Ahmedabad – Gujarat, India / Emmanuel Dyan / flickr.com

Dual India: Smart vs. Slums

An interview with Sujata Patel on the consequences of building smart cities in India by Iana Kozak

Read intro

An interview with Sujata Patel

An interview by Iana Kozak

We've have recently witnessed the enormous growth of new type of cities, ‘Smart cities’. The concept of the ‘Smart City’, is now gaining increasing popularity in China, South Korea, Africa, India, etc. How many "smart " cities projects are launched all around the world? There are nearly 50 new "Smart" projects; and India plans to build seven of them, each home at least two million people, which will rise up between Delhi and Mumbai as part of the Delhi-Mumbai Industrial Corridor (DMIC).In the future, their number will increase to 24. But when talking about developing countries like India, we need to understand that these new cities are built not for everyone, but for those who can afford them. How to build a city for former "ruling groups" in a country where half the population is poor?

DMICDC selected IBM for the company’s expertise in the area of Smarter Cities. For five years, IBM has been working with companies, cities and communities around the world to build a Smarter Planet. IBM has made India a "major focus area" for its smarter planet and cities business, an area that involves making cities and townships more cost-efficient, and is actively talking with several real estate developers, cities and state governments in this regard. “We didn’t do our investment in India just for it to be a lab for the whole world. Smarter Planet is a central growth theme for IBM, and India is a huge focus area for us,” he said, in an interview with The Hindu. And here talent matters. Further, the fact that talent can matter enormously for the quality of these strategic outputs and, given the importance of speed, creates potential disbalance within a country.

And we are approaching the dystopian scenario depicted by Saskia Sassen: "There are now big firms that sell you a city. They will build you a city. And some of them will rent you the city. So that’s the dystopian scenario. That’s the dystopian scenario; in other words we will have vast settlements with probably many toxic conditions, where a lot of people – modest, middle-class people – will be living in slums... This is contrasted with these brand new perfect cities that aren’t really cities in that full robust sense of the term." In this interview with Sujata Patel, Professor at the Department of Sociology, University of Hyderabad, India, I tried to envisage the possibility of creating Smart Cities and their viability in India, as an extension of gated communities. What are the differences between these private cities and colonies? What kind of consequences will we get from such extreme growth in developing countries?
Hide intro

You were actively involved in Human Rights Activism, for a long period of time. How has this aspect helped you in your understanding of society, its weaknesses and potentials?

It is a very interesting question. It is my upbringing and it is my parents’ background, because they were involved in freedom movements, and I grew up with concerns regarding how to understand contemporary India.

In the middle of the 1970s, the state declared what it called an Emergency. We didn’t have any involvement of the state until that time. And it was full of freedom of expression, freedom to demonstrate, freedom to question the state. In 1973, there was a major movement against the Indian state and as a consequence of this, the Indian Prime Minister Mrs. Indira Gandhi decided to implement what is called an Emergency: that is, a constitutional provision to suspend the rights of all citizens. And for the next two years, from 1975 till 1977, there was little possibility of any dissent in Indian politics. And most political leaders were put in prison. After that, in 1977, there was an establishing of Human rights organisations. At that time I was doing a doctoral thesis in Delhi while my parents were staying in Bombay. I was involved in both New Delhi and Bombay.

After 1977, human rights organisations started examining all kinds of rights violation by the state. Firstly, in extreme political parties, then in non-​mainstream political parties and groups, and many have appeared since India became independent. They were not part of political parties but they were still part of social protest and social movement, but outside the political parties and outside political culture, and were against all that. And the state started showing its strength and repression. We were able to understand the weaknesses because we started investigating the cases of ‘encounter to death’ when the police could pick up people and take them to edges of the city … Every case of encounter to death, of torture, was connected with an elimination of individuals and a repression of social movements. And we started investigating this and getting to know systematically the weaknesses of the project of creating India as a modern country.

New kolkata township /  seaview99 / flickr.com

New kolkata township /​seaview99 /​flickr​.com

India already has plans to build seven new Smart cities, each home to at least two million people, which will rise up between Delhi and Mumbai as part of the Delhi-​Mumbai Industrial Corridor (DMIC) (Dadri-​Noida-​Ghaziabad in Uttar Pradesh, Manesar-​Bawal in Haryana, Khushkhera-​Bhiwadi-​Neemrana in Rajasthan, Ahmedabad-​Dholera in Gujarat, Pithampur-​Dhar-​Mhow in MP, and Dighi Port and Shendra in Maharashtra). Smart cities are greenfield industrial cities providing IBM-​developed Integrated Communication Technology (ICT). These cities are supposed to host the “elite”. How is it possible in the context of India?

