Preservation from necessity

An interview with architect Muck Petzet by Konstantin Budarin

Read intro

An interview with Muck Petzet

An interview by Konstantin Budarin

The practice of heritage preservation is based on the idea that some objects are more valuable than others: that one form of architecture is more important than another. It affirms that we can find the best examples of architecture and preserve them. Actually, we don’t even need to find anything. There already are specialized organizations to do it for us, such as UNESCO. But is this approach still relevant today? Is ‘value’ the only criteria for preserving buildings? Can we look forward to a future where the idea of heritage preservation has evolved beyond creation of fetishes?

Muck Petzet is a German architect. He and his bureau specialize in preservation projects. In 2012 he was the curator of the German pavilion at the Venice biennale, Reduce Reuse Recycle.
Hide intro

In 2012 you were the curator of the German pavilion at the Venice biennale. Your project was called Reduce Reuse Recycle. Can you explain what it was about?

I realized that architects don’t place a lot of emphasis on, or see a lot of value in transformation projects. At the same time – in Germany, for instance – they are the most common type of architectural work. There’s a big gap between what society needs and how we perceive the role of architects. Often when you make a very good transformation the result is not visible: in some ways it is better than it was before and in most other ways it stays the same. But typically both the architects and the public want visible results.

To show the value of this kind of work I was looking for another set of values, from outside the world of architecture. I found a set of values from the waste production and processing field, called Reduce Reuse Recycle. It’s a waste pyramid, in fact. It isn’t just three different methods for treating waste – it’s a system in which reduction or avoidance is the best thing to do. Reusing things in more or less the same way they were used before is second best. Recycling is kind of seen as a bad thing because it requires extra energy and resources.

I was wondering how we can transplant this value system into our treatment of existing buildings, and what strategies we would need to achieve that.

German pavilion in Venice 2012

German pavilion in Venice 2012 /​Photo by Nico Saieh /​Arch​daily​.com

In the 1920s, Bauhaus brought the factory and the proletariat into architectural practice; in the 1960s, architects were crazy about cars. Maybe the new ecological, energy-​reduction agenda can also provide new meanings for architecture?

Naturally, everybody is talking about sustainability at the moment. In Germany, at least, the discourse is very fixed on how much energy we consume when we use buildings. Everybody wants to save energy. That’s the main focus. There is this big discussion, but on the other hand, nobody can bear to hear about it anymore. Now every company declares in every advert that it’s trying to be more efficient, more sustainable.

The idea that you have to create something new only really appeared at the beginning of the last century

Focusing on this is completely wrong, because the energy spent when buildings are used is just part of the total energy consumed. We must think about the whole lifecycle of buildings. It starts when we extract resources and transform them into building materials. Cement production is especially energy-​intensive, for example. Then we turn the materials into buildings. These processes are neglected at the moment, at least in Germany. The only country where this process isn’t neglected is Switzerland, where they are trying to find a way to measure, compare and certify the whole lifecycle of a building. From an energy perspective, we need to look at a building’s construction and usage costs. We also need to count transportation costs, because materials need to be shipped; and mobility costs, which are determined by how well a building connects to the city. At the end of a building’s life there are dismantle costs. All of these parameters seen together give a picture of a building’s energy balance. That is quite interesting.

Meanwhile, Germany is completely focused on the energy consumed by buildings during their use, on things like heating. It’s all about insulating existing buildings and upgrading them. A lot of buildings have been dismantled for this reason, replaced by beautifully efficient new ones. Nobody notices that by doing this we consume an enormous amount of energy and release tons of CO­2 into the atmosphere.

You are suggesting that working with existing buildings is a better approach for the present day. But is there a place for architecture in this new world you are describing – in a world where all the buildings are already built?

For me personally, working on a new building has never been any different to working on an existing one. They are tasks of equal importance. Society currently sees an architect as a creator of new things, even though there is a long tradition of architecture as something else. That tradition always set out to develop existing things further. The idea that you have to create something new only really appeared at the beginning of the last century. Now architecture is a kind of public art. Of course, there are a lot of parallels with history of art. I think that this situation is wrong, especially in architecture, where you always work within existing ensembles or patterns or surroundings. Naturally, every architect says that their work is site-​specific, but hardly anyone’s really is. Lacaton & Vassal also talk about this. Even if you have an empty plot, there’s no difference – it’s never totally empty.

