make realistic contributions to the sustainable quality of the urban condition.

In 2011 ETH opened his branch in Singapore, since that moment Kees Christiaanse is Programme Leader of the Future Cities Laboratory (FCL) which is a trans disciplinary research centre focused on diverse themes related to future cities and environmental sustainability.
Hide intro

Mr Christiaanse, during interviews you often quote Jane Jacobs, as well as in “The open city and its Enemies” where she is used as a key figure to explain the Open City ” the city of Jane Jacobs, whose image assumes clearly defined contours in her sizeable oeuvre, as an Open City where coexistence thrives and that extends far beyond Greenwich Village, is she still actual? How is she relevant for urban scale projects?

I quote her often not because I know her books deeply, but because I met her in person a couple of times, and when we were talking we were on the same level. I don’t consider the book she wrote in 1960 “The death and life of the great American cities, as containing everything that has been developed in urban theory between then and now, but it is definitely an important book covering many very actual issues of urbanism.

How can her work, based mostly on the human scale be relevant for big urban planning?

She wrote about extremely practical things and she based her work on empirical observation. In my opinion when she started to conceive a theory, as for example in her book “The economy of cities” she is less interesting. I appreciate the real and concrete set of observations of how people behave in the cities. And I think her observations don’t refer only to the human scale but are also applicable to the scale of the whole city.

For instance the principle of “Open City” where the city has the maximum of permeability, transparency and accessibility of street crossings is a principle that is valid on the small scale or on the large scale.

How did your personal interest in combining two scales, the small human, and the large urban scale develop? What fascinated you about cities?

I used to work on the large scale from the beginning because I’m Dutch and we have been working in “land winning” for ages. We have some good examples of early work in new towns like Lelystad and Almere. In the tradition of Dutch urbanism, large scale planning is frequently related to the tradition of land fill. Because of all these efforts to gain new land, the Netherlands is a very compact and collective society in which there is a lot of collaboration. The state also is willing for the public development of collective activities.

I remember around 1970 I saw a booklet “In search of Living” which illustrated the land of the Netherlands as a kind of fiction, presenting for example monorails and catamarans. This fascinated me, and I decided to study architecture. I ‘ve always been interested in this two different scales large and small at the same time.

Remon Rijper /

Remon Rijper /​flickr​.com

Did the experience at OMA influence your approach towards the urban scale?

I was a founding member of OMA in Rotterdam and at the beginning we got mainly urban projects, so I definitely started to approach this scale right from the beginning of my career. There was interaction between those who were designing the architectural projects and the urban scale projects. The competition for the park de la Villette was very important in that sense because it was one of the first concepts dealing with the unpredictability of an uncertain future. We had to design a structure that had to adapt to many circumstances. This was the beginning, and I’ve been doing it ever since. When I opened my office in Rotterdam I did mainly large urban scale design competitions, and I won some of them, for example HafenCity in Hamburg. Then, in a certain moment of your career, you are the “masterplanner”, not anymore the architect, although I sometimes do architectural projects. I think you cannot do urban design if you are not doing building design.

When you opened your office in Zurich you said in an interview: “You cannot move too many times in your life […] it is realistic to say that I will spend the rest of my professional life in Switzerland.” What kind of tendency brought you to Singapore?

This is the paradox of the people who deal with sustainable urbanism like I’m doing, where you are supposed to be reducing mobility, but then I fly often all over the world to sell my ideas and to help cities to develop in the right directions. Very strange situation I would say.

This is the paradox of the people who deal with sustainable urbanism like I’m doing, where you suppose to reduce mobility, but then I fly often all over the world to sell my ideas and to help cities developing in the right directions

It is an experiment to work in Singapore; it was a very interesting project from the beginning. Singapore decided to become the knowledge out of Asia, and because they have a flourishing economic situation, they are collaborating with good universities, which come here bringing very talented people and create a sort of incubator situation.

For me it is very important to have a base, from which I can move all around; and my base is Zurich. Starting this new experience in Singapore means that I need to delegate many tasks of my offices, so it also means I cannot do it for so long. I have also a little office in Shanghai but they are coordinating the projects in China. The design part is developed in Europe.

How is the Laboratory in Singapore organized?

It is a branch of the ETH in Zurich, but the main difference is that it is not a school but a Research institute. We have 100 researchers, half of them are PhD students, the other half are post doctoral researchers.

At the Laboratory Future Cities in Singapore you are dealing with future urbanism everyday, what kind of research have you been developing?

The Singapore government expected big masterplanning from us for Singapore, but we decided to approach the future in a different way. Our research works on very different levels, different scales, for example slums study, large-​scale projects, ecology, water projects and traffic simulation. We do urban scale projects like the masterplan of a large region around Singapore, which include the islands of Indonesia and Malaysia, but on the contrary we investigate also very small technical aspects. For example we are currently exploring the possibility of replacing steel reinforcements with a bamboo composite material due to corrosion and cost of steel inside reinforced concrete structures. For another research project we develop Kampong house prototypes for neighbourhoods in South East Asia. We are doing many things.

Nowadays people are moving into urbanised areas and we have already reached the point where more people live in cities than in rural areas, how will it shape the future?

Many people live in an urbanized landscape, but it doesn’t mean they live in dense cities. What I consider very important is the intermediate condition between the rural and the urban: the Desa-​Kota

There are many types of urbanisation; we always say that the future will be in an urbanized area. Many people live in an urbanised landscape, but it doesn’t mean they live in dense cities. What I consider very important is the intermediate condition between the rural and the urban: the Desa Kota. The Desa Kota is the rural area or town located in between agricultural or industrial production and the city. For instance, the area in the north of Italy which goes from Udine until Genova. It is a very good example, an endless city and industrialised landscape, that you can’t call one city. It is a kind of galaxy made out of towns, villages and cities with different dimensions. All of them can only exist because they are part of this network. I consider the European urban condition with the existence of hundreds of middlesized cities that lay in the landscape to be a positive example. The cities are part of a network and the city itself became important as a large whole.

Concerning the urbanisation I think there will be four conditions: the city, the Desa Kota, the industrial agriculture and the wilderness. These four conditions will be all strongly related and they merge into one another. It is not easy to separate them.

City as an egg / Based on a drawing of Cedric Price

City as an egg /​Based on a drawing of Cedric Price

You just described one of these four conditions, could you tell something more about the others?

Speaking about the city, I do not believe that the compact city is the only module. The compact city is a type that many planners propagate because of sustainability. The polycentric-​urbanised landscape will be increasing its importance because you can combine residential, production and agriculture in the landscape. It needs much more energy and money compared with a compact city, in that sense people who support the compact city are right, but the human behaviour is opposite to that.

Cedric Price gave the definition of the city using eggs as a metaphor. During the medieval time the city was a boiled egg because it had a defined border built in form of walls. In the XVIII and XIX centuries the egg was fried because the walls were removed and they didn’t have a defined border anymore. Nowadays I consider the city as a scrambled egg with many centralities. It is inevitable.

The European cities can be seen as a network of many eggs laying in an urbanised landscape.

Then of course you will have everywhere large scale compound development; large scale monofunctional areas, for example huge hospitals, gigantic airports, agricultural complexes like the big green houses in the Netherlands.

I think almost everything will be accessible and the real wilderness will be very rare.

Speaking about Russia, I know that with your office you are developing projects in two completely different situations, Moscow that is growing quickly, and Perm where there is a completely different trend. How do you approach these two completely different tasks?

Moscow in its attractive power is much more a Chinese city than a European city. It is growing really fast and it became the attraction of the whole Russia. It is because of an extreme organisation of the country that makes it possible to have this kind of situation. In Europe only Paris and London are similar. Many other cities like Berlin are stable and they have their own dimension. In Moscow we didn’t do the whole masterplanning but only a project.