I think in order to understand, we have to see the changes that have been taking place in the last 20 years. Structural adjustment programmes and neoliberal policy have been implemented in the country. The neoliberal policy has directed public-​private partnership towards urban India. And as a consequence, there has been enormous investment in urban India and created parts of what the establishment calls “gated communities”. So, with gated communities there has also appeared the SEZ (Special Economic Zone). Both of these have been a way in which we can see the city growing as a dual city4: which is how we refer to the city’s position, I mean accumulation, by this position. The same is discussed by Saskia Sassen in “Global city” — it’s where one part of services are developed and they spread somewhere else. And we see that nowadays the investments for the poor, for helping the poor, for services for the poor, for even giving opportunities for the poor, have been reduced. The investments are going to creating this market upscale for the new middle class that the neoliberal policy wants to expand now. So, “Smart cities” are part of the same. I think that there have been enormous questions, confrontations, contestations and movements against at least SEZ, because they want to establish it by taking land from farmers. India is still an agricultural country. More than 31 percent of India is urban, the rest of it is agricultural. And any ecologically oriented settlement has to take agriculture into account. In principle, I understand “Smart Cities” are part of ecologically sustainable environment. I think this kind of a settlement, ultimately, is going against the economic organisation trends of the rest of India. To implement this, requires enormous political will. But it represents a way to create, as you said, an “elite”, but I would say “ruling group,” which wants to live a leader’s life, which is international, but which is against the rest of the country. I think it will lead to negative political consequences, not only economical consequences, which are about creating an unequal country, but also political and cultural consequences, which in a democracy is very difficult to sustain.

Anam City is a new town along the Niger River Delta under construction in Anambra State, Eastern Nigeria / anamcity.com

Anam City is a new town along the Niger River Delta under construction in Anambra State, Eastern Nigeria /​anam​c​ity​.com

In the cities we can see a symbiosis between gated communities and the urban poor: Could we imagine these cities without slums?

And what happens is that it creates a small group of “privilege poor” who can get access to these gated communities, but who cannot become the part of the “elite” and who will remain outside gated communities in small slums, small settlements.

It is very important to remember that we are talking about a country with an enormous population: 1.8 bln. But they don’t need so many services, they need only a few. And what happens is that it creates a small group of “privileged poor” who can get access to these gated communities, but who cannot become part of the “elite” and who will remain outside gated communities in small slums, small settlements. You create a dual city, in previous spaces of the country.

4. –The use of the term Dual City as a synonym for a late capitalist metropolis is very frequent among city theorists who ideologically come within the neo-​Marxist orbit. These thinkers produce social criticism that aims to unmask the capitalist superstructure and denounce urban injustices. This position is becoming more and more important after several decades of globalisation, which has generated degrees of social polarisation unknown since the end of the Second World War. Saskia Sassen thinks that it is a case of a phenomenon that is intrinsic to the new late capitalist order, where badly paid jobs are the key to economic growth. This makes social decline a complement to development, and not as previously an indication of decadence.

In some parts slums are found around gated communities, in some cities you have them living from 5 to 10 km away. There is enormous competition for giving these services; not everyone gets a job. This is a problem in smart cities; there is a belief that this is a way in which there will be a ripple effect of demand: demand of services, demand of education — this demand will incorporate productive labour in these cities. This is a wrong assumption, in my opinion, because these services will raise a competition and a lot of people will have to leave, and a result they flood the informal market.

Gujarat International Finance Tec-City construction along Dehli Mumbai Industrial corridor / giftgujarat.in

Gujarat International Finance Tec-​City construction along Dehli Mumbai Industrial corridor /​gift​gu​jarat​.in

The informal economy and “urban poor ” play a fundamental role in city development in the context of India, and other developing countries. What will their role be in the future?

Poor is reproduced as poor

India has 96% of the population working in the informal sector. It is a huge number. A huge part of it takes in agriculture: small peasants, land, etc. The informal sector has been there all the time. That is the way the economy is organised. We are talking about 50% of the people living in cities being the “urban poor”. Poor reproduces poor. In the book, “Beyond Kolkata: Rajarhat and the Dystopia of Urban Imagination,” about new township development, you can check and find that it creates more and more poor rather than vice versa, because peasants’ resources have been taken away.

The Delhi-​Mumbai Industrial Corridor (DMIC) project is partially financed by the Japanese Government. And nowadays, we can see dozens of “smart cities” projects across the world funded by foreign investments. Do you consider new “smart cities” as modern colonial cities?

We have to be careful about how the colonial economy is different to the “new colonial economy” — i.e. neoliberalism. It is possible to argue that new Smart Cities will continue to build this dual city hypothesis. If we look at African cities, the situation would be more correct. The national heritage forms a more complicated situation in India. And I don’t think that external control would be complete in the way it is in Africa, because there are lots of checks and balances within India, which don’t allow international projects to be created completely. There is an international group that is now building a Smart City in Kerala, led by the Dubai Group. Because of checks and balances you have to create Indian interest, and this interest makes it very difficult to make it completely dependent on external finance and external human resources. So, I think there is a more complex situation around the implementation of Smart Cities, and it is a different situation, I would suggest.

As far as I know, the state is pulling back the Smart City. And what I have read up till now makes me think that it is not going so easy in Africa either. The state is trying to bring in this kind of development, but there are two main issues: first, the state does not have complete legitimacy, and second, there have been a lot of protests against this kind of land acquisition. So, it will not be so easy to build Smart cities across the world.

Slums Mumbai India / Le Grand Portage / flickr.com

Slums Mumbai India /​Le Grand Portage /​flickr​.com

What can other developing countries learn from India? What can European countries like Russia learn from India?

Smart Cities, you know, are possibilities in context with developing countries but the economy cannot be implemented in other developing countries until there are economic changes to accept this

I think developing countries can learn two things. One is that one should not go for progress with such uneven implications for poverty and wealth. And I think that European and North American projects cannot be replicated in this part of the world. These kinds of projects, Smart Cities, you know, are possibilities in the context of developing countries but the economy cannot be implemented in other developing countries until there are economic changes to accept this. You know that the anthropologist Clifford Geertz had made a distinction between evolution and involution. Involution is unproductive development or growth without growth in per capita wealth. And I think we need to understand that it will actually lead to more negative than positive consequences. But that doesn’t mean it won’t happen, I think it will happen because the elite in India want these things. They want to live an international lifestyle and they want to maintain an international identity and, certainly, they will have it. And then the consequences are much more negative than it would be in Europe or in Russia.

But let me tell you that I have met many European social scientists who are also against this type of Smart Cities and gated communities as an extension of Smart Cities. I think they will also understand that there can be negative implications, including the negative implications of having IT-​oriented technologies which you don’t control but others control you. I also want to raise another question about what kind of surveillance and control they bring into our lifestyle. They are organised in such a way as to dominate, routinise and almost robotise lifestyles. In principle, I have great objections to this kind of thinking about cities. IT-​oriented cities are what any part of the world should have, even in Asia.

cialis 10 mg cialis patent expiration date extended lexapro para que sirve what is cipro what is tamoxifen used for viagra single packs levitra online acyclovir 800 mg 5 times a day how does cialis work cipro dosage cialis patent expiration how to wean off lexapro without withdrawals levitra bayer 20mg meilleur prix azithromycin pediatric dosing cialis vs viagra ciprofloxacin 250mg lexapro manufacturer website cialis samples overnight tamoxifen side effects in women over 55 side effects of lexapro in women lexapro and weight gain in women lexapro 10 mg cialis generic cheap levitra discount viagra ciprofloxacin coverage azithromycine finasteride and enlarged prostate viagra nebenwirkungen viagra vs cialis vs levitra free viagra zovirax pills cipro antibiotics viagra uk cialis 20 mg side effects of acyclovir utilisation viagra what is escitalopram what is lexapro side effects of ciprofloxacin 500 mg does lexapro cause weight gain ciprofloxacin 500 ciprofloxacin uses azithromycin three times a week zovirax cream cialis testimonials viagra 100 viagra alternatives acyclovir dose viagra 100 mg viagra pillen kruidvat price cialis levitra 20mg cost per pill ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg tab how long does viagra last cialis generic tadalafil ciprofloxacin dosierung azithromycin 500 mg viagra online what is acyclovir ciprofloxacin 250 mg levitra rezeptfrei deutschland tamoxifen and bone pain cialis without a doctor’s prescription when will cialis go generic azithromycin 500mg cialis for sale acyclovir cream levitra 10 mg prezzo generic viagra 100mg viagra bestellen cialis sample azithromycin uses viagra medicine azithromycin 250 mg azithromycin class side effects of viagra online cialis cialis samples azithromycin side effects ciprofloxacin hcl azithromycin 250mg tablets 6 pack lexapro reviews weaning off lexapro ciprofloxacin drug class what is acyclovir for cialis 5 mg viagra 100mg finasteride medication is azithromycin acyclovir 800mg canadian viagra azithromycin tablet cialis for daily use viagra prices ciprofloxacin spc finasteride 5mg side effects mayo clinic acyclovir dosing herbal viagra lexapro side effects in women generic cialis tadalafil cialis coupon 20 mg ciprofloxacin 500mg tablets acyclovir dosage generic for lexapro 200 cialis coupon levitra 20mg what is ciprofloxacin cialis coupons from manufacturer ciprofloxacin hydrochloride ophthalmic lexapro coupons acyclovir vs valacyclovir cialis 5mg cilias ciprofloxacin 500 mg sophia viagra withdrawal from lexapro levitra without a doctor prescription tamoxifen interaction tamoxifen cost generic cialis at walmart ciprofloxacin hydrochloride viagra on line viagra tesco cialis prices escitalopram side effects levitra 20 mg von bayer azithromycin without a doctor’s prescription azithromycin for uti tamoxifen langzeitfolgen side effects lexapro what bacteria does ciprofloxacin kill levitra 20 mg cost walmart cialis for men what is azithromycin for what is ciprofloxacin used for cialis dosage propecia azithromycin 250mg what is acyclovir used for ciprofloxacin side effects after age 60 finasteride vs dutasteride viagra activate azithromycin cost cialis coupons 2017 viagra cialis cialis from canada is azithromycin penicillin levitra prezzo in farmacia cialas viagra pills tamoxifen and weight gain vardenafil vs viagra tamoxifen bijwerkingen generic levitra what does finasteride do discount cialis lexapro dosage acyclovir 800 mg for shingles thuoc azithromycin cialis for bph viagra generic viagra sans ordonnance celexa vs lexapro best price viagra levitra dosage how to wean off lexapro cialis pricing cialis savings card finasteride reviews acyclovir for shingles ciprofloxacin dose lexapro vs zoloft cialis side effects how does viagra work lexapro side effects how to take cialis ciprofloxacin 500mg antibiotics side effects side effects of tamoxifen cipro side effects lexapro weight gain tamoxifen lawsuits tamoxifen pfizer viagra coupons from pfizer free cialis levitra vs viagra lexapro withdrawal symptoms levitra tamoxifen nebenwirkungen daily cialis finasteride results azithromycin eye drops lexapro 5mg is lexapro a controlled substance ciprofloxacin side effects first few days on lexapro canada viagra azithromycin medscape cost of cialis buy generic levitra pfizer viagra zoloft vs lexapro viagra samples levitra generic canada cialis cialis coupon how does lexapro work viagra natural cipro antibiotic cialis medication escitalopram 10 mg para que sirve cialis coupons printable what is tamoxifen viamedic cialis viagra ciprofloxacin dosage viagra wikipedia finasteride tablets how long for lexapro to work cialis 30 day sample levitra prices viagra vs cialis cialis otc buy viagra finasteride side effects tamoxifen citrate viagra generico viagra wiki ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg side effects zovirax for cold sores how does acyclovir work viagra for sale uk side effects of azithromycin 250 mg acyclovir dosage for cold sores what is azithromycin used for side effects of azithromycin viagra coupon buy levitra online acyclovir 800 mg cialis website cialis reviews buying viagra cialis pharmacy prices cialis 20mg sex viagra for