From an airplane, the slums of Nairobi. Taken on safari in Kenya / John Storr / commons.wikimedia.org

Slums as Cities of Future

An interview with Robert Neuwirth on what we could learn from the slums by Vera Lukyanovich

Read intro

An interview with Robert Neuwirth

An interview by Vera Lukyanovich

Between 2000 and 2050 the world population is expected to increase by 3 billion. Little of this growth will happen either in developed countries, or in the rural developing world. Almost all of it will appear in cities in developing countries, with much of the urban growth taking place in slums. Slums are a kind of buffer from rural to urban life caused by rapid rural-to-urban migration. People come to a city from the countryside, and what brings them there is the hope for a new life as a result of the intense economic activity happening in the cities, and they obviously have reasons for such hope. The newcomers need a place to live, but they are not able to rent it. So they simply create it. People build themselves habitations, forming huge settlements.

In most developing countries "sustainable" building is a long-range goal. The reality is that, despite no land being owned, a whole low-cost real estate economy takes shape, being managed without any laws or governmental approval. Life in such informal settlements is characterised by grossly inadequate housing and lack or total absence of access to basic urban services and infrastructure. Nevertheless, whole generations live and work there. People earn money, cultivating the development of the informal economy, which grows to an incredible scale; along with the slums.

I discussed these issues with Robert Neuwirth, American investigative reporter and author of “Shadow Cities: A Billion Squatters, A New Urban World” and “Stealth of Nations”. The first book was written as a result of Robert’s experience of living in squatter communities in Nairobi, Rio de Janeiro, Istanbul and Mumbai. Research for his second book,“Stealth of Nations”, took four years, which Robert spent investigating the way people earn a living in squatter settlements. Robert was observing from inside the operation of street vendors, smugglers and various informal import/export companies.
Hide intro

The first question I want to ask you is about the future of cities in developing countries. Today the tendency is as follows: more than 30 % or about 865 million of the urban population in the developing world lives in slums. This is the data from UN-​HABITAT as of 2012. In India every eighth urban child under 6 years lives in a slum, and this continues to grow. In EU the average number of children born to a woman during her lifetime is 1.6 children, in Indian slums this rate amounts to 4.5. This figure is also higher than the overall national rate in India, which is 2.5. Generally, the population in slums is significantly younger than in the typical city of a developed country. So, the question is whether, in your opinion, slums can be considered as a city of the future?

First, I try not to use the term ‘slum.’ Why? Because it’s degrading. These are communities that are degraded because they are deprived of municipal services. But they are real communities. It’s even a problem to call all these areas shantytowns, because, in countries like Brazil and Turkey, the homes people build are most often with reinforced concrete and brick. They’re not shanties or huts, but rather real apartment buildings.

I tend to call these neighbourhoods ‘squatter communities’ because that expresses the in-​between legal status involved: people have built their homes without approval on land they don’t own.

Anything that involves 13 of the urban population of the world is beyond a trend. It’s reality.

But the key principle is this: anything that involves 13 of the urban population of the world is beyond a trend. It’s reality. These are real neighbourhoods – part of every city’s fabric – and they should be treated that way. And, given the number of children growing up in these communities (and check your Indian statistic … it has to be more than one in eight children in urban India growing up in these communities given that, in Mumbai for instance, squatters make up 12 the urban population), they are the cities of the future.

columbia water center copy

Columbia Water Center /​flickr​.com

These are the official criteria for a household to be considered as a “slum household” (this is the definition from UN-​HABITAT). It says that there should be a group of individuals living under the same roof in an urban area who lack one or more of the following: 1. Durable housing of a permanent nature that protects against extreme climate conditions 2. Sufficient living space, which means not more than three people sharing the same room 3. Easy access to safe water in sufficient amounts at an affordable price 4. Access to adequate sanitation in the form of a private or public toilet shared by a reasonable number of people 5. Security of tenure that prevents forced evictions. According to these criteria an immense amount of housing in Russia can be considered as “slum households” – at least 18 million people in Russia lived in such condition as of 2001. What is your opinion about it? What are your criteria for a settlement to be considered as a “slum” or squatter community?

What’s ridiculous about the UN’s criteria is that, by its own terms, many ‘redeveloped’ slums are slums. In India, as I noted, large families are given one 225 square foot room in a redeveloped building, and may share a toilet and kitchen with many other families. That flunks points 2 and 4 in its own definition.

