Nо Air: Provocative Thoughts on Future Mobility

An interview with researched Sven Kesserling about alternative mobility futures

Read intro

An interview with Sven Kesselring

An interview by Irina Lunevich

The 'miracle of flight' is not a miracle any more. More and more people take planes in order to go to work, to visit their friends and relatives, or just to spend a weekend in an unusual place. The future in which everyone is on the move doesn’t seem to be so utopian. This interview focuses not only on our relationships with aero-mobility, but also on infrastructure that supports it and on how air travel impacts social relations and our daily lives on the ground. Researcher Sven Kesselring shares his ideas about how mobility will be transformed in the future and what alternative mobility futures will look like.

Sven Kesselring is a senior researcher at the Institute for Transportation and Director of the mobil.TUM project at the Technische Universität München in Germany. He has published extensively in the field of interdisciplinary mobilities research and co-edited a number of books, including ‘Aeromobilities’ and ‘Tracing Mobilities. Towards a Cosmopolitan Perspective'. He is the founder of the Cosmobilities Network.
Hide intro

In your works you mainly focus on mobility pioneers. However, they constitute just a fraction of society. Is it interesting to study how mobility affects the daily routines of other social groups, such as young people, housewives, elderly people?

Doing research about pioneers is always doing research about the future society. I remember that when we used the term ‘virtual mobility’ for the first time, people in the research center were laughing. When we were conducting our first interviews in 1999 it was really something new to have radio talks on the Internet. However, it has become a part of everyday communication. If we talk about elderly people, for example, at the age of 65, today they use the Internet a lot and it’s totally normal for young people to use FaceTime. One of the big things in my research is the normalization of mobility, the normalization of virtual mobility and digital lifestyles.

It is obvious that more and more people use the Internet all over the world, but can we talk about the normalization of physical mobility? I mean that housewives or elderly people do not travel as often as, for example, businessmen.

It’s totally normal to live in Munich and to have your holidays, for instance, at the Bahamas. People travel to Cuba or Thailand because they like to experience new places. Moreover, living in Munich and never going out of Munich doesn’t mean that your lifestyle isn’t mobility intense, because you produce or consume goods that are being moved around a lot.

2

Communication technologies allow to work together without traveling /​photo: De Balle/​Flickr​.com

If it comes to consumption – all the food, all the clothes that we’re wearing, the electronic devices that we’re buying – everything is based on air travel and logistics. Thus, our life is extremely mobility intense and the whole lifestyle in the Western world is based on extensive travel.

Mobility is considered to be a social good. However, in your articles you write about the ‘mobile risk society’. What are the risks?

On the societal level, of course, there is an enormous risk of CO2 emissions and climate change. Ecological risks are related to individual decisions about where to we travel, how often we travel and how far we travel. Secondly, there are significant health risks related to mobility. People who travel for work get sick more often than people who do not. There are also a lot of social risks, uncertainties and insecurities which mobile workers are facing. They definitely have more freedom and more choices, but they are not a part of micro-​politics within a company. For example, when they stay abroad for a long period of time, there is a question how they can get back to the company or what is going to happen with their careers back home.

Never going out doesn’t mean that your lifestyle isn’t mobility intense, because you produce or consume goods that are being moved around a lot

Are there any ways to adjust to new mobility regimes?

The problem is that mobility in business life is still taken for granted. There are lots of reasons why people travel. If you are signing a contract or if you are building new connections with business partners, it requires lots of trust and face-​to-​face communication. On the other hand, there are a lot of opportunities to work together without travelling. Many companies install equipment for mini-​conferencing or Skype, for example…

However, only a handful of companies ask their employees to replace travelling with virtual mobility, with online communication. Moreover, people who have been working and traveling let us say only for a year, they talk about their mobility as something totally normal. The question ‘Do I really have to travel?’ is not a part of everyday routines.

3

Should we use our travel time to work or to relax? /​Photo: Art Hupy, 1935

If the amount of travel is not going to decrease, what competences and skills should we develop in order to deal with the growing mobility pressure?

