Temporary tent city setup for 2 million Muslims on pilgrim (haj). Mecca, Saudi Arabia / Al Jazeera / flickr.com

Future Settlement

An interview with Vladimir Nikitin on how the human settlements will change by Anna Kamyshan

Read intro

An interview with Vladimir Nikitin

An interview by Anna Kamyshan

When thinking of constructing models of the future, I ask myself: how can we treat the present with the required portion of alienation and reflect on it to create a qualitatively new model of the future? One possible approach to designing models for the future is a system-thought-activity approach developed by G. Shchedrovitsky and his students at the Moscow Methodological Club. This unique approach allows us to analyse a wide range of socio-cultural and intellectual phenomena and develop almost any system of mental activity. One of the followers of MMC and a supporter of this approach is Vladimir Nikitin, a member of the methodological movement since 1978. He is also one of the founders of the international open project Foundation For Future, the Togliatti Academy of Management and the Kiev Business Lyceum, an international consultant on organisational changes, Doctor of Cultural Studies and a Ph.D. in Architecture.

Nikitin is also an author of the book "Founding the Other," in which he discusses the future of cities and new types of settlement. In his other book, "The principle of the city: an organisational concept", he considers the genesis of settlements and how to work with a city. I was interested to hear his ideas about new types of settlement, new citizens and their forms of consciousness, on the management and organisation of the cities of the future.
Hide intro

How do you see the settlement system in the future? What will define it, and are there already noticeable trends towards this at the moment?

In the future there will be more forms of urban life itself: cities are not similar to modern by their way of life and relationships between people.

First of all it is variety. There will be no mass movement towards some special kind of cities of the future. There will be more forms of urban life itself: cities dissimilar to the contemporary city in their way of life and the relationships between people in them. There will be technologically advanced centres for the fast life and slower paced cities for more relaxed people, “human-​anthill cities” for the production of human material, and the “instant” city. For example, there are more and more of these human anthill cities in Asia. China is trying to create tens of megalopolises. The prototype of an instant city is a festival-​town or a world exhibition. The city develops for a short time and then disappears without a trace. City in the network is a separate topic. In general, there is no unified future for everybody. There are many different ones. We have moved into an era of rapid time, but it does not mean that other ways of living and thinking would disappear.

Very interesting… And who are these cities for?

City is a special form of thinking, vertical and multi-​level, as opposed to complex shapes “grass roots” in the village. Today to create a city means to create new forms of thinking.

There will be more cities but less city people. A city is a special form of thinking, vertical and multi-​level, as opposed to the complex “grass roots” forms in the village. The city-​shell will be filled with the carriers of rural and nomadic consciousness. Just as it was before, but the rate will be different. Therefore it is unclear how to massively produce new citizens. The Chinese, for instance, offer mass training in hieroglyphics and ancient literature to complicate and change the form of rural consciousness. To create a city today means creating new forms of thinking.

A Consciousness-​Based Education” by David Lynch Foundation in a Peru school /​Jdontfight /​flickr​.com

In your book, suggesting a future settlement system, you mention the end of the institution of self-​government, while many other people talk about participatory methods in the city government of the future. Who will manage and organise all the processes?

Cities will remain, and state, probably will not

This the way in which cities will be distinguished from each other. In some places self-​government will be retained, in others the founders of a city will govern its life, elsewhere it might be managed by lot… If the infrastructure is to be managed through self-​organisation, other aspects can be managed in quite a different way. Administration is not the only form of organisation of life in the city and not the best. Since 1929, our city became state-​run and lost its budget and rights. From then on, the role of state for city life became exaggerated. However, even if it doesn’t last forever, our city lives in the administrative reality of today. Cities will remain, however, while the state probably will not.

How can we resolve conflicts in the cities by management/​organisation?

Usually communal conflicts and conflicts of interests shape the content of urban policy. However, they are not resolved at this level but are only extinguished for a time. It is important to be able to transform a conflict of interest into a discussion on content and meaning. Unfortunately it rarely happens. In fact we often do not understand such simple things as, for example, the fact that tourism provides income and jobs, but destroys the emotional life of the city, its soul. We work with fragments rather than the whole. And who will speak on behalf of the city? The more successful management there is in a city, the less sense is preserved.

Formation of ways to work with the city. Materials from the book “The principle of the city: an organisational concept” /​Courtesy of V.Nikitin

Cruise boat Ruby Princess arrives in Venice / Dan Davison / flickr.com

Cruise boat Ruby Princess arrives in Venice /​Dan Davison /​flickr​.com

Nowadays the professionals involved in the development of cities often occupy a position of global experts. They use similar solutions to different contexts in their practice. Who do you think will be engaged with the city in future, who is going to design it?

The more successful management in a city, the less sense city keeps

The period of professionals has, for better or worse, ended, although there is still some time in which they are really needed. The city begins with a discussion of its meaning: why do people come there and stay to live? How will the resources get there, or how will they be produced? Only after understanding all this can the professionals of infrastructure be brought in… City is primarily a symbolic structure rather than functional one. Poetry in those terms is more powerful way to think of the city than the design. Even technology is only a tool for symbolic imagination of the city and it is not worth to rely on the fact that the future of cities depends on technology.

Formation of ways to work with the city. Materials from the book “The principle of the city: an organisational concept” /​Courtesy of V.Nikitin

You are one of the founders of the international open source project Foundation For Future, the purpose of which is “to create a stratum of people whose thinking is directed to the future…” How can you create this stratum of people?

Thinking people disappear. To think, it is necessary to feel and imagine. Most people live in the world of opinions and myths but only quite a small part of us have a position based on reasons and principles. We are trying to create people, bearers of ideas, operating with visions and organisation of life, practices and forms of urban consciousness.

What are the functions of these thinking people, the new elite of the future? Will they have any kind of special rights in the city? Power?

An “elite” has duties rather than rights. Usually, elite people have public authority rather than power. This is because those who are given power care primarily about its preservation, and not about society.

Thinking about the city as a space of national and global policies, what can be demonstrated by the present events in Kiev?

It can testify to the fact that in Ukraine, cities still remain. After all, the main resource and product of urban life is freedom.

If we turn to the theory of genesis of urban settlement that you have developed, what stage is now Kiev now at? What about Moscow?

Not Kiev and Moscow, but Russia and Ukraine. Ukraine is undergoing the phase of destroying its industrial and settlement system and no movement to anything else is yet discernible. Only Kiev and a couple of cities are found on the global level. Russia has already discussed the new formats of settlement, primarily for the North and Siberia, but still there is little progress.

And the last question: you say that after the global city we come to the personal city. What does this mean and when can we expect this? What other unpublished predictions do you have?

Predictions are meaningless in our fast-​moving spontaneous world. The future is that what negates the present. The personal city is a city for me, real and virtual, a town shared between my relatives and myself. Anyway, I won’t talk yet about its creation, I just have a premonition of it. The notion of a home, leisure and working time, and resettlement is in the changing process, and the city is derived by these changes. We require a global view on resettlement, on the world of mankind in general.

lexapro benefits for women finasteride permanent side effects cialis for daily use finasteride for women finasteride tablets is ciprofloxacin a penicillin 200 cialis coupon how long for azithromycin to take effect celexa vs lexapro ciprofloxacin coverage lexapro withdrawal symptoms nolvadex ciprofloxacin uses utilisation viagra viagra 100 mg cialis alternative cipro antibiotic ciprofloxacin dosage female viagra cialis canada lexapro and weight gain in women finasteride vs dutasteride tamoxifen nebenwirkungen zovirax dosage tamoxifen and bone pain levitra 20 mg cost walmart viagra canada how to wean off lexapro propecia side effects finasteride reviews buy viagra what is acyclovir cialis otc levitra vs viagra cialis coupons 2017 zovirax pills tamoxifen interaction acyclovir for cold sores levitra vs viagra for hardness finasteride 5mg side effects cialis patent expiration 2017 cialis dosage viagra for women viagra 100mg azithromycine eg 500 mg bijsluiter lexapro and weight loss generic lexapro acyclovir cream azithromycin eye drops cheap viagra azithromycin side effects lexapro dosages tamoxifen and foods to avoid acyclovir 800 mg for shingles side effects of acyclovir generic cialis lexapro weight gain ciprofloxacin 500mg zithromax 500 mg cialis samples ciprofloxacin drops tamoxifen side effects in women over 55 cialis copay card viagra alternative cipro side effects finasteride side effects in men tamoxifen therapy azithromycin liquid what does ciprofloxacin treat zovirax how does viagra work azithromycin 500 acyclovir dose zoloft vs lexapro cialis price canadian viagra cialis dosage strengths what does viagra do lexapro 5mg side effects of azithromycin 250 mg finasteride 5 mg tab levitra dosage cialis pills is azithromycin azithromycin for pneumonia viagra single packs ciprofloxacin 500mg antibiotics side effects finasteride 1mg escitalopram side effects ciprofloxacin eye drops azithromycin pregnancy cipro side effects in elderly cialis coupons viagra generico levitra bayer 20mg meilleur prix lexapro dosing acyclovir 800 mg how does acyclovir work acyclovir viagra price ciprofloxacin for dogs cialis testimonials what is ciprofloxacin used for what is finasteride used for cipro drug class cialis patent expiration cialis coupon 20 mg cialis for women what is viagra viagra kaufen what is azithromycin for lexapro vs zoloft lexapro free viagra cialis for bph ciprofloxacin hcl cialis 20 mg levitra prezzo in farmacia viagra for sale viagra prices how long for lexapro to work side effects of viagra levitra coupons what is cipro usually prescribed for viagra vs cialis vs levitra levitra 20 mg von bayer levitra 20mg cilias herbal viagra buy generic levitra lexapro 10mg liquid cialis where to buy viagra cialis side effects viagra online viagra pill tamoxifen finasteride efectos secundarios cialis 5mg daily zithromax z-​pak cialis cipro antibiotics finasteride side effects natural viagra what is ciprofloxacin acyclovir 400mg antibiotic ciprofloxacin cialis vs viagra women viagra lexapro generic acyclovir medication lexapro side effects in women azithromycin 250 mg treatment ciprofloxacin ophthalmic solution viagra soft sex viagra for women levitra rezeptfrei deutschland viagra tesco is lexapro a controlled substance acyclovir 200mg buy levitra side effects of tamoxifen lexapro side effects lowest cialis prices revatio vs viagra viamedic cialis side effects of lexapro 10 mg cialis pricing cialis samples overnight side effects of lexapro in women daily cialis cheap cialis viagra effects azithromycin without a doctor’s prescription what is lexapro acyclovir side effects azithromycin coverage wellbutrin and lexapro cipro dangers viagra vs cialis viagra on line tamoxifen and weight gain cialis 5 mg ciprofloxacin 250 mg cialis generic tadalafil viagra from canada viagra uk viagra en ligne livraison 24h how to get off lexapro free cialis cialis coupon print canada viagra effects of stopping finasteride side effects of lexapro online viagra buy levitra online cialis website cialis pharmacy prices cialis 30 day trial coupon what is ciprofloxacin prescribed for stopping lexapro tamoxifen citrate levitra vs viagra viagra pillen kruidvat viagra tablets ciprofloxacin 500 mg tabletten cialis dosage recommendations what is azithromycin tamoxifen langzeitfolgen is azithromycin penicillin is tamoxifen chemotherapy cialis 10 mg side effects of ciprofloxacin 500 mg cipro dosage tamoxifen bijwerkingen cialis without a doctor’s prescription ciprofloxacin used for cialis online what bacteria does ciprofloxacin kill ciprofloxacin spc cialis cheap cialis coupons from manufacturer viagra 100 acyclovir ointment azithromycin 250mg what is cialis cialis medication viagra pills generic for lexapro acyclovir 800mg escitalopram oxalate how does cialis work azithromycin tablets cipro for uti what is escitalopram azithromycine azithromycin 250 what is tamoxifen used for cialis 20mg directions ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg azithromycin 250 mg lexapro overdose generic cialis tadalafil buy generic viagra zovirax for cold sores discount viagra lexapro and weight gain azithromycin 500 erfahrungen what works better than viagra