Cedric Price’s architectural drawings engaged with existing landscapes. 1966

Cedric Price’s architectural drawings engaged with existing landscapes. 1966

I was part of a big group working on a city planning project in China; the territory was flat and undeveloped, seemingly perfect for a development of green office-​blocks. Perfect, of course, but when you looked closer you always saw little villages, streets, nature, holy-​ground. I think that in the near future – or let’s say mid-​term future – architecture will be about dealing with the existing environment, at least in central Europe. We will work more and more in this field. It already makes up about 70% of the work. That’s why it’s so important to see this as an equally worthy, or at least as an interesting task for us architects. 

Strelka has been obsessed with heritage preservation from the beginning. We are especially interested in the preservation of modernist buildings. What does it mean to save a prefabricated building? How can you show the quality of something which is not unique?

I am personally very fond of modernist buildings. I appreciate their attempt to solve problems in an ingenious and technical way. Of course, many of these efforts didn’t work perfectly when they were implemented. But still, the whole craftsmanship side and the industrial building methods – especially from the ‘60s and ‘70s – are amazing. Later, in the ‘80s and ‘90s, everyone started dismissing it as total shit – flawed thinking and so on. It doesn’t work, that’s what I learnt at my school. But I secretly always thought that somehow it had a real charm and made a genuine attempt to solve the problem of housing.

I’m also very fascinated by the attempt to make a perfect housing-​block in the most effective way – to create a building as a good thing in itself. Now our building techniques have in some sense degenerated to the lowest point of the ‘50s. There are no skilled craftsmen anymore, so everything is done on a very, very cheap level and everything just gets glued together. It’s not about engineering anymore, it’s about fabricating something which looks like architecture and fits with the times.

This technical approach of pre-​fabricating everything you possibly can is much, much better and much, much more advanced. It’s not used anymore. Now you get all these cheap materials and you have no skilled labour on site. I much prefer transforming a modernist building from, say, the ‘60s or ‘70s, than an industrial building from the 19th century which is ok. Everyone already loves the 19th century buildings – there is no change of perception. 

There are no skilled craftsmen anymore, so everything just gets glued together. It’s not about engineering anymore, it’s about fabricating something which looks like architecture and fits with the times

There are always hidden qualities to exploit if you look beyond the poorness. Or you can add qualities to make buildings more interesting, or richer. That’s also an interesting part of transforming. I’m not talking only about preservation…I’m not talking about changing everything either, but I think it’s important to give things feet for the future. If you’re working on a very poor building then that’s an aspect you can improve – you can make it fleshier or more interesting. Sometimes you don’t have to, because there is enough spirit in the building already.

Сurtains by Lacaton & Vassal

Сurtains by Lacaton & Vassal /​laca​ton​va​s​sal​.com

Can you give a few examples of implemented projects which are close to your approach to architecture?

Lacaton & Vassal are pioneers in many ways. I think my favourite project is the tower Bois le Prêtre in Paris. I even went to Paris to see it. It is so impressive how they managed to look at all the resources stored in the existing architecture. The main part of that is the social pattern connected to the building.

They changed the whole ground floor to give it various social uses, and now it houses a number of meeting rooms for the community. In this way, a building that used to be hermetic is becoming part of a larger community. They also took the residents very seriously and developed a method to transform the building without moving everyone out, because usually when we move people out and transform their home into something beautiful they don’t come back. They worked intelligently with the existing structure: changing the internal distribution, dealing with fire protection complications – everything. It’s about asking yourselves: “how can we really add value, how can we change the function only where it’s really necessary?” That’s the whole principle. It’s setting out to give people more space, and then saying, “but space is a luxury so let’s do it with very cheap materials”. That’s the spirit of the pioneers of modernism.

Lacaton & Vassal used technical curtains from green houses, which are both very cheap and which added to the building interesting, even theatrical, aspects. It’s a very clever use of low cost materials to create more value for the existing social fabric and to connect it to the wider environment. So this is really one of the best examples. Recently they have been getting a lot of commissions for large buildings and I hope their example will lead the way.