I think that people should allow themselves to lock off, to switch off the mobile, not to read e-​mails, to choose immobility… In addition, people have to be more active in fighting for their own rights. They definitely have the right to say ‘no’, to say ‘I have been traveling during the last two weeks, I cannot travel again. I need direct flights. I cannot take a stopover flight, although it is cheaper for the company’.

Another thing is the ability to save yourself from being totally exploited during travel time. When you travel from, let’s say, Moscow to Los-​Angeles, you have to ask yourself if a travel time is a working time when you have to prepare yourself or this is a time when you can relax, read a book or watch a movie. Time-​space compression is really a big issue in these new mobile working relations.

Mobility is not a free choice anymore. It’s something that you have to do

It seems that virtual mobility could become an alternative for physical travel…

In general, more communications equals more reasons to travel. However, it is important to understand how the relations between mobility and immobility and between physical and virtual mobility is going to develop in the future – and it is not only about what the free market directs you to do, but it is also about political decisions. Probably, in 50 years, we are going to have political and legal conditions that will be much more regulating and that will change somehow the privatization of air travel. It will be more economically interesting to replace physical travel with other forms of communication.

Today, we’re observing a significant change in the organization of the global world. Families and friends are connected through technologies and, probably, in the future people will interact in a virtual space. It is different from face-​to-​face interaction, but maybe we will have an opportunity to see facial expressions and body language, to smell people and to have more kinesthetic experience online, which is very different from what basic technologies allow us to do today. I would say that it’s definitely not possible to replace all physical travel by virtual travel, but the relations between mobility and immobility will be re-​configured in a new way.

You said that mobility is already affecting people’s lives, but how it will affect our lives in the future? Some groups of people will stay immobile for various reasons… How this relationship between mobile and immobile groups of people could alter the social structure?

One of the dystopian views on the future society is that mobility and, in particular, air travel, will become accessible only to a very small group of people. It is the mobility of the rich or super rich who are still able to travel around the world, while all the others have to stick to one place. 

On the other hand, we could imagine the future in which just a small group will be forced to travel for work. Thus, mobility is not a free choice anymore. It’s something that you have to do. People who are able to decide if they stay at home or if they go only for short trips have the wealth. So it could be a privilege to decide for your own immobility. If we look at statistics, we can see this trend.

In any case, I am sure we will soon reach some sort of a tipping point when suddenly a different concept of mobility, which is not linked to the physical travel any more, would become predominant and would open completely new perspectives for the society. 

The emergence of low-​cost airlines allowed the inclusion of new social groups into air transportation…

I see a conflict and a dilemma between social equality and ecological sustainability. I think this is the task for our century to solve this problem and get this back into balance. I am also convinced that mobility is a common good, it is not a product as many people in the industry think today.

What we need to find is a policy and an organization of movement that supports less disastrous and less negative forms of mobility. We (now I’m talking about Germany) have policies for trains, for road traffic, for container shipping, for ships on rivers and all this things, but Germany actually does not have an air traffic policy. On the city scale we use a lot of different instruments to control private cars and promote public transport. It is not a taboo any more to talk about limiting mobility. Air travel will be also probably limited in 50 or 100 years from now. 

Still, the amount of air traffic is growing every year. Many airports around the world fail to meet growing traffic demand. How should an airport infrastructure be changed in order to keep up with the increasing number of passengers?

First of all, I have to say that all statistics are political and they always work as an instrument to determine the future. If we adapt infrastructure to estimated travel demand it means that we accept statistical forecasts. It’s not the capacities that have to be adapted to demand, but the other way round: we need to make political decisions about what the demand for air travel should be.

Today, the Munich airport receives around 13 million passengers per year. A travel demand of 40 million travelers per year means an enormous extension of airport infrastructure and all the logistics in the background. But there should be a political decision to limit this growth. We can say: ‘We do not accept more than 25 million passengers per year and this is the infrastructure which we consider as sustainable for our region’. This will have a lot of economic consequences, but it does not mean that the region of Munich will totally fail. It means that companies and stakeholders will have to adapt to the policy.

We should simply think about other opportunities to provide access to air travel in the future.

Are governments and local authorities ready to limit the number of passengers in airports?

Yes, I think so, but not everywhere, as there are a lot of cultural differences between cities and countries. However, there is a discussion about what is acceptable and what is not. If we’re talking about the Central Europe, there is a significant change in the understanding of what planning is today, in comparison with the 1960s, 1970s and 1980s. There is a paradigm shift in a lot of planning processes from “we need to adapt to increasing travel demand in society” to ‘we are actually a part of shaping the mobility of future; we decide what is realistic and what is sustainable’.

4

Inability to keep up with growing traffic demand leads to airport congestions and flight delays/​Photo: Buh Snarf/​Flickr​.com

So, the growth of air traffic increases environmental risks. Alternative fuels might help reducing the impact of the aviation on the environment, but are there any other ways to achieve sort of a balance between sustainability issues and traffic demand?

This is a really complicated question. Airports are the places where different scales of global society are coming together. This requires specific forms of consensus: a balance between the interests of local actors and that of global stakeholders. In addition, we need to think about new sustainability strategies that strengthen the region itself. This could decrease the necessity of traveling. Nowadays, every nation-​state discusses the possibility to build airports even in economically less developed regions. I believe that the increase in the number of small-​scale airports is the way of producing enormous ecological consequences. We should simply think about other opportunities to provide access to air travel in the future.

