Intensive Farming / Urban grid by NASA /

At The Edges, Everywhere

An interview with Arjen Oosterman on the limits of the city by Nicholas Moore

Read intro

An interview with Arjen Oosterman

An interview by Nicholas Moore

“The future is already here – it's just not evenly distributed.” ― William Gibson, The Economist, December 4, 2003

Urbanism is already here ― it’s just not evenly distributed.

In the 60s and 70s, Archizoom drew plans of No-Stop City; meant as a critique, in many ways we can read their typewriter drawings as diagrams of contemporary urbanization ― infinite distribution of capitalist density supported by infrastructure of consumption, production, and parking. But the scene on the ground is much less consistent. While urbanization, chariot of capital, may be ubiquitous (even, increasingly, extending to outer space), cities, their material and people, live with(in) specific limits. These limits may be political, economic, geographic, demographic... They can be built or unbuilt, but they have implied or delineated edges to be explored.

Arjen Oosterman lives in Amsterdam and is Editor-in-Chief at the Volume Project. He spoke with Nicholas Moore from Shenzhen, where he is working with the Team Ole Bouman at the Shenzhen Biennale.
Hide intro

I would like to talk about edges and limits. You were trained as an architectural historian, and you’re a journalist, Editor-​in-​Chief at Volume. The motto of Volume is “TO BEYOND OR NOT TO BE” ― you and your team constantