The Age of Fragmentation

Eugen Kosyk’s interview with Dr. Martin van Creveld, one of the world’s leading experts on military history and strategy

Read intro

An interview with Martin van Creveld

An interview by Eugen Kosyk

Some of the theoretical developments of the past and predictions about the future world order are coming true today. The state apparatus is too rigid and inert to meet the needs of citizens. Most of its institutions have ceased to function at the appropriate level: the army is no longer needed for war, the police does not protect citizens, and pensions do not ensure well-being.

Historian and theorist Dr. Martin van Creveld, professor emeritus of the Hebrew University, Jerusalem, is one of the world's leading experts on military history and strategy. He has written twenty five books on various aspects of strategy, military history, the history of the state, and feminism. Two more books, dealing with the history of equality and of conscience respectively, are forthcoming. In this interview, he shared some of his original thoughts on the future of the state and governance.
Hide intro

Today we see that mistrust of the state is growing. Can technology change this situation in future?

Over the last fifty years or so two technologies have been most successful and powerful in changing the world: transportation and communication. What they have in common is that they cross national borders. In some ways they make those borders irrelevant. Of course, you can say, as North Korea does, ‘I’m cutting myself from the world, I’m going to do everything on my own.’ However, doing so comes at a very high price. As I wrote in my book, The Rise and Fall of the State, normally the more any country uses the aforesaid technologies, the higher its per capita income is and the higher the standard of living its people enjoy.

But that is not all. Another interesting development is taking place. Certain companies, such as Google, have decided that they no longer need the state. They are going to build their own headquarters at sea in exterritorial waters. As a result they will no longer be subject to the laws of any state.

The technological forces that are pushing for change are very powerful. Some countries will no doubt try to delay their impact, but doing so will almost entail a return to the Stone Age.

Over the last fifty years or so two technologies have been most successful and powerful in changing the world: transportation and communication

What do you think about direct democracy? Where could it lead?

In Switzerland for example, they just had a plebiscite. The Swiss are always complaining about the federal government trying to expand its power. There seems to be a struggle between two opposite tendencies. One, coming from below, points towards more plebiscites and more direct democracy, which could be assisted by electronic technology. The other, coming from the federal governments, points towards centralization. My guess would be that direct democracy is going to win this struggle. And that it will help them become even more successful than they already are.

Can one imagine the future as consisting of something similar to cities-​states as they were in Ancient Greece?

Look at Singapore. Very few countries have been as successful as Singapore in last fifty years. I can hardly think of any; perhaps Israel, but in a different way. That is a smashing success. I will not be surprised if others say ‘look at this, we want to do the same’. We certainly live in an age of fragmentation. In which, in other words, political units, instead of growing larger and larger, will become smaller.

When UN Headquarters was built back in 1948 the organization had about 60 members. Now it has three times as many and there is not enough room for all their flags! Hardly a day passes without some new separatist movement raising its standards. This seems to be the prevailing trend of our age. Because it allows, and hopefully will continue to allow, direct democracy and local government to flourish. On the other hand, since at least some states will not agree to let go of their own free will, this trend may also increase the danger of war; as, for example, happened in the former Yugoslavia.

img 1

During the Middle Ages down to the Renaissance inclusive, much of Europe consisted of city-​states. Some of them formed leagues, such as the Hansa, which were not organized on national lines but around the commercial interest of the ruling classes. Map: The Extent of the Hansa about 1400 /​map: Wikipedia​.org

Can separatist movements work in the opposite direction, causing some countries to become more authoritarian so as to prevent these movements?

To prevent separatism, states will have to become more totalitarian. The question is – can they do it? Will they succeed? I suppose that some will and some will not. This again will raise tensions between those who succeed and those who did not.

How do you see relations between these new governmental entities?

They will look much more like feudal structures than the modern state does. There are many parts of the world where some sort of feudal system prevailed for centuries on end. As the state loses its ability to protect its citizens, they will naturally turn to grandees, great local people who can protect them. In return for that protection they will have to pay in the form of loss of freedom and also in the form of taxes. We are going in that direction. A close analogy is the Roman Empire after about 330 B.C. The external threat joined the one coming from the inside. Many modern countries, Russia included, seem to be in a similar situation today.