I consider the European urban condition with the existence of hundreds of middle sized cities that lay in the landscape to be a positive example. The cities are part of a network and the city itself became important as a large whole

In Perm for completely different reasons there is a very complex situation too. Perm is a city that became important during the Second World War when many factories moved there to defend them against the Nazi invasion. In the last decades, after the boom of post soviet era, Perm became victim of an uncontrolled and wild development.

They want to create an exemplary city and they visited many European cities like Hamburg and Bilbao. There was a whole process of renovation of the city working at the same time on the urbanism and political reform but also on cultural and social development.

The actual situation of Perm is that it doesn’t grow as a population, but the buildings are growing. People abandon the old buildings and build new buildings somewhere else. The result is an enormous sprawl, because they didn’t replace the old buildings, they just leave them behind. It is a very difficult situation, because none of the city networks work anymore. There is no public transport, everybody uses the car, the pipes are so long and the rents are completely out of balance. What we proposed is to consolidate the buildings and create densification inside the built zone, not allowing construction out of the built part. We create a contour within which to densify and a green contour where you are not allowed to build at all. It is a plan in strong contrast with the interest of the investors and the landlords; this is the reason why the developer started a campaign against the project. They sabotaged our masterplan and proposed a different one. Now our project is frozen and I don’t know what will happen.

Discussing your work and academic experience, we spoke about many places and situations. Do you have general predictions about the practice of urban planning in the future?

Concerning the Asian cities the only opportunity for developing the megacities is to create multiples centres as already is happening, but I don’t consider that established by a network of cities. The agenda for Europe now is that the cities are growing very slowly. It means the city governments are focusing their attention on strategy and flexibility; they’ve stopped making master-​­‐plans that control everything and are based on growth. At the same they are developing small projects, which are connected with the existing overall structure like the Bilbao waterfront or the docklands in London. I consider the European urban condition established by a network of cities a good model for the future.