I don’t think it’s useful to spent time defining what makes a community a slum. Indeed, it’s because of criteria like the UN’s that I prefer to talk about squatter communities. What’s different about these communities is their legal status: they are not recognised as part of the formal city. If we can change that, people and build and redevelop and make their own rules in the communities where they live, and improvements will be commensurate and in keeping with their needs and desires. I start from the principle that, no matter the material conditions, people value their own neighbourhoods and want to make them better. What was most interesting to me as I traveled around the shantytowns of Nairobi, for instance, was this: when I asked people what they wanted for their community, the answer was rarely a better house. It was water, or sewers, or electricity or street lighting, or roads on which an ambulance could get through. Infrastructure rather than new homes. People want to work for the betterment of their communities. Governments restrict them, as do our prejudice that what is most important is the bricks and mortar of the house.

computerwhiz417 / flickr.com

computerwhiz417 /​flickr​.com

Now I’d like to talk to you a little about your personal experience, which is really interesting and extensive. You spent about 4 years living in squatter communities around the world. What is the difference between them in your view? Where is the strongest sense of community and why?

Well, the differences are cultural and material. Some cultures foster togetherness. Others are based more on individualism. In some, tribal and family disputes predominate. In others, people work together despite regional and ethnic differences. All of the places I have lived – neighbourhoods in Brazil, Turkey, Kenya, Nigeria, India, Paraguay – had strong community identities. But in Kenya, for instance, people did not feel free to mobilise on behalf of their communities. While in Turkey or Brazil they did. India’s empowerment efforts were blunted somewhat by the caste system, but at least the ethos is still there. In Nigeria, the political structure is still quite repressive, and while people are allowed to mobilise, efforts at community empowerment are often met with force – so the population is quite fearful. In Kenya, an atavistic colonial-​era bureaucracy called the provincial administration made organising in the shantytown very difficult.

All that aside, people in every neighbourhood were proud of their community. That was an important universal lesson.

How did your interest in squatter communities appear? What was the trigger for it?

I spent years writing almost exclusively about the inequities and inequalities involved in housing and politics in New York City and one day a friend who was working for the UN mentioned the number of squatters in the developing world. I realised that instant that the issues I was writing about were small by comparison. These people, who created so much out of nothing, were the real story. There’s no government or developer who can build housing at the cost people can afford and in the numbers that are needed to house the urban poor. So they seize land and build for themselves. This, it seemed to me, was one of the great untold stories of the 21st century, and it inspired me. I had never been outside of North America and Europe, so I didn’t have much knowledge or courage. It took me five years to develop the courage and to finally quit my job and go to live in these communities. I feel amazingly privileged that people opened their lives to me and I hope my writing has done justice to the effort and dignity the world’s squatters have put into making their communities better.

And now let’s discuss the redevelopment of squatter communities, which has recently become a very popular issue. Governmental programmes of building multi-​storey housing instead of existing squatter communities have been applied in some countries; this being especially popular in India. What do you think of such programmes? What could be considered as effective redevelopment of squatter communities?

Squatter communities can redevelop themselves, in partnership with government.

It really depends. I’m not totally against so-​called redevelopment. If – and this is the key point – it is the choice of the people in the communities themselves. Often, people don’t see some of the negatives involved in what is called redevelopment. In India, for instance, a family gets, as I recall, 225 square feet in a redeveloped building – no matter how many generations and children are living together. And while they may run a store from their home in the so-​called slum, they will be refused permission to do this in the redeveloped apartment. Also, we should be aware that so-​called slum neighbourhoods are often near to where people work, while redeveloped buildings are often far away, requiring a costly and time-​consuming commute to work.

I prefer to think about people developing and redeveloping their own neighbourhoods. Squatter communities can redevelop themselves, in partnership with government.

ILO in Asia and the Pacific / flickr.com

ILO in Asia and the Pacific /​flickr​.com

So, how do you see squatter communities in 20 years? What are the major global tendencies in their redevelopment that you have observed? Are there any successful examples of redevelopment so far?

The biggest changes in the past 20 years have been in countries like Turkey and Brazil and other countries across South & Central America and North Africa, where squatters have started to develop on a larger and more dense scale. People are building apartments rather than one-​storey shanties and you can rent in the squatter community rather than build for yourself. This is successful redevelopment, by the squatters themselves.

I have not seen any government projects that are truly community-​based and community-​led.

I see the future as bright for these communities. But it will take a fight against the private real estate lobby. In Istanbul, the government has been destroying historic neighbourhoods in the name of upgrading. Same in Rio de Janeiro in the buildup to the World Cup and the Olympics. Squatter communities in valuable central areas of the cities are the most vulnerable – and people have to mobilise to protect themselves and their communities. If the people mobilise now, their communities will be important parts of the city in 20 years.

Taking into account that squatter communities have already to a large extent drawn the attention of modern society, forcing urbanists, economists and politicians to work on the improvement of quality of life, let’s assume that the quality would dramatically increase and major problems would be solved. This could cause unaffordability for newcomers from rural areas settling there. Does it mean that squatter communities are unavoidable?

In most countries in which housing is built for profit, the best market, from a landlord’s perspective, is one of managed scarcity. Too many apartments available and the price will crash. Too few and the ones available will quickly become too expensive. In that kind of market, it is no wonder that people are forced to build for themselves, on land they don’t own, and in precarious environmental regions.

Or people are underpaid for their work. In India, for example, I met a woman who worked two half-​time jobs for middle class families. The combined wages were not enough to rent an apartment for herself and her two daughters. In fact, her income was not enough to rent a hut in a squatter settlement. So her family lived on the open ground under a road flyover next to the train tracks. The middle class families that employ her would have to pay a living wage for this to change.

Slums or squatter communities are not unavoidable. But only if we make changes – personally and as a society. No more business as usual.

You state that about 1.8 billion people are engaged in informal economic activities around the world. How can we cooperate with it? Do you see any particular plan for effective cooperation? How do you see the development of the informal economy in future?

Informal economy is the economy of the global majority

To me, the informal economy – or what I call System D – is the economy of the global majority. More than half the workers of the world work off the books, either for themselves or being paid in cash. This makes System D the most important economy in the world. To ignore it is to ignore the global majority.

There’s lots of pressure on System D now. Governments all over the world are criminalising street trading. The merchants need to organise themselves to improve their businesses, their markets and their neighbourhoods. If they can do this, if they can create a space for themselves, politically and socially they will represent a tremendous positive force for the future.

Slums in Mumbai, Dharavi / Jon Hurd / flickr.com

Slums in Mumbai, Dharavi /​Jon Hurd /​flickr​.com

Thank you, Robert! It was nice to talk to you. My pleasure.