In Germany nobody is able to build affordable apartments anymore. Now is the start of a serious housing crisis

Naturally, we have also done some projects along these lines. We recently transformed a large seventies’ community centre; it was great fun to work with this architecture although there were big technical problems due to the architect’s conceit of having the load-​bearing structure outside the building. You have a concrete and steel structure with cross-​beams that penetrate the façade. It was fun to solve these problems in a way that didn’t destroy the original idea. The interior was thoroughly uninteresting, so we transformed it, but we still tried to think like the original architect who was a real visionary and pioneer – he had totally crazy ideas. In the end we stripped out all the suspended ceilings which were concealing the structure, painted everything in crazy colours and showed all the inner workings of the building. We wanted to work in a way that did justice to the outside. I think it’s really interesting not to just invent your own language and plaster it on top of things, but to get inspired, to feel your way into the existing architecture, and to go on with it.

I have a strange thought that this energy agenda can also have implications for our ideas about space. We currently want small apartments because of energy efficiency. How can the new agenda change the physical features of architecture, or our perception of architecture?

The main direction now is that still everybody wants more space. In Switzerland I think it’s already 45m2 per person. Which is really crazy. It would be more interesting to think not in terms of growth of quantity but in terms of growth of quality.

In the future we won’t be able to consume as much energy and resources as today. We have to think about how to build for an age of less because we have to reduce what we already consume. That will be nearly impossible to achieve because nobody wants to step back from the level that we’ve reached.

But sooner or later we’ll be forced to, because if the world continues to expand at the current rate, and everyone’s living space keeps on growing, at a certain point it will simply no longer be possible. There will be rents that force us to take a step back, if we don’t get there first.

All of this gives us a real chance to think about what is really necessary, what is really quality? In Germany – also as a result of the rising standards in efficiency, comfort and size – nobody is able to build affordable apartments anymore. Now is the start of a serious housing crisis, but I hope that it could also be the beginning of something else, that in the future people will think in terms of quality, rather than quantity. That’s my big hope.

