Photo: Andrés García /

Historical Heritage: Preservation as Development

An interview with architect Natalia Dushkina about the ways in which heritage preservation will influence the appearance and texture of future cities

Read intro

An interview with Natalia Dushkina

An interview by Irina Shmeleva and Valeria Tabakova

The preservation of historical heritage is an attempt of a society’s self-identification. We preserve monuments of architecture and culture in order to understand who we are, where we come from and where we are going. It’s impossible to predict the future without considering the theme of heritage preservation, since the relationship between societies created in the past determines those of the present and future. Observing the process of what is preserved and restored in different cities and countries, we can speculate on how things there will be developed. New methods of preservation, new criteria on selecting the heritage, further diversification of types of heritage, even the selective destruction of historical monuments – all this will influence the appearance and texture of future cities.

Natalia Dushkina was born in Moscow into the family of a famous Soviet architect. She is an architect, professor at the Moscow Architectural Institute, and an expert on the protection of architectural heritage. Dushkina is a member of Docomomo and an expert on World Heritage sites at ICOMOS. She is an author of numerous articles and monographs on the history of architecture and historic preservation, published in Russia and abroad.
Hide intro

In 1964, the Venice Charter was accepted, which became a code of professional standards for heritage preservation and restoration. Even though it is widely accepted, it still contains a lot of controversies on how heritage should be restored, and what should be preserved. Why?

This document was created at the crest of the wave of post-​WWII reconstruction, in 1964. Europe acknowledged that everything that was destroyed should be reconstructed as soon as possible. It was important from the moral and economic points of view. It seemed necessary to do and to show that all could be restored as it was before, to show it to the people who survived the war. However, reconstruction was done in huge hurry, and it demonstrated a lot of negative examples of renovation.


Restored architecture of the “White city”, Tel-​Aviv, Israel /​Photo: Andrew Nash /​Flickr​.com

That’s why the Venice Charter was born. It is based on negative experiences of quick renovation of historic areas. The Venice Charter states: ‘It is our duty to hand them on in the full richness of their authenticity’. What does it mean? We should remember that we are temporary users of the valuable things that we have inherited. We are the people who can ensure their preservation and transfer them forward into the future. In a historical perspective we live in extremely tiny moments of time. From the pyramids to the Eiffel tower, everything made by humans are the tracks which define human life. If you demolish them, a part of human life will be erased.

Authenticity is a key definition for understanding what heritage preservation means. However, it is also the most controversial. On one hand, authenticity now has an ephemeral, outdated definition. Many modern architects say: ‘Let’s build on top of it, or attach something to it, it won’t be worse’. On the other hand, everyone understands that authenticity has been altered. What exists now will be the subject of a new culture. When I hear discussions about preserving a building by way of destroying and rebuilding it from scratch, I understand that it doesn’t relate to restoration at all. It’s ridiculous to call it as method of conservation.

You can’t oppose development to conservation. They’re not antagonistic

There is one more controversial idea. ‘The city isn’t a museum, it has to develop’. Cities are always developing! You can’t oppose development to conservation, they’re not antagonistic. It is very important to understand that preservation is part of development.

In Russian context, which role does preservation play in processes of cultural development?

Russia has its own specifics. There is the desire to get money from a building immediately, to find a way to instant wealth. There was a post-​Soviet period of wild capitalism, everything was changing rapidly. This challenged heritage, since old objects are concentrated in the very center of the city, in the most desirable areas. If somebody invests in the center of the city, the most expensive part, it must have the highest profit – it’s a rule dictated by money.

In reality, a restoration project should have a long-​term payback period, approximately 15 – 20 years. However we can see the examples where large, famous companies get revenue from a restoration after 5 – 7 years. That is impossible in case of real restoration. Thus we understand what is restoration and what is repairment.

Western countries have similar problems, but at least there are specific institutions which were able to create schemes and tools to resist these conditions. In Moscow we have very weak institutions of preservation. As soon as a conflict arises, the decision is escalated and made by the person with authority and money. Nevertheless, this is a learning process. A lot of new good, positive trends appear, which signify that there is light at the end of the tunnel.


Graffiti reproduction of work by artist D. Prigov, microrayon Belyaevo, Moscow, Russia (photo by Chistova Margaria /​ag​.mos​.ru

What are these trends?

These are not really trends, more likely methodologies, based financially between the state and the private sector. The same companies which refurbish buildings instead of restoring them introduce a correct model: association of state and private investment aimed to restore historical objects. Keeping in mind the size of our country and the terrible condition in which most heritage is maintained, the only way to preserve historical objects is to use private capital.

A lot of economic programs are developed just for that: projects for public restoration, crowd funding, private investments and so on. Moreover, a recent addition to Federal Law #73 ‘On Heritage Preservation’ introduced an important point benefits for the investor. In my opinion, that is enough to attract private capital, but only if the investor is well educated and cultural and understands the importance of heritage preservation. Otherwise, the restoration project will fail.

In addition, the position of civil society has great importance. There some positive trends also can be seen. For example, our Moscow ‘Archnadzor’ is a necessary organization; it is a real patriotic movement, in the best sense of the word.

Speaking about trends in heritage preservation, is important to mention The White City in Tel-​Aviv. In the process of restoration, the owners were allowed to build up several stories on top of historical buildings. After that, the city started to bloom. What do you think about this project?

Tel Aviv as a city went through several stages of fading away. Due to the climate and wars during the 20th century it was turning into a terrible gray crust. There wasn’t any restoration, just layers cement to smooth the damages. The city was terribly distorted. A new company popped up that understood that this city is not only the heritage and symbol of Zionism, but a symbol of the nation. The state had no money for restoration, so some economic schemes had to be launched in order to attract attention to restoration.

Nitza Szmuk, who at the time was the head of the heritage protection department, understood that the money can only be taken from the owners of historical houses themselves. But she had to offer them something in exchange. They created the concept that you mentioned: accept funding from private owners and restore their buildings, but allow them to build several floors on top on those houses, to make the payload bigger. The owner got a profit from that. This is a method I call ‘putting hats on’.

The city was restored. Nitza Szmuk performed a miracle. Historical buildings were reconstructed in a quality manner and with good details, and – the most important thing – the restoration has created an amazing effect: people realized that these buildings with ‘hats’ are very attractive from an aesthetic point of view – they represent national identity. The district became a fancy one, since it’s located in the center of the city. The word ‘fancy’ is not a random one. When a historical object becomes fancy, it immediately installs itself on strong legs, gets a second life. This happened in Tel-​Aviv. The same thing happened in Berlin, when it became fancy to buy or rent an apartment in worker’s districts.

London morning sunrise. London eye, County Hall, Westminster Bridge, Big Ben and Houses of Parliament.

Ferris wheel “The London eye”, built in the historical district of London, UK

Speaking of unusual approaches to heritage preservation, or absolutely new forms of heritage: what do you think about preservation on unobvious types of objects?

Not only glossy things are valuable. The project of Belyaevo’s preservation is an example. We are clear on understanding that a church of the 18th century or the Shukhov Tower have certain value due to their uniqueness. The microrayon Belyaevo is not unique, it is typical, and that’s why it’s hard to distinguish its value. However, a nice landscape and specific coziness has formed in Belyaevo over the years. A closer look shows us a special environment that made its mark on the people living there. Recently, one of Belyaevo houses had a graffiti painted on the wall – a replica of artist Dmitriy Prigov’s work, who was living in the area. This stunning picture «АЯ» refers to human ego throughout the phrase ‘not you, not he, not they, but ME’. In fact it means what about me?’

We should remember that we are temporary users of the valuable things that we have inherited

I do not know if it is possible for this type of heritage to receive the recognition of UNESCO World Heritage. Most likely at this moment it is practically impossible, since even some of Le Corbusier’s projects are not covered. However, this project defines a direction of conversation, that each generation leave behind its own values, and that they should be subsequently respected.

Nowadays you have to literally fight for each historical object. Why?

First of all, the pyramid of values has been turned upside down. In past, and even in 20th century, people had certain humanitarian, spiritual values. Nowadays this pyramid of values is crowned by money. Profit becomes more important than professional, religious or any other value.

Second: society changed the way it sees reality. The intensity of visualization in the world has reached a crazy level, now it’s all about the picture. Before, we had a comprehensive vision of the world, now everything is split to fragments of mosaic. This is also corresponds to the preservation of history. Society needs picture perfection, beauty, glamour; society doesn’t need ruins, doesn’t need archaeology.

In order to get money it is necessary to create a completed thing. That’s why the world has completely wild examples, when someone starts to reconstruct the archaeological fragments, building something on top, and by that – killing archeology itself.

There’s an ongoing process of completing the Parthenon. For example: Tsaritsyno Park in Moscow. People like pictures, but no one knows who the architect was – nor Kazakov nor Bazhenov – nor who Catherine the Great was and what happened there between them. They like this place, because first of all it is clean, and there are lots of features and a completed picture can be seen. This park is a tool to get profit. That is ‘presentation’ of heritage, not preservation.

Another example is London. UNESCO has named London as worst example of architecture preservation experience. The fact is that London is the commercial center of the world now, and what is happening there directly affects the rest of the cities worldwide. In St. Petersburg and Moscow, the first argument, which is given in discussion regarding destruction of the historical center, is an appeal to London: ‘Why can London do it and we can’t? We want to be London too’.

All these aspects raise the question of professionalism; in the modern world this kind of thing should depend on professionals.

What types of professionals are required today?

I think that professionals have to be more independent. This may sound naïve, but nevertheless, I think that both construction and architectural businesses can be built on top of mutual agreement between all parties, and be sustained as sources of profit and at the same time provide goodness to society. Many architects have dominating egos and are crazy about their own work, they want to implement their projects without taking into account any heritage institutions.I admire this position, but times have changed, thanks to the emergence of powerful heritage institutions.


Rem Koolhaas explains that over time humanity builds and preserves more and more objects of heritage, at the CRONOCAOS exhibition in 2010, Venice, Italy /​Photo source: Designboom

In fact, there’s ongoing battle for the market between those who restore, and conserve the city and architects who built it. Remember, the first Strelka Institute studio with Rem Koolhaas was about heritage – it is the same desire to refocus architects onto the preservation field and to be the first in this market.

Even some of Le Corbusier’s projects are not covered by UNESCO protection

He is intelligent – that’s why he is appealing, and at the same time scary. It is obviously necessary to oppose him, because he represents a more business, modernist approach to the preservation. He doesn’t reject creative destruction; for him it is sometimes necessary to represent the classical, conservative approach in society in order to reach a balance. With him you can reach a consensus. With an intelligent man it is always possible to find a common platform.

What will happen with preservation in the future, in 20 or 40 years?

After all, from a development perspective, the forecast for the 21st century is not furious development and expansion of development, but actually the opposite. We will be confronted with problems of ecology, demand for green architecture; we produce more than we consume and preservation is related to this by elaboration and filling of what already exists. We can’t destroy any longer, because there is no place to store such huge amount of waste. Where did they put all the trash from the demolished Hotel Russia? We have to stop destroying and fix and develop the things that already exist.

cialis coupon print when will cialis go generic azithromycine cialis for men ciprofloxacin side effects in women ciprofloxacin ophthalmic solution ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg tab cipro antibiotic is azithromycin penicillin what is azithromycin used for acyclovir 800 mg where to buy viagra zovirax pills what works better than viagra wholesale cialis cipro 500 cialis patent expiration best price viagra pfizer viagra what does ciprofloxacin treat cialis tadalafil side effects of ciprofloxacin 500 mg generic cialis at walmart finasteride vs dutasteride cialis generic viamedic cialis canadian cialis azithromycin uses side effects of viagra acyclovir for cold sores what is finasteride used for acyclovir price cialis what infections does ciprofloxacin treat buy cialis online female viagra cialis professional cialis 20mg acyclovir for shingles cialis samples overnight ciprofloxacin hydrochloride ophthalmic acyclovir 200mg finasteride effets secondaires cialis 5mg daily liquid cialis generic viagra erectile dysfunction cialis how to wean off lexapro lexapro bula azithromycin 500 mg lexapro dosages ciprofloxacin side effects after age 60 how does lexapro work side effects of ciprofloxacin buy levitra online cialis side effects buy viagra azithromycin without a doctor’s prescription lexapro withdrawal tamoxifen and weight gain cipro uses azithromycin 250 mg treatment cialis pricing escitalopram 20 mg utilisation viagra viagra nebenwirkungen ciprofloxacin drops viagra tablet ciprofloxacin 500mg antibiotics side effects how does cialis work antibiotic ciprofloxacin zithromax antibiotic azithromycin liquid levitra erfahrungen ciprofloxacin 500 mg tabletten levitra prezzo in farmacia zovirax dosage cialis daily cialis 5mg levitra vs viagra lexapro and weight loss how to wean off lexapro without withdrawals viagra samples stopping lexapro how much does cialis cost azithromycin pediatric dosing levitra bayer 20mg meilleur prix azithromycin side effects what is tamoxifen used for ciprofloxacin cyalis zithromax 500 mg viagra side effects viagra soft side effects of azithromycin 250 mg viagra coupons azithromycin coverage viagra on line no prec finasteride 5mg side effects mayo clinic viagra substitute ciprofloxacin side effects acyclovir dosing viagra medicine what is azithromycin cialis online lexapro overdose cialis samples discount viagra viagra for men finasteride side effects in men lexapro vs celexa finasteride for hair loss lexapro 5mg cialis pills viagra for sale uk viagra alternative finasteride efectos secundarios is azithromycin how does viagra work propecia viagra pill ciprofloxacin hydrochloride cialis testimonials lexapro side effects cost of cialis levitra vs viagra azithromycin eye drops lexapro for anxiety lexapro medication cipro dangers cialis pharmacy prices herbal viagra how does acyclovir work azithromycin tablet what is lexapro zovirax cream zithromax dosage what is cipro cialis patent expiration date extended cialis voucher order viagra finasteride 5mg tab free cialis finasteride permanent side effects zoloft vs lexapro ciprofloxacin 500 mg viagra kaufen viagra wikipedia lexapro ciprofloxacin dosierung what is cialis azithromycin drug class does lexapro cause weight gain viagra dosage what is ciprofloxacin ciprofloxacin 500mg tablets side effects lexapro tamoxifen nebenwirkungen viagra activate cialis 20mg directions finasteride for women lexapro coupons buy generic levitra cialis copay card lexapro manufacturer website tamoxifen bijwerkingen cialis prices ciprofloxacin drug class lowest cialis prices tamoxifen and bone pain cialis price side effects of azithromycin common side effects of ciprofloxacin 500 mg side effects of finasteride lexapro side effects in men finasteride side effects acyclovir 800 mg for shingles cialis dosage strengths tamoxifen langzeitfolgen viagra 100 mg thuoc azithromycin acyclovir 400mg side effects of lexapro in women daily cialis viagra 100mg tablets retail price cheap viagra cialis coupon 20 mg acyclovir side effects escitalopram effets secondaires escitalopram 10 mg online viagra cialis withdrawal from lexapro buying viagra cialis trial ciprofloxacin used for ciprofloxacin dosage levitra 10 mg prezzo cialis on line cialis canada nolvadex ciprofloxacin class tamoxifen cost viagra alternatives cialis vs viagra cipro for uti viagra costs acyclovir 400 mg cealis how to use viagra ciprofloxacin 250 mg levitra 20mg cialis sample azithromycin dosage lexapro and weight gain in women azithromycin pregnancy category 9 levitra at walmart ciprofloxacin nebenwirkungen azithromycin 250mg online cialis azithromycin cost cipro antibiotics azithromycin z pak ciprofloxacin dose generic for cialis levitra online cheap levitra azithromycin 250 azithromycin for strep throat effects of stopping finasteride lexapro and wellbutrin combination therapy cialis 30 day trial coupon canadian viagra buy levitra ciprofloxacin spc lexapro generic viagra for sale viagra cialis cialas canada cialis ciprofloxacin 500 ciprofloxacin coverage levitra 20 mg how long for lexapro to work cialis generic tadalafil tamoxifen citrate acyclovir ointment viagra coupon tamoxifen side effects