Certain companies, such as Google, have decided that they no longer need the state. They are going to build their own headquarters at sea in exterritorial waters 

If the role of cities is changing. What do you think about relations between cities and states in future?

I will give you a very recent example. The other day I read that Tel-​Aviv was going to impose new taxes on its citizens in order to pay for the new civil guard. Some 25 years ago, I gave a talk to a meeting of municipal leaders here in Israel. I told them that, in the future, the rise of terrorism, and even more so people’s fear of its rise, would almost certainly compel cities to set up their own militias, their own police forces, and even their own armies. It was a very unsuccessful meeting and they looked at me as if I were mad. But now it is happening. Many cities and towns feel that state is no longer protecting them the way it should. So they set up their own police forces. Everywhere police forces, including also private police forces, are becoming stronger and acquiring more weapons. The day may come when they can start challenging states. It won’t be half-​surprising.

How could collective security be provided in a fragmented future world, where no one follows the common rules and there are no big ideologies and countries left?

As you know, the Middle Ages were full of wars. I very much doubt whether such a thing as ‘collective security’ will be possible at all. You might even take this point further; you might argue that the whole point of this process is precisely to enable people to go to war against each other again. I think that, in their heart of hearts, many people in advanced countries miss war. They want to fight, but cannot do so owing to the threat posed by nuclear weapons. A new, more fragmented, world might enable them to fight each other again. Ian Morris in his book War! What Is It Good For? wrote that the most important function of the big states, Leviathans, is to make war inside themselves impossible. But not everybody likes that situation.

What will be the main cause of future armed conflict?

Well, the most disruptive force nowadays appears to be ethnic. As we know, in many European countries non-​Europeans are on the rise. In Russia about 28 percent of the population is not Slavic. There thus exists plenty of room for future conflict. Ongoing demographic trends point in the same direction. The Muslims have many more children than the established populations do. These processes will develop at different speed in different countries, generating friction and armed conflict between some of them.

Concerning relations between Slavic and Islamic cultures in Russia. Russia seems to be losing its Slavic allies. The outcome could be ethnic conflicts. What do you think about this situation?

I have written once or twice that what Putin is doing in Ukraine is a tremendous gamble. If it succeeds – OK. But if it does not succeed it may lead to disintegration of the Russian Federation just as the war in Afghanistan contributed very greatly to the disintegration of the Soviet Union. I know that every time I talk about men and women, about gender and about sex, people start sniggering. Yet I am convinced that these factors form a central part of the processes we just discussed. In 1921 – 1922 Russia, having just gone through World War I and the Civil War, was in a terrible mess. Millions of dead, devastation as far as the eye could see. Lenin and his associates wanted to rebuild the country. Not having capital, the one resource they could draw on was unemployed women. So they started building Soviet industry on the blood of Soviet women. As part of the effort, they adopted a certain kind of feminism. In many ways they made women equal with men. Equal in work, marriage, divorce, education, the right to choose a profession, and much more.

img 3

Liberated woman – build up socialism!’ Soviet poster by Strakhov-​Braslavsky, 1926

It worked in the sense that, during the 1930s, women formed a growing percentage of the industrial workforce. Millions of Soviet women went to universities and entered almost all professions. But there was a price to pay. In 1900, the average Russian woman had up to eight children in her lifetime of whom about five reached adulthood. Then the birth rate started falling. A typical Russian family, particularly in towns, came to consist of a husband, a wife, one child and a babushka. However, the decline in fertility was not distributed evenly across the Soviet Union. Some areas suffered much more than others did. The more modern and urban a particular region, the more the birth rate went down. The districts in which it did not go down nearly as much were the outlying Muslim ones, because they were far away and relatively backward. This brought about a change in demographic balance between Slavs and non-​Slavs.

Private police forces are becoming stronger and acquiring more weapons. They may start challenging states

You can find more about this topic in my book ‘The Privileged Sex’. Brezhnev during his last years in power woke up to this problem. He and his successors understood that what they had done was literally going to destroy the Soviet Union. So they tried to put the wheel back. They sent a few women back home and launched a propaganda campaign to make women have more children. However, it was too late. Exactly the same happened in Yugoslavia ten years later. If we ignore these problems, we are going to miss a very important part of the story.

In one of your interviews, you said that the men like to wage war and women love warriors – what do you mean by that?

Let me explain how I see things. In a certain way, we are all Hegelians. Being Hegelians means that we believe in causes. X happened because of cause Y. History is a story of causes that led to outcomes. This is one way of looking at things. But it also diminishes the importance of what people actually want to do.

I’ll give you an analogy. Imagine a heavy goods train climbing a mountain. There are two locomotives. The locomotive in the rear is the cause, but the locomotive in front is what people want to do. I believe that the Hegelian way of looking at things has gone too far in ignoring what people want to do. One of the most important things men want to do is to fight each other. Because it is the supreme way in which they can prove themselves and the best way in which they can earn glory and booty. It is also the best way in which men can assert themselves in the eyes of women. Women need protection because they are not as strong as men and because they have children. They look up to those who defend them and open their arms to them. I think that, without taking into account both the differences and similarities between the sexes, you are not going to understand anything about these things either. Did I hear you laughing?

No, no, I am serious…

It is a very uncommon point of view. Do you know that I have a website? There is one article called ‘He and She.’ Look it up. This is what I think.