viagra without a doctor prescription propecia finasteride 5mg canadian cialis viagra azithromycin 500 erfahrungen finasteride 5mg side effects mayo clinic cialis patent expiration date extended zovirax pills azithromycin tablet side effects of lexapro in women cialis 20mg side effects of viagra viagra vs cialis vs levitra viagra coupons acyclovir cream acyclovir zithromax 500 mg levitra prezzo in farmacia what is cipro usually prescribed for lexapro manufacturer website viagra vs cialis ciprofloxacin side effects after age 60 viagra natural ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg tab how does cialis work ciprofloxacin for dogs cialis trial lexapro benefits for women viagra alternatives buy cialis lexapro bula levitra 20 mg lexapro 5mg ciprofloxacin side effects levitra vs viagra cipro drug class viagra costs what is finasteride lexapro side effects lexapro para que sirve buy cialis online what is azithromycin cialis without a doctor’s prescription ciprofloxacin ophthalmic solution cialis patent expiration 2017 levitra coupon is tamoxifen chemotherapy viagra wikipedia cipro and tendonitis cialis for women cipro dangers tamoxifen cialis azithromycin side effects viagra bestellen viagra pills azithromycin pregnancy acyclovir 400 mg what works better than viagra finasteride 1mg what does viagra do erectile dysfunction cialis what is acyclovir zithromax azithromycine how to use viagra escitalopram 10 mg para que sirve viagra generic azithromycin for strep throat lexapro what is escitalopram viagra activate azithromycin pediatric dosing finasteride and enlarged prostate azithromycin z pak cost of viagra ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg side effects lexapro ciprofloxacin coverage viagra for sale uk lexapro generic viagra generico cialis daily wholesale cialis azithromycin dosage vardenafil 20mg levitra vs viagra zithromax z-​pak azithromycin 500 mg ciprofloxacin 500mg what is ciprofloxacin tamoxifen side effects in women levitra online lexapro dosage ciprofloxacin nebenwirkungen ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg side effects finasteride side effects in men generic lexapro zoloft vs lexapro cialis for daily use escitalopram 10mg when will cialis go generic levitra erfahrungen levitra 20 mg precio farmacia cialis or viagra acyclovir 800 mg 5 times a day buy generic levitra cialis pricing is azithromycin ciprofloxacin 250 mg escitalopram 20 mg tamoxifen bijwerkingen viagra tablet cialis sample cheap cialis cialis 5 mg viagra dosage buy viagra viagra price viagra single packs cialis alternative lexapro medication zovirax ointment zithromax dosage ciprofloxacin hydrochloride ophthalmic azithromycin 250 mg azithromycin without a doctor’s prescription viagra 50mg revatio vs viagra azithromycin for pneumonia ciprofloxacin dosage acyclovir 400mg cialis medication levitra 20 mg cost walmart cialis 5mg cipro antibiotic finasteride dosage what is viagra cialis 10 mg viagra 100 ciprofloxacin 500 cialis generic tadalafil cialis pharmacy prices levitra vs viagra for hardness cialis canadian pharmacy zovirax cream lexapro 10 mg cialis samples canada viagra acyclovir dosage ciprofloxacin 500 mg how to take cialis pfizer viagra discount viagra lexapro vs zoloft cialis price cialis patent expiration buy generic viagra how does lexapro work azithromycin 250 mg treatment azithromycine 250 mg what is lexapro used for cialis testimonials cipro lexapro 10mg cialis 30 day sample escitalopram oxalate lexapro side effects men viagra from canada online cialis lexapro and wellbutrin combination therapy finasteride 5 mg cialis canada azithromycin coverage azithromycin 250 what does ciprofloxacin 500mg treat viagra tesco tamoxifen and bone pain cialis online tamoxifen langzeitfolgen viagra prices levitra without a doctor prescription what is finasteride used for levitra 20 mg von bayer finasteride vs dutasteride cilias azithromycin lexapro 20mg finasteride for women cialis generic availability what is tamoxifen used for cialas effects of stopping finasteride free viagra cialis cheap viagra for women cialis pills sex viagra for women cialis 30 day trial coupon viagra vs cialis vs levitra finasteride 5mg tab what is ciprofloxacin used for generic cialis at walmart lexapro reviews what is azithromycin for viagra on line generic viagra 100mg viagra ohne rezept aus deutschland how long does viagra last viagra without a doctor prescription usa ciprofloxacin drops generic cialis tadalafil canadian viagra zovirax for cold sores finasteride 5mg side effects lexapro side effects in women ciprofloxacin eye drops levitra lexapro withdrawal symptoms what infections does ciprofloxacin treat lexapro dosages viagra coupon does lexapro cause weight gain natural viagra finasteride hair loss side effects of azithromycin ciprofloxacin class ciprofloxacin side effects in women azithromycin cost cealis side effects of finasteride tamoxifen citrate cialis from canada azithromycin 500 acyclovir ointment 5 azithromycin 5 day dose pack cialis copay card tamoxifen interaction cialis coupon print lexapro and weight gain in women tamoxifen and weight gain female viagra levitra prices viagra side effects viagra