azithromycin 500 cialis vs viagra escitalopram 10mg acyclovir dosage for cold sores vardenafil 20mg viagra ohne rezept auf rechnung zovirax pills cilias lexapro benefits for women ciprofloxacin 500mg azithromycin 250 mg treatment cialis pills for sale viagra coupon generic cialis tadalafil what is acyclovir used for finasteride efectos secundarios viagra tablet thuoc azithromycin ciprofloxacin ophthalmic solution azithromycin pregnancy category viagra samples viagra 50mg ciprofloxacin side effects lexapro dosages cialis coupon viagra receptfritt levitra dosage canadian viagra viagra generic cialis canada cialis canadian pharmacy generic cialis at walmart finasteride tablets viagra coupons cialis price escitalopram side effects tamoxifen lawsuits does lexapro cause weight gain ciprofloxacin bnf herbal viagra acyclovir 800 mg 5 times a day cealis liquid cialis lexapro manufacturer website how does lexapro work azithromycin dosage what is escitalopram lexapro 10mg lexapro for anxiety tamoxifen and foods to avoid acyclovir 400 mg cialis dosage recommendations free viagra equipe argentine viagra cialis copay card zovirax ointment effects of stopping lexapro suddenly cialis coupons side effects of tamoxifen azithromycin tablets viagra side effects ciprofloxacin dosage how to get off lexapro post finasteride syndrome azithromycin z pak azithromycin side effects azithromycin 250mg tablets 6 pack levitra online ciprofloxacin 500mg antibiotics lexapro reviews azithromycine eg 500 mg bijsluiter viagra natural what does azithromycin treat is tamoxifen chemotherapy side effects of lexapro 10 mg cialis trial azithromycine 250 mg tamoxifen and weight gain viagra cialis azithromycin uses tamoxifen nebenwirkungen viagra nebenwirkungen cialis savings card cialis on line cialis testimonials ciprofloxacin 500 mg tabletten cialis coupons printable viagra what is ciprofloxacin used for viagra tablets generic lexapro what works better than viagra is lexapro a controlled substance acyclovir cream zovirax what is azithromycin used for cipro drug class lexapro bula levitra vs viagra cipro utilisation viagra cialis 20mg viagra 100mg tablets retail price viagra cost cheap viagra wholesale cialis cialis 20 mg ciprofloxacin hydrochloride how much does cialis cost lowest cialis prices azithromycin for strep throat cialis free trial escitalopram sex viagra for women levitra 20mg viagra price tamoxifen bijwerkingen cialis effects escitalopram nebenwirkungen ciprofloxacin spc side effects of ciprofloxacin 500 mg cialis otc cialis dosage strengths cialis cheap viagra wikipedia zovirax dosage generic viagra 100mg cialis prices first few days on lexapro ciprofloxacin 500 levitra azithromycin 250 mg cipro dangers acyclovir dosage what is acyclovir for buy levitra online side effects of azithromycin 250 mg lexapro generic zithromax tamoxifen side effects lexapro lexapro side effects in women ciprofloxacin coverage escitalopram 10 mg lexapro 5mg cialis samples viagra from canada azithromycin 500 erfahrungen cialis discount levitra vs viagra for hardness finasteride reviews azithromycin medscape levitra coupon levitra prices zithromax z-​pak ciprofloxacin dosierung ciprofloxacin for dogs ciprofloxacin uses where to buy viagra viagra 100mg how long for azithromycin to take effect cialis azithromycin acyclovir dosing ciprofloxacin used for viagra vs cialis azithromycin cost ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg tab what is cipro zithromax antibiotic finasteride vs dutasteride viagra effects cialis or viagra azithromycin and alcohol viagra costs what is tamoxifen stopping lexapro levitra rezeptfrei deutschland finasteride side effects in men wellbutrin and lexapro azithromycin three times a week acyclovir 400mg azithromycin 250mg azithromycin drug class lexapro overdose zoloft vs lexapro propecia what is viagra cipro side effects cialis professional finasteride medication cialis vs viagra viagra prices levitra bayer 20mg meilleur prix cost of viagra cialis coupons 2017 lexapro para que sirve finasteride results azithromycin 500mg tamoxifen side effects in women over 55 buy viagra online levitra erfahrungen azithromycin for pneumonia tamoxifen citrate viagra substitute cialis for bph side effects of acyclovir cialis patent expiration 2017 tamoxifen side effects in women cialis 30 day trial coupon cipro 500 cialis dosage azithromycin coverage acyclovir vs valacyclovir finasteride side effects pfizer viagra coupons from pfizer ciprofloxacin drops cialis 30 day sample cialis tadalafil cialis website viagra pill women viagra viagra for sale viagra alternative viagra sans ordonnance ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg side effects acyclovir for shingles what is lexapro used for tamoxifen therapy cialis coupons from manufacturer azithromycin eye drops levitra 20 mg von bayer viagra wiki azithromycin for uti online cialis how does viagra work lexapro withdrawal viagra 100 finasteride for hair loss cialis 10 mg viagra 100 mg cialis pills finasteride 5 mg generic for lexapro canadian cialis antibiotic ciprofloxacin viagra on line cialis for sale price cialis finasteride dosage lexapro coupons ciprofloxacin 250 mg cialis