azithromycin viagra wiki cialis for bph ciprofloxacin 500 buy generic viagra what does viagra do finasteride tablets cialis free trial herbal viagra 200 cialis coupon zithromax dosage generic cialis tadalafil cipro antibiotic azithromycin drug class zithromax z-​pak cipro antibiotics order viagra cialis 30 day trial coupon ciprofloxacin drug class azithromycin uses viagra coupon how to use viagra escitalopram 10 mg zovirax dosage cialis professional is lexapro a controlled substance canadian cialis viagra tablets what is viagra cipro cialis 20 mg ciprofloxacin hcl azithromycin z pak finasteride permanent side effects cipro 500 lexapro dosage viagra coupons cialis coupons printable generic cialis viagra generico cialis samples overnight cialis dosage strengths finasteride 1mg ciprofloxacin dosage ciprofloxacin 500mg tablets ciprofloxacin 250 mg equipe argentine viagra cheap cialis ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg tab what does finasteride do cialis patent expiration date extended cialis generic tadalafil azithromycin 500 erfahrungen cialis 5 mg lexapro overdose ciprofloxacin side effects in women viagra bestellen vardenafil vs viagra cost of cialis lowest cialis prices levitra vs viagra daily cialis finasteride hair loss ciprofloxacin spc tamoxifen citrate cialis cost lexapro reviews does lexapro cause weight gain side effects of ciprofloxacin what does ciprofloxacin treat lexapro coupons common side effects of ciprofloxacin 500 mg cialis prices cialis samples azithromycin pregnancy levitra rezeptfrei deutschland weaning off lexapro acyclovir cream lexapro withdrawal symptoms cialis daily side effects of lexapro ciprofloxacin 500mg antibiotics side effects ciprofloxacin hydrochloride viagra for women azithromycin medscape ciprofloxacin hydrochloride ophthalmic women viagra viagra without a doctor prescription usa escitalopram nebenwirkungen escitalopram 10 mg para que sirve cialis price how does viagra work viagra for sale uk viagra pillen kruidvat azithromycin 5 day dose pack what is acyclovir for levitra 20 mg von bayer ciprofloxacin dose finasteride results lexapro 10 mg viagra 100mg acyclovir dosage lexapro vs celexa discount cialis cialis without a doctor’s prescription acyclovir ointment buy cialis azithromycine 250 mg cialis effects cialis pricing what is cipro used for ciprofloxacin 250mg what is acyclovir how long for azithromycin to take effect finasteride 5mg tab acyclovir for cold sores viagra alternative azithromycin eye drops viagra on line cialis pills viagra without a doctor prescription ciprofloxacin side effects after age 60 azithromycin side effects ciprofloxacin drops azithromycin 500mg cialis sample tamoxifen side effects tamoxifen side effects in women over 55 cealis viagra for men discount viagra azithromycin for pneumonia cialis for daily use tamoxifen lawsuits ciprofloxacin bnf levitra generic cialis generic availability cialis patent expiration 2017 viamedic cialis finasteride side effects canada viagra azithromycin 250 generic cialis at walmart how does acyclovir work cialis voucher side effects of finasteride 5mg when will cialis go generic cialis viagra from canada canada cialis what is finasteride used for lexapro for anxiety viagra 100 mg side effects of lexapro in women viagra vs cialis vs levitra cialis otc finasteride 5mg levitra online lexapro weight gain lexapro withdrawal viagra en ligne livraison 24h tamoxifen bijwerkingen azithromycin coverage cialis medication tamoxifen langzeitfolgen viagra tablet tamoxifen and foods to avoid azithromycin and alcohol propecia side effects cialis coupon what is cialis zovirax for cold sores cialis coupons escitalopram 20 mg cialis pills for sale what is ciprofloxacin prescribed for is tamoxifen chemotherapy acyclovir medication generic lexapro azithromycin cost canadian viagra zithromax cialas viagra vs cialis cialis 20mg what bacteria does ciprofloxacin kill cialis savings card cipro drug class azithromycine what is azithromycin for finasteride effets secondaires azithromycin for strep throat viagra tesco azithromycin class what is acyclovir used for cialis 5mg daily cialis tadalafil lexapro side effects lexapro vs wellbutrin price cialis cialis canadian pharmacy cialis vs viagra how to get off lexapro azithromycin liquid zoloft vs lexapro what works better than viagra cialis coupons from manufacturer levitra coupons cipro and tendonitis acyclovir side effects ciprofloxacin 500mg acyclovir dosing acyclovir dose ciprofloxacin ophthalmic solution cialis coupon 20 mg viagra sex stopping lexapro what is ciprofloxacin ciprofloxacin class levitra without a doctor prescription erectile dysfunction cialis cilias levitra 10 mg prezzo what is tamoxifen how does lexapro work cialis on line levitra 20mg cost per pill cialis 30 day sample viagra on line no prec cialis coupon print over the counter viagra cheap viagra tamoxifen therapy viagra pills azithromycin 250 mg finasteride reviews buy generic levitra propecia ciprofloxacin 500mg antibiotics finasteride 5 mg cipro uses antibiotic ciprofloxacin ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg generic levitra revatio vs viagra lexapro 20mg natural viagra levitra