women azithromycin 250 mg treatment azithromycin 250 azithromycin coverage online viagra revatio vs viagra azithromycin and alcohol viagra ohne rezept auf rechnung cialis effects azithromycin dosage azithromycin 500 buy generic viagra cialis on line levitra erfahrungen viagra alternative viagra cost generic viagra is tamoxifen chemotherapy escitalopram oxalate cost of viagra cialis dosage strengths lexapro for anxiety women viagra side effects of ciprofloxacin generic cialis zithromax levitra vs viagra for hardness how long for azithromycin to take effect levitra 20 mg viagra canada lexapro 20mg azithromycin 500 erfahrungen canadian cialis what infections does ciprofloxacin treat viagra ohne rezept aus deutschland lexapro and wellbutrin combination therapy viagra for sale generic lexapro finasteride efectos secundarios generic for cialis cialis vs viagra cialis tadalafil finasteride 5mg generic levitra vardenafil 20mg cheap viagra what is finasteride used for viagra price how to get off lexapro tamoxifen side effects in women tamoxifen therapy effects of stopping finasteride what is lexapro for azithromycine 250 mg azithromycin tablets lexapro generic name cialis generic availability lexapro overdose viagra from canada cipro for uti cialis discount cialis or viagra lexapro benefits for women side effects of cialis azithromycin vs erythromycin azithromycin drug class levitra coupon acyclovir medication viagra for men cialis free trial cialis cost finasteride hair loss escitalopram effets secondaires buy cialis online where to buy viagra zithromax antibiotic azithromycine eg 500 mg bijsluiter cipro and tendonitis cipro drug class viagra 50mg how much does cialis cost ciprofloxacin 500mg viagra receptfritt tamoxifen side effects side effects of lexapro 10 mg cialis price azithromycin pregnancy category vardenafil 20mg cialis 5mg daily stopping lexapro escitalopram 10mg zithromax dosage order viagra lowest cialis prices azithromycin pregnancy cipro side effects in elderly what is azithromycin ciprofloxacin for dogs azithromycin liquid lexapro and weight gain acyclovir 200mg finasteride effets secondaires liquid cialis acyclovir ointment 5 lexapro side effects men viagra 100mg tablets retail price what does ciprofloxacin 500mg treat finasteride side effects in men azithromycin z pak viagra en ligne livraison 24h cialis professional azithromycin viagra without a doctor prescription what is cipro usually prescribed for cialis 20mg directions viagra soft ciprofloxacin class propecia side effects lexapro and weight loss buy viagra online viagra sex finasteride for hair loss cialis 30 day trial coupon cialis canada escitalopram 20 mg viagra vs cialis natural viagra cialis pills finasteride permanent side effects cipro what is viagra cialis for women wholesale cialis ciprofloxacin used for viagra dosage cialis coupons what works better than viagra buy levitra side effects of finasteride 5mg what is cialis finasteride viagra effects cialis trial cialis online finasteride 5 mg tab ciprofloxacin ophthalmic solution buy cialis viagra tablets effects of stopping lexapro suddenly ciprofloxacin eye drops equipe argentine viagra acyclovir acyclovir ointment cialis pills for sale cyalis zovirax ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg ciprofloxacin 500 mg for urinary tract infection viagra coupons acyclovir 400mg zovirax ointment lexapro levitra coupons finasteride long term effects escitalopram nebenwirkungen viagra without a doctor prescription usa finasteride dosage lexapro generic lexapro vs celexa lexapro withdrawal how to use viagra azithromycin 5 day dose pack viagra pill over the counter viagra cipro dangers finasteride 5mg tab post finasteride syndrome what does viagra do viagra for women azithromycin for pneumonia ciprofloxacin 500mg antibiotics cialis copay card levitra vs viagra female viagra what does ciprofloxacin treat 9 levitra at walmart ciprofloxacin bnf cialis dosage recommendations cipro 500 cialis coupon print antibiotic ciprofloxacin viagra side effects cialis alternative what is cipro used for cheap cialis ciprofloxacin what does azithromycin treat viagra costs viagra substitute lexapro 10mg cialis cheap side effects of lexapro viagra vs cialis vs levitra ciprofloxacin side effects in women cialis daily cialis patent expiration 2017 cialis acyclovir 400 mg ciprofloxacin 500 mg tabletten tamoxifen and foods to avoid lexapro vs wellbutrin lexapro side effects in men wellbutrin and lexapro viagra kaufen azithromycin for strep throat viagra tablet what is finasteride escitalopram 10 mg what is ciprofloxacin prescribed for side effects of finasteride lexapro bula cealis zithromax 500 mg zovirax dosage cialis canadian pharmacy acyclovir for cold sores finasteride 1mg nolvadex is ciprofloxacin a penicillin ciprofloxacin drops cipro uses what is lexapro used for cialis voucher acyclovir side effects finasteride 5mg side effects levitra 20 mg precio farmacia erectile dysfunction cialis finasteride 5 mg ciprofloxacin nebenwirkungen finasteride for women lexapro dosages lexapro dosing zithromax z-​pak lexapro medication viagra on line no prec escitalopram common side effects of ciprofloxacin 500 mg