side effects ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg acyclovir 200mg over the counter viagra best price viagra cialis reviews ciprofloxacin drug class viagra tesco cialis voucher cialis cost lexapro dosing finasteride 5mg side effects mayo clinic viagra vs cialis vs levitra cialis samples overnight pfizer viagra lexapro vs zoloft when will cialis go generic azithromycin class lexapro and weight loss acyclovir medication azithromycin pediatric dosing buy generic levitra side effects of cialis lexapro generic name viagra medicine cialis alternative cipro dosage viagra without a doctor prescription cialis pricing what is finasteride azithromycin tablet ciprofloxacin class what is ciprofloxacin prescribed for cialis medication cipro uses viagra alternatives 9 levitra at walmart lexapro vs wellbutrin acyclovir 800 mg zovirax cream side effects of ciprofloxacin propecia side effects azithromycin liquid acyclovir for cold sores ciprofloxacin 500 mg for urinary tract infection finasteride 5 mg tab azithromycin vs erythromycin cipro for uti ciprofloxacin nebenwirkungen acyclovir ointment how to take cialis viagra vs cialis vs levitra viagra for men side effects of viagra ciprofloxacin 500 mg side effects of lexapro in women what bacteria does ciprofloxacin kill levitra 20mg cost per pill levitra coupons cialis daily lexapro side effects men cialis 5 mg what is ciprofloxacin ciprofloxacin hcl acyclovir dose is azithromycin penicillin how to wean off lexapro without withdrawals ciprofloxacin side effects after age 60 how to wean off lexapro what is lexapro for generic levitra vardenafil 20mg ciprofloxacin eye drops finasteride for women cheap cialis what does finasteride do acyclovir ointment 5 viagra kaufen zovirax for cold sores zithromax dosage common side effects of ciprofloxacin 500 mg lexapro 20mg acyclovir ciprofloxacin 500mg tablets viagra en ligne livraison 24h lexapro side effects in men finasteride and enlarged prostate how does cialis work levitra vs viagra lexapro withdrawal symptoms cialis for women viagra for sale uk viagra activate viagra ohne rezept aus deutschland lexapro side effects viagra soft levitra 20 mg precio farmacia ciprofloxacin hydrochloride ophthalmic cialis online ciprofloxacin 500mg antibiotics side effects canada viagra ciprofloxacin dose azithromycin without a doctor’s prescription cialis without a doctor’s prescription viagra for women lexapro and weight gain viamedic cialis cyalis viagra pills is azithromycin generic viagra levitra without a doctor prescription cialis 20mg directions levitra 20 mg cost walmart viagra bestellen effects of stopping finasteride daily cialis viagra online viagra single packs what infections does ciprofloxacin treat azithromycin 250 escitalopram 10 mg para que sirve levitra prezzo in farmacia 200 cialis coupon cialis pharmacy prices how to use viagra viagra without a doctor prescription usa what does ciprofloxacin treat free cialis how does acyclovir work order viagra finasteride cipro and tendonitis lexapro weight gain finasteride hair loss side effects of finasteride 5mg acyclovir side effects finasteride 5mg female viagra sophia viagra lexapro vs celexa how long does viagra last azithromycin 500 mg what is cipro usually prescribed for cialis coupon 20 mg buy cialis ciprofloxacin side effects in women viagra canada how long for lexapro to work cialis from canada viagra generico buying viagra tamoxifen langzeitfolgen azithromycin 5 day dose pack escitalopram effets secondaires nolvadex what is lexapro discount viagra what is azithromycin for ciprofloxacin 250mg tamoxifen interaction cialis for daily use azithromycine cost of cialis viagra dosage cialis 5mg lexapro and weight gain in women cialis generic availability lexapro dosage vardenafil vs viagra cipro antibiotics tamoxifen and bone pain tamoxifen side effects lexapro 10 mg viagra on line no prec what is acyclovir withdrawal from lexapro what is cialis finasteride effets secondaires lexapro and wellbutrin combination therapy canada cialis cialis for men generic for cialis buy cialis online levitra 10 mg prezzo cialis coupon print levitra 20 mg celexa vs lexapro finasteride long term effects escitalopram oxalate viagra sex cipro antibiotic viagra pillen kruidvat side effects of azithromycin lexapro finasteride permanent side effects escitalopram 20 mg what is azithromycin cialis 5mg daily viagra uk cialis generic finasteride 5mg tab levitra generic cialas discount cialis viagra vs cialis lexapro medication erectile dysfunction cialis buy levitra acyclovir 800 mg for shingles tamoxifen cost cipro side effects in elderly finasteride 1mg ciprofloxacin side effects of finasteride azithromycin pregnancy generic levitra cialis generic tadalafil acyclovir 800mg weaning off lexapro finasteride 5mg side effects what does viagra do generic cialis what is cipro used for side effects of lexapro cheap levitra revatio vs viagra natural viagra zithromax 500 mg what does ciprofloxacin 500mg treat cialis patent expiration online viagra what is tamoxifen used for what is finasteride used for buy viagra buy generic viagra cialis sample cialis patent expiration date extended is ciprofloxacin a penicillin