viagra cialis viagra sex viagra for men viagra wikipedia ciprofloxacin hydrochloride ophthalmic viagra samples discount cialis azithromycin uses cialis voucher what does finasteride do does lexapro cause weight gain escitalopram nebenwirkungen buy cialis online cialis pills for sale azithromycin class generic levitra cialis vs viagra 9 levitra at walmart order viagra cealis cialis tadalafil side effects lexapro levitra 10 mg prezzo best price viagra lexapro and wellbutrin combination therapy cialis generic availability acyclovir 400 mg vardenafil 20mg canada cialis finasteride medication viagra coupon escitalopram 20 mg viagra vs cialis vs levitra viagra vs cialis finasteride long term effects side effects of finasteride 5mg azithromycin 250mg tablets 6 pack weaning off lexapro ciprofloxacin 500mg antibiotics pfizer viagra coupons from pfizer cialis sample finasteride dosage azithromycin for strep throat what is acyclovir used for zithromax viagra ohne rezept aus deutschland zithromax dosage side effects of azithromycin when will cialis go generic acyclovir 800 mg 5 times a day lexapro vs celexa finasteride and enlarged prostate cialis 30 day sample azithromycin 500mg acyclovir for shingles what is lexapro used for ciprofloxacin 500 mg for urinary tract infection viagra side effects viagra generic viagra receptfritt buying viagra viagra natural finasteride for hair loss azithromycin pediatric dosing online cialis lexapro 10 mg wholesale cialis lexapro reviews levitra 20mg cost per pill withdrawal from lexapro azithromycin cost cialis cost thuoc azithromycin pfizer viagra price cialis levitra prices ciprofloxacin drug class lexapro side effects men ciprofloxacin side effects in women escitalopram 10 mg para que sirve buy cialis finasteride 5mg finasteride effets secondaires acyclovir vs valacyclovir cipro and tendonitis cialis for men cialis from canada common side effects of ciprofloxacin 500 mg escitalopram 10 mg cialis discount cialis coupon cialis coupons printable lexapro withdrawal tamoxifen cost levitra without a doctor prescription what is acyclovir for cheap levitra viagra without a doctor prescription usa finasteride results how to wean off lexapro without withdrawals zithromax antibiotic viagra cost lexapro coupons azithromycin 500 mg lexapro generic name finasteride 5 mg viagra cipro levitra coupon equipe argentine viagra cialis daily generic for cialis viagra costs lexapro para que sirve viagra medicine tamoxifen lawsuits escitalopram effets secondaires azithromycin pregnancy category ciprofloxacin nebenwirkungen levitra generic how to use viagra cipro 500 side effects of cialis ciprofloxacin 250mg azithromycine 250 mg cialis patent expiration date extended generic viagra 100mg azithromycin for uti cyalis ciprofloxacin dose what is finasteride cialis 20mg ciprofloxacin class cialis prices ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg side effects ciprofloxacin hydrochloride azithromycin z pak acyclovir ointment 5 tamoxifen side effects in women finasteride 5mg tab escitalopram 10mg what infections does ciprofloxacin treat ciprofloxacin 500 mg cialis professional how does lexapro work viagra tablet viagra sans ordonnance lexapro medication lexapro for anxiety azithromycin 5 day dose pack viagra substitute what is tamoxifen ciprofloxacin dosierung viagra without a doctor prescription how much does cialis cost acyclovir dosing over the counter viagra what does azithromycin treat azithromycin viagra activate cialis 5mg ciprofloxacin side effects after age 60 azithromycin and alcohol generic cialis at walmart viagra alternatives effects of stopping lexapro suddenly cialis effects what does ciprofloxacin 500mg treat cost of viagra side effects of finasteride levitra online azithromycin dosage how to take cialis erectile dysfunction cialis post finasteride syndrome viagra ohne rezept auf rechnung generic viagra cipro uses first few days on lexapro what is cipro finasteride hair loss azithromycin medscape azithromycin tablet viagra 100mg tablets retail price cialis or viagra ciprofloxacin 500 propecia buy viagra online ciprofloxacin tamoxifen side effects cialis reviews levitra 20 mg precio farmacia viagra coupons viagra on line no prec viagra wiki canadian cialis viagra dosage cialis on line escitalopram cialis generic side effects of ciprofloxacin levitra how long does viagra last levitra 20 mg lexapro 20mg finasteride 5mg side effects mayo clinic acyclovir dosage levitra erfahrungen cialis for sale cialas viagra 50mg azithromycin drug class finasteride what is azithromycin used for cialis free trial viagra bestellen viagra nebenwirkungen lexapro dosage cialis trial cialis canadian pharmacy lexapro side effects in men acyclovir dosage for cold sores sophia viagra what is cipro used for ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg tab ciprofloxacin side effects ciprofloxacin bnf vardenafil vs viagra cialis savings card generic levitra vardenafil 20mg what is lexapro for azithromycin vs erythromycin ciprofloxacin 500mg tablets zovirax ointment azithromycin three times a week zovirax cream lexapro bula lexapro vs wellbutrin viagra for sale uk cost of cialis lexapro manufacturer website