viagra prices side effects of azithromycin best price viagra finasteride 5mg side effects mayo clinic cialis 5mg cialis generic availability buy levitra lexapro dosage lexapro 10 mg cialis patent expiration withdrawal from lexapro cipro antibiotic acyclovir ointment cialis pills tamoxifen side effects sophia viagra lexapro medication cipro cialis samples overnight what is finasteride used for viagra without a doctor prescription usa azithromycin tablet tamoxifen side effects in women viagra sans ordonnance side effects of lexapro azithromycin for strep throat zovirax for cold sores cipro side effects in elderly lexapro side effects finasteride for hair loss acyclovir dosage for cold sores tamoxifen citrate side effects of ciprofloxacin 500 mg viagra vs cialis vardenafil 20mg cipro antibiotics cheap viagra viagra effects ciprofloxacin bnf where to buy viagra lexapro bula viagra wikipedia cialis sample cialis cost finasteride results cialis or viagra acyclovir for shingles pfizer viagra cialis patent expiration 2017 viagra vs cialis vs levitra levitra 20 mg equipe argentine viagra 9 levitra at walmart acyclovir dosage viagra generico cialis pricing generic for lexapro how does viagra work finasteride vs dutasteride cialis cheap cialis from canada levitra dosage acyclovir side effects what is cipro usually prescribed for viagra 100mg tablets retail price cialis canada tamoxifen side effects of lexapro 10 mg buy cialis online ciprofloxacin 500 viagra kaufen 200 cialis coupon lexapro 20mg cialis website viagra single packs cialis online zoloft vs lexapro finasteride long term effects cealis levitra prices ciprofloxacin spc how long for azithromycin to take effect lowest cialis prices levitra generic lexapro side effects men ciprofloxacin dosage side effects of azithromycin 250 mg viagra coupon generic cialis tadalafil propecia side effects viagra bestellen levitra coupons viagra alternative cialis daily acyclovir 800mg generic lexapro effects of stopping finasteride wholesale cialis escitalopram effets secondaires tamoxifen side effects in women over 55 ciprofloxacin 500mg finasteride reviews cialis price tamoxifen cost ciprofloxacin vardenafil vs viagra viamedic cialis finasteride tablets side effects of cialis cialis dosage viagra generic cialis coupons printable azithromycin 250 mg treatment zithromax tamoxifen lawsuits zovirax pills finasteride and enlarged prostate wellbutrin and lexapro escitalopram 10 mg para que sirve lexapro weight gain levitra 10 mg prezzo generic viagra 100mg viagra natural lexapro vs celexa cialis 5 mg side effects of finasteride generic levitra vardenafil 20mg what is ciprofloxacin used for lexapro 5mg cialis generic tadalafil what is azithromycin used for daily cialis how to wean off lexapro common side effects of ciprofloxacin 500 mg levitra vs viagra cialis vs viagra cialis coupon azithromycin tablets viagra tesco ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg tab azithromycin 500 how does lexapro work finasteride 1mg viagra 100mg cialis canadian pharmacy zithromax antibiotic utilisation viagra discount viagra azithromycin eye drops what is cipro used for ciprofloxacin 500 mg for urinary tract infection cialis 20mg directions viagra uk is ciprofloxacin a penicillin lexapro reviews cialis for men azithromycin 5 day dose pack cialis pills for sale post finasteride syndrome generic cialis at walmart viagra price lexapro overdose azithromycin and alcohol what is cialis tamoxifen therapy acyclovir ointment 5 online cialis cialis ciprofloxacin hydrochloride tamoxifen bijwerkingen cialis 20mg cialis 30 day sample ciprofloxacin 250mg ciprofloxacin side effects acyclovir 200mg acyclovir medication what does finasteride do acyclovir 800 mg azithromycin for pneumonia azithromycin vs erythromycin cialis effects canadian viagra acyclovir 800 mg 5 times a day finasteride for women lexapro and weight gain ciprofloxacin uses finasteride effets secondaires cialis coupons 2017 levitra 20mg cost per pill viagra cost zovirax cream finasteride 5 mg viagra pills finasteride dosage ciprofloxacin dosierung finasteride 5mg escitalopram side effects acyclovir dose levitra 20 mg precio farmacia viagra medicine acyclovir dosing cialis for daily use levitra online lexapro dosing side effects of finasteride 5mg ciprofloxacin used for azithromycin pregnancy side effects of lexapro in women what is acyclovir for is lexapro a controlled substance finasteride efectos secundarios azithromycin class azithromycin three times a week viagra for men how to get off lexapro tamoxifen and weight gain lexapro vs zoloft cialis trial escitalopram nebenwirkungen cialis tadalafil generic levitra viagra en ligne livraison 24h zovirax cipro drug class azithromycin 250 mg azithromycin 500 erfahrungen cialis for sale acyclovir 800 mg for shingles levitra erfahrungen azithromycin 250mg what is lexapro for ciprofloxacin class liquid cialis zithromax 500 mg viagra canada lexapro manufacturer website finasteride side effects in men levitra without a doctor prescription side effects of acyclovir side effects lexapro acyclovir azithromycin side effects cialis generic what does azithromycin treat female viagra how to take cialis weaning off lexapro cialis discount buy levitra online ciprofloxacin hydrochloride ophthalmic ciprofloxacin 250 mg levitra rezeptfrei deutschland thuoc azithromycin azithromycine 250 mg ciprofloxacin side effects in women cialis dosage strengths viagra vs cialis cialis coupon 20 mg cialis side effects viagra costs viagra ohne rezept aus deutschland cheap cialis cialis otc stopping lexapro cipro 500 azithromycin cost revatio vs viagra azithromycin liquid cialis testimonials what is lexapro cost of cialis does lexapro cause weight gain viagra alternatives viagra sex finasteride side effects generic cialis what does ciprofloxacin 500mg treat celexa vs lexapro ciprofloxacin 500mg antibiotics what infections does ciprofloxacin treat viagra receptfritt levitra 20 mg von bayer azithromycin coverage sex viagra for women what is tamoxifen used for cialis professional finasteride 5mg tab over the counter viagra tamoxifen and bone pain herbal viagra viagra without a doctor prescription lexapro benefits for women levitra vs viagra for hardness viagra side effects first few days on lexapro levitra bayer 20mg meilleur prix lexapro para que sirve what is viagra azithromycin z pak how does cialis work viagra online cipro dosage lexapro 10mg cialis without a doctor’s prescription viagra viagra soft canadian cialis how long does viagra last tamoxifen langzeitfolgen side effects of viagra viagra cialis cilias ciprofloxacin 500 mg tabletten generic for cialis generic viagra viagra vs cialis vs levitra lexapro and weight gain in women finasteride 5 mg tab finasteride medication free cialis lexapro what is finasteride viagra on line no prec cipro side effects cialis coupon print lexapro side effects in men ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg order viagra viagra pill viagra on line viagra ohne rezept auf rechnung how to wean off lexapro without withdrawals what is ciprofloxacin what does viagra do azithromycin pediatric dosing cialis alternative ciprofloxacin for dogs azithromycin 500mg azithromycin 250 viagra dosage ciprofloxacin coverage buy generic levitra how does acyclovir work cialis 10 mg ciprofloxacin dose acyclovir 400 mg levitra vs viagra finasteride hair loss acyclovir cream finasteride 5mg side effects azithromycine eg 500 mg bijsluiter ciprofloxacin 500mg tablets when will cialis go generic cialis prices lexapro generic how long for lexapro to work finasteride ciprofloxacin eye drops ciprofloxacin side effects after age 60 cialis coupons azithromycin drug class lexapro generic name lexapro and wellbutrin combination therapy tamoxifen and foods to avoid women viagra cialis coupons from manufacturer ciprofloxacin 500 mg escitalopram 20 mg levitra coupon buy viagra zithromax z-​pak online viagra nolvadex zovirax ointment canada cialis what is escitalopram acyclovir vs valacyclovir cialas buy cialis erectile dysfunction cialis azithromycin medscape what works better than viagra side effects of ciprofloxacin azithromycine side effects of tamoxifen ciprofloxacin ophthalmic solution cialis dosage recommendations cialis on line free viagra cost of viagra discount cialis ciprofloxacin drug class cialis medication what is lexapro used for cialis reviews cialis samples levitra 20 mg cost walmart viagra tablets is azithromycin penicillin what does ciprofloxacin treat viagra nebenwirkungen escitalopram 10 mg azithromycin 500 mg viagra wiki escitalopram oxalate what is ciprofloxacin prescribed for viagra pillen kruidvat natural viagra levitra 20mg cipro dangers ciprofloxacin hcl what is tamoxifen cipro for uti azithromycin 250mg tablets 6 pack tamoxifen interaction cialis voucher acyclovir 400mg azithromycin dosage cialis free trial zithromax dosage antibiotic ciprofloxacin cialis savings card escitalopram buy viagra online price cialis finasteride permanent side effects azithromycin lexapro withdrawal cipro and tendonitis levitra canada viagra cialis pharmacy prices is azithromycin lexapro and weight loss cialis 5mg daily viagra 100 tamoxifen nebenwirkungen what is azithromycin viagra from canada what is acyclovir used for cialis for women cipro uses lexapro coupons cialis copay card azithromycin uses viagra for women is tamoxifen chemotherapy what is cipro cialis patent expiration date extended ciprofloxacin nebenwirkungen viagra activate buying viagra viagra 50mg cialis 20 mg cialis for bph viagra coupons buy generic viagra zovirax dosage lexapro side effects in women what bacteria does ciprofloxacin kill azithromycin for uti ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg side effects viagra tablet viagra for sale pfizer viagra coupons from pfizer cialis vs viagra lexapro vs wellbutrin viagra substitute azithromycin pregnancy category escitalopram 10mg viagra for sale uk how to use viagra levitra prezzo in farmacia lexapro withdrawal symptoms azithromycin without a doctor’s prescription lexapro dosages ciprofloxacin drops cheap levitra cyalis effects of stopping lexapro suddenly what is azithromycin for what is acyclovir acyclovir for cold sores propecia lexapro for anxiety how much does cialis cost cialis 30 day trial coupon viagra 100 mg viagra samples ciprofloxacin 500mg antibiotics side effects