cialis pills for sale side effects of cialis viagra receptfritt viagra vs cialis viagra prices zovirax for cold sores cialis for bph cialis patent expiration 2017 lexapro weight gain what is lexapro used for viagra for women levitra vs viagra for hardness ciprofloxacin 500mg antibiotics side effects of lexapro viagra en ligne livraison 24h lexapro benefits for women pfizer viagra coupons from pfizer zovirax ointment generic lexapro acyclovir medication lexapro generic name tamoxifen side effects in women azithromycin pregnancy finasteride 1mg viagra vs cialis vs levitra what does ciprofloxacin 500mg treat levitra prices side effects of tamoxifen generic levitra vardenafil 20mg buy cialis cialis 5 mg ciprofloxacin hcl cipro side effects in elderly levitra 20 mg von bayer azithromycine eg 500 mg bijsluiter tamoxifen lawsuits azithromycin 250mg tablets 6 pack generic viagra 100mg azithromycin tablets viagra 100mg what is cipro used for viagra natural ciprofloxacin uses cialis website how long does viagra last women viagra azithromycin vs erythromycin ciprofloxacin bnf vardenafil vs viagra viagra vs cialis sex viagra for women vardenafil 20mg escitalopram 10mg acyclovir dose cialis effects ciprofloxacin 500 mg for urinary tract infection viagra wiki ciprofloxacin 500mg finasteride tablets azithromycin 500mg viagra from canada generic levitra azithromycin class cialis discount how to get off lexapro discount cialis azithromycin 500 erfahrungen over the counter viagra canada viagra viagra on line finasteride medication viagra ohne rezept aus deutschland tamoxifen side effects in women over 55 acyclovir 800 mg 5 times a day tamoxifen therapy finasteride 5 mg what is lexapro for what is ciprofloxacin prescribed for wellbutrin and lexapro equipe argentine viagra escitalopram nebenwirkungen viagra generic viagra 100 what is azithromycin for tamoxifen and foods to avoid cialis 30 day sample azithromycin for uti finasteride 5mg side effects viagra price what is acyclovir used for how long for azithromycin to take effect post finasteride syndrome effects of stopping lexapro suddenly viagra effects cialis coupons 2017 finasteride hair loss cipro dosage acyclovir cream propecia side effects zithromax z-​pak cialis generic availability levitra dosage side effects of finasteride 5mg side effects of acyclovir what does viagra do cialis medication acyclovir ointment 5 buy viagra online levitra rezeptfrei deutschland lexapro dosage cialis reviews what does finasteride do viagra pills lexapro 10mg cialis or viagra azithromycine 250 mg lexapro vs wellbutrin is lexapro a controlled substance azithromycin for pneumonia generic cialis escitalopram side effects azithromycin medscape cialis vs viagra is tamoxifen chemotherapy viagra pillen kruidvat first few days on lexapro generic cialis tadalafil lexapro and weight gain generic for lexapro cialis dosage recommendations how to take cialis viagra sex viagra vs cialis vs levitra natural viagra acyclovir dosage for cold sores azithromycin 500 finasteride and enlarged prostate viagra ohne rezept auf rechnung what is tamoxifen finasteride results cialis coupons ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg lexapro 20mg ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg side effects ciprofloxacin 250mg finasteride dosage cialis coupons printable buy generic viagra cialis cheap viagra 50mg viagra bestellen weaning off lexapro cipro drug class free viagra lexapro para que sirve azithromycin three times a week is ciprofloxacin a penicillin cialis canadian pharmacy cilias zovirax azithromycin 250 mg viagra tesco levitra coupon revatio vs viagra what is cipro usually prescribed for viagra generico tamoxifen interaction cheap cialis azithromycin and alcohol cipro side effects levitra viagra sans ordonnance what is finasteride cipro azithromycin 5 day dose pack lexapro side effects in women ciprofloxacin eye drops cialis savings card cialis 10 mg acyclovir vs valacyclovir viagra without a doctor prescription usa what is escitalopram cialis coupon cialis for daily use what bacteria does ciprofloxacin kill escitalopram levitra coupons levitra 20 mg cost walmart viagra uk what is acyclovir lexapro withdrawal symptoms lexapro 10 mg levitra 20 mg precio farmacia cialis for sale cialis alternative viagra single packs cialis cost zithromax tamoxifen what does azithromycin treat cialis otc cialis without a doctor’s prescription viagra without a doctor prescription lexapro side effects men cialis for women lexapro reviews side effects of lexapro 10 mg ciprofloxacin for dogs cialis coupons from manufacturer 200 cialis coupon levitra generic escitalopram oxalate escitalopram 10 mg para que sirve what is ciprofloxacin used for acyclovir 800mg cialis dosage levitra without a doctor prescription celexa vs lexapro cialis free trial viagra cost of viagra viagra online viagra canada what is viagra acyclovir dosage azithromycin finasteride reviews viagra cost cipro and tendonitis cialis 20 mg finasteride lexapro dosing viagra tablets lexapro vs zoloft sophia viagra levitra 20mg cost per pill cialis from canada finasteride 5mg finasteride 5 mg tab finasteride long term effects what is acyclovir for