cialis 20mg directions is azithromycin ciprofloxacin used for ciprofloxacin 500mg antibiotics cialis otc sophia viagra cialas buying viagra azithromycin liquid cialis without a doctor’s prescription daily cialis finasteride for hair loss side effects of finasteride what is finasteride used for cost of viagra cipro dosage ciprofloxacin dosage how to wean off lexapro without withdrawals levitra cialis coupons cialis online viagra bestellen viagra sans ordonnance levitra 20 mg von bayer buy viagra cialis on line generic for lexapro best price viagra azithromycin acyclovir 200mg finasteride efectos secundarios ciprofloxacin 500mg antibiotics side effects viagra receptfritt viagra activate azithromycin pregnancy category finasteride cialis for men what is cipro used for viagra tablets azithromycin 250 lexapro dosing finasteride side effects azithromycin medscape tamoxifen interaction levitra vs viagra for hardness azithromycin tablet lexapro for anxiety escitalopram effets secondaires azithromycin for pneumonia acyclovir 400 mg lexapro coupons levitra 10 mg prezzo viagra effects viagra for sale uk wholesale cialis viagra 100mg tablets retail price ciprofloxacin drug class when will cialis go generic levitra vs viagra viagra for women ciprofloxacin hydrochloride generic cialis tadalafil stopping lexapro ciprofloxacin 500 cialis for women how to wean off lexapro lexapro and wellbutrin combination therapy ciprofloxacin acyclovir medication cialis 20 mg cialis 5 mg azithromycin 500 lexapro withdrawal symptoms generic viagra 100mg ciprofloxacin 500 mg tabletten lexapro weight gain women viagra viagra tablet azithromycin 500 erfahrungen viagra samples azithromycin 250 mg viagra kaufen zovirax cream ciprofloxacin 250mg ciprofloxacin eye drops withdrawal from lexapro lexapro side effects finasteride long term effects ciprofloxacin for dogs cialis cheap lexapro dosage cost of cialis azithromycin without a doctor’s prescription pfizer viagra coupons from pfizer azithromycin z pak online viagra 200 cialis coupon viagra without a doctor prescription cialis medication zovirax dosage how to get off lexapro free cialis lexapro medication what is lexapro acyclovir dosage what is cipro usually prescribed for cialis patent expiration date extended viagra online online cialis viagra from canada canadian cialis erectile dysfunction cialis viagra coupons how does acyclovir work what is cialis tamoxifen side effects in women what is azithromycin escitalopram 10 mg viagra vs cialis cialis for sale finasteride reviews cialis generic availability tamoxifen side effects in women over 55 cipro and tendonitis side effects of ciprofloxacin cialis dosage side effects of acyclovir escitalopram how does viagra work does lexapro cause weight gain generic viagra ciprofloxacin bnf viagra generic weaning off lexapro viagra nebenwirkungen viagra costs cialis side effects ciprofloxacin hydrochloride ophthalmic azithromycin vs erythromycin side effects of lexapro 10 mg viagra alternatives generic levitra azithromycin cost azithromycin tablets levitra without a doctor prescription viagra pill pfizer viagra cialis 30 day sample lexapro 10mg lexapro bula finasteride dosage viagra pills cialis vs viagra what is viagra finasteride 5mg side effects mayo clinic lowest cialis prices tamoxifen citrate how much does cialis cost canada cialis what does ciprofloxacin 500mg treat first few days on lexapro azithromycin eye drops ciprofloxacin class viagra acyclovir dosing what is acyclovir zovirax pills generic lexapro discount viagra viagra soft acyclovir ointment 5 what does azithromycin treat acyclovir 800 mg cialis pills cialis testimonials viagra ohne rezept auf rechnung what bacteria does ciprofloxacin kill levitra online ciprofloxacin 500mg tablets lexapro vs wellbutrin cialis savings card ciprofloxacin 500 mg for urinary tract infection viagra without a doctor prescription usa lexapro benefits for women ciprofloxacin 250 mg lexapro para que sirve lexapro 10 mg cialis pricing what is lexapro for herbal viagra zoloft vs lexapro tamoxifen side effects cialis or viagra ciprofloxacin side effects in women ciprofloxacin spc finasteride and enlarged prostate effects of stopping finasteride is tamoxifen chemotherapy viagra tesco acyclovir side effects of ciprofloxacin 500 mg viagra for men cialis patent expiration 2017 cealis lexapro and weight gain levitra coupons cialis professional viagra en ligne livraison 24h azithromycin drug class cialis patent expiration cialis dosage strengths lexapro side effects in men wellbutrin and lexapro is lexapro a controlled substance viagra on line no prec cialis website acyclovir side effects cialis coupons printable viagra wiki tamoxifen and foods to avoid antibiotic ciprofloxacin natural viagra lexapro 5mg cialis coupons from manufacturer cialis pharmacy prices finasteride results ciprofloxacin coverage generic levitra vardenafil 20mg azithromycin side effects cheap viagra cialis for bph cialis tadalafil ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg tab acyclovir 800 mg for shingles cipro antibiotics cheap cialis zovirax for cold sores what is finasteride levitra 20mg how does lexapro work cipro antibiotic finasteride