canada lexapro withdrawal ciprofloxacin dosierung buy levitra online cialis otc weaning off lexapro ciprofloxacin 500mg antibiotics what is azithromycin used for online viagra viagra uk what is cipro what is ciprofloxacin prescribed for ciprofloxacin bnf cialis savings card cialis dosage escitalopram nebenwirkungen celexa vs lexapro acyclovir 800mg zovirax levitra generic cialis vs viagra viagra on line no prec is lexapro a controlled substance viagra 100mg tablets retail price common side effects of ciprofloxacin 500 mg tamoxifen side effects in women over 55 ciprofloxacin drug class zovirax dosage order viagra viagra kaufen equipe argentine viagra ciprofloxacin 500 mg tabletten buying viagra what is lexapro cipro dosage generic levitra viagra effects finasteride tablets acyclovir dose lexapro generic name ciprofloxacin dose levitra bayer 20mg meilleur prix pfizer viagra coupons from pfizer first few days on lexapro azithromycin liquid 200 cialis coupon azithromycin tablets tamoxifen and foods to avoid lexapro for anxiety how to get off lexapro cialis vs viagra levitra dosage buy viagra online escitalopram 10 mg cialis generic best price viagra lexapro weight gain finasteride side effects women viagra zithromax antibiotic finasteride results cialis dosage strengths how to wean off lexapro without withdrawals antibiotic ciprofloxacin viagra en ligne livraison 24h escitalopram finasteride medication cheap levitra where to buy viagra cialis on line acyclovir for shingles cialis for bph viamedic cialis azithromycin class side effects of acyclovir what does ciprofloxacin treat viagra pill cyalis liquid cialis thuoc azithromycin cialis reviews lexapro side effects in men azithromycin uses acyclovir dosage for cold sores cialis for men wellbutrin and lexapro generic viagra levitra 20mg cost per pill viagra cialis viagra ohne rezept auf rechnung side effects of tamoxifen over the counter viagra cialis 20 mg finasteride reviews viagra soft what is acyclovir for acyclovir side effects viagra tablets azithromycin eye drops what is cipro used for 9 levitra at walmart finasteride long term effects cialis samples overnight ciprofloxacin sophia viagra daily cialis viagra vs cialis azithromycin 250mg viagra receptfritt acyclovir dosing viagra pillen kruidvat viagra 100mg acyclovir 200mg levitra coupons how does viagra work lexapro and weight loss viagra sex price cialis finasteride 5 mg tab viagra medicine how long for lexapro to work how to wean off lexapro generic for cialis finasteride cipro antibiotics lexapro coupons cialis cost acyclovir 800 mg for shingles discount cialis cialis prices viagra samples ciprofloxacin uses acyclovir medication finasteride efectos secundarios buy levitra ciprofloxacin 500mg tablets cipro 500 azithromycin drug class what is lexapro for azithromycin and alcohol cialis coupon 20 mg azithromycin 500mg is azithromycin penicillin cost of cialis viagra sans ordonnance lexapro and weight gain herbal viagra lexapro overdose viagra 100 mg finasteride permanent side effects side effects of finasteride 5mg how much does cialis cost tamoxifen cost levitra 10 mg prezzo how long for azithromycin to take effect propecia side effects viagra cost tamoxifen nebenwirkungen side effects of cialis ciprofloxacin used for lexapro vs wellbutrin free cialis viagra online what is tamoxifen cialis pills for sale azithromycin 250mg tablets 6 pack side effects of lexapro 10 mg cheap viagra finasteride effets secondaires how does acyclovir work what does finasteride do cialis tadalafil post finasteride syndrome cialis professional viagra substitute ciprofloxacin hcl levitra 20mg ciprofloxacin 500 mg for urinary tract infection utilisation viagra viagra alternative finasteride for hair loss viagra for sale generic for lexapro cialis coupons stopping lexapro lexapro dosing side effects of ciprofloxacin 500 mg cialis for sale what bacteria does ciprofloxacin kill acyclovir ointment lowest cialis prices nolvadex ciprofloxacin hydrochloride side effects of azithromycin 250 mg cialis effects cipro side effects cialis coupons from manufacturer withdrawal from lexapro viagra wiki lexapro vs celexa cialis voucher escitalopram side effects azithromycin for uti what is cialis azithromycin pregnancy category viagra nebenwirkungen what does azithromycin treat levitra rezeptfrei deutschland is ciprofloxacin a penicillin tamoxifen lawsuits cialis side effects cialis discount viagra for men tamoxifen side effects cialis coupons 2017 cialis website ciprofloxacin 500mg antibiotics side effects azithromycin three times a week canada cialis acyclovir vs valacyclovir cipro for uti ciprofloxacin 250mg vardenafil vs viagra cialis free trial side effects of ciprofloxacin cipro uses what is acyclovir used for tamoxifen therapy escitalopram effets secondaires effects of stopping lexapro suddenly acyclovir 800 mg cialis coupon cialis coupons printable azithromycin medscape side effects of lexapro generic cialis cialis 20mg directions acyclovir for cold sores azithromycin vs erythromycin ciprofloxacin spc azithromycine eg 500 mg bijsluiter cialis dosage recommendations generic levitra vardenafil 20mg cialis 5mg daily cipro side effects in elderly