cialis 10 mg azithromycin 500 mg viagra price cialis discount ciprofloxacin nebenwirkungen ciprofloxacin side effects cialis coupons 2017 generic for cialis lexapro vs zoloft cipro dosage levitra 20 mg ciprofloxacin 500 mg for urinary tract infection viagra pill side effects of viagra viagra effects viagra canada what is lexapro vardenafil 20mg zithromax 500 mg lexapro manufacturer website levitra dosage lexapro dosing finasteride 5mg side effects mayo clinic azithromycin pediatric dosing lexapro medication acyclovir 400mg cialis alternative free cialis finasteride 5 mg tab viagra ohne rezept auf rechnung how much does cialis cost buy levitra wellbutrin and lexapro cialis 20mg directions zithromax antibiotic how does cialis work lexapro 10mg azithromycin dosage 9 levitra at walmart free viagra viagra soft escitalopram side effects azithromycin tablets acyclovir for shingles viagra prices acyclovir 800 mg for shingles how long for lexapro to work azithromycin without a doctor’s prescription acyclovir dosage for cold sores side effects of ciprofloxacin 500 mg online viagra lexapro and weight loss tamoxifen and bone pain pfizer viagra tamoxifen nebenwirkungen levitra prezzo in farmacia tamoxifen side effects in women levitra vs viagra for hardness cost of viagra where to buy viagra buy cialis online viagra kaufen viagra uk zovirax cream viagra medicine viagra single packs levitra prices ciprofloxacin coverage cialis trial is ciprofloxacin a penicillin viagra online buy levitra online ciprofloxacin used for what is cipro usually prescribed for cialis patent expiration post finasteride syndrome side effects of azithromycin azithromycin 250mg tablets 6 pack buy viagra online lexapro and wellbutrin combination therapy viagra costs viagra 50mg cipro for uti cyalis cialis reviews how long does viagra last generic viagra escitalopram best price viagra levitra 20 mg cost walmart azithromycin pregnancy category finasteride for women cialis cheap ciprofloxacin 500 mg tabletten viagra 100 ciprofloxacin lexapro side effects of finasteride cialis side effects is azithromycin cialis dosage viagra for sale cialis website cipro dangers how to wean off lexapro azithromycin 250 mg treatment generic levitra vardenafil 20mg what is lexapro used for azithromycine eg 500 mg bijsluiter tamoxifen cost side effects of tamoxifen escitalopram oxalate levitra erfahrungen lexapro side effects men how to wean off lexapro without withdrawals female viagra cialis copay card cialis generic thuoc azithromycin acyclovir vs valacyclovir side effects of cialis finasteride dosage azithromycin vs erythromycin lexapro and weight gain lexapro side effects in women levitra coupon cheap levitra levitra 20 mg precio farmacia viagra activate azithromycin for uti what is finasteride cialis dosage recommendations withdrawal from lexapro escitalopram 10mg finasteride vs dutasteride what is lexapro for viagra side effects sophia viagra what does ciprofloxacin 500mg treat tamoxifen and weight gain what does azithromycin treat what is azithromycin cialis pharmacy prices first few days on lexapro ciprofloxacin for dogs finasteride long term effects azithromycin tablet viagra cost ciprofloxacin uses finasteride 5mg side effects buy viagra lexapro and weight gain in women sex viagra for women viagra ohne rezept aus deutschland lexapro dosages cialis from canada generic viagra 100mg azithromycin 250mg finasteride and enlarged prostate ciprofloxacin 500 mg tamoxifen interaction utilisation viagra wholesale cialis acyclovir 200mg celexa vs lexapro cialis for women viagra alternatives finasteride acyclovir 400 mg nolvadex acyclovir viagra vs cialis finasteride efectos secundarios cialis 5mg what infections does ciprofloxacin treat cipro side effects viagra receptfritt cipro side effects in elderly side effects of acyclovir lexapro bula lexapro generic ciprofloxacin eye drops acyclovir 800 mg side effects lexapro viagra wikipedia effects of stopping finasteride what is cipro ciprofloxacin dosierung generic for lexapro cialis canada lexapro 5mg lexapro side effects in men tamoxifen lexapro generic name what is ciprofloxacin used for buying viagra levitra bayer 20mg meilleur prix liquid cialis how to take cialis ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg side effects viagra dosage viagra natural what is escitalopram levitra 20mg levitra vs viagra acyclovir 800 mg 5 times a day lexapro para que sirve is azithromycin penicillin finasteride for hair loss cialis for men viagra generic side effects of lexapro 10 mg azithromycin three times a week viagra cialis acyclovir ointment 5 viagra samples effects of stopping lexapro suddenly escitalopram effets secondaires cialis or viagra acyclovir 800mg online cialis azithromycin 500 viagra nebenwirkungen finasteride medication cialis vs viagra viagra substitute what is azithromycin used for what is tamoxifen used for viagra vs cialis vs levitra side effects of azithromycin 250 mg lexapro benefits for women viagra 100mg tablets retail price cialis for sale zovirax ointment cialis online viagra sans ordonnance finasteride side effects in men zovirax pills cialis testimonials pfizer viagra coupons from pfizer zovirax viagra