medication acyclovir 800mg acyclovir ointment buy cialis online viagra prices viagra medicine what does viagra do cyalis viagra coupon ciprofloxacin side effects ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg side effects viagra alternative side effects lexapro what is ciprofloxacin cialis trial buy levitra online side effects of viagra azithromycin and alcohol levitra prices tamoxifen bijwerkingen levitra rezeptfrei deutschland azithromycin 250mg tablets 6 pack cialis coupon 20 mg cipro drug class viagra dosage zovirax generic for cialis ciprofloxacin 500 mg utilisation viagra tamoxifen and bone pain tamoxifen lawsuits cialis prices cialis 5mg is azithromycin penicillin how long does viagra last acyclovir for cold sores nolvadex acyclovir 400mg what infections does ciprofloxacin treat cialis vs viagra what is azithromycin for lexapro manufacturer website viagra sex lexapro vs celexa effects of stopping lexapro suddenly finasteride tablets viagra substitute generic cialis azithromycin 500 mg vardenafil vs viagra lexapro reviews levitra bayer 20mg meilleur prix azithromycin 250 mg treatment viagra vs cialis vs levitra vardenafil 20mg azithromycin for uti acyclovir dose zithromax 500 mg equipe argentine viagra how long for azithromycin to take effect cialis coupons 2017 lexapro generic name cialis levitra dosage azithromycin for strep throat what is azithromycin used for lexapro generic zithromax dosage viagra for sale propecia viagra 50mg lexapro side effects men buy viagra online is ciprofloxacin a penicillin where to buy viagra cialis coupon revatio vs viagra cialis for daily use finasteride 5 mg tab finasteride 5mg side effects acyclovir for shingles azithromycin 500mg viagra side effects cipro buy generic viagra cipro uses what is ciprofloxacin used for cialis samples ciprofloxacin side effects after age 60 how long for lexapro to work azithromycine 250 mg tamoxifen cost levitra prezzo in farmacia viamedic cialis cialis daily celexa vs lexapro escitalopram 10 mg para que sirve cialis effects cialis price cialis 20mg tamoxifen therapy finasteride 5 mg cialis copay card cialis pills for sale thuoc azithromycin what is escitalopram cipro side effects cialis 30 day trial coupon canada viagra tamoxifen langzeitfolgen viagra 100 mg escitalopram side effects what is acyclovir used for cialis dosage recommendations lexapro withdrawal liquid cialis viagra natural viagra 100 cialis reviews cialis generic tadalafil cipro dangers zithromax cialis 5mg daily side effects of lexapro in women cialis alternative cipro side effects in elderly viagra vs cialis viagra canada cialis sample zithromax antibiotic 9 levitra at walmart buy generic levitra viagra cialis what works better than viagra lexapro and weight loss acyclovir cream zithromax z-​pak azithromycin coverage cialis canadian pharmacy levitra 20 mg precio farmacia finasteride vs dutasteride azithromycin pediatric dosing escitalopram nebenwirkungen side effects of tamoxifen side effects of finasteride 5mg generic cialis at walmart how to take cialis sex viagra for women cilias viagra cost side effects of azithromycin 250 mg lexapro common side effects of ciprofloxacin 500 mg cipro 500 tamoxifen and weight gain discount cialis finasteride 5mg ciprofloxacin dose levitra 20 mg finasteride for women cialis canada how to use viagra levitra vs viagra azithromycine levitra 20mg cost per pill what is acyclovir for cheap levitra azithromycin uses azithromycin dosage viagra pillen kruidvat propecia side effects buy levitra viagra 100mg how does cialis work viagra wikipedia tamoxifen nebenwirkungen cialis discount azithromycin class finasteride 5mg tab escitalopram 20 mg what is ciprofloxacin prescribed for what is tamoxifen acyclovir dosage for cold sores what is lexapro used for viagra uk viagra price cialis cost free viagra finasteride side effects in men acyclovir 800 mg 5 times a day female viagra lexapro and weight gain in women ciprofloxacin nebenwirkungen ciprofloxacin drops what does ciprofloxacin treat viagra on line what is tamoxifen used for buy cialis levitra generic acyclovir vs valacyclovir side effects of cialis cialis generic ciprofloxacin uses viagra vs cialis vs levitra levitra coupon ciprofloxacin hcl side effects of azithromycin finasteride permanent side effects finasteride 1mg finasteride hair loss viagra generico zovirax ointment cialis samples overnight cialis voucher cialis 10 mg what is cipro canadian viagra ciprofloxacin ophthalmic solution levitra erfahrungen azithromycin pregnancy azithromycine eg 500 mg bijsluiter ciprofloxacin dosierung viagra single packs order viagra what does finasteride do finasteride effets secondaires cialis free trial over the counter viagra lexapro dosages cipro for uti price cialis lexapro vs zoloft tamoxifen side effects of lexapro lexapro side effects in women lexapro 20mg levitra 20 mg cost walmart azithromycin three times a week cialis coupon print lexapro overdose cialis from canada ciprofloxacin 500mg ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg azithromycin 250mg viagra ohne rezept aus deutschland escitalopram 10mg azithromycin 5 day dose pack post finasteride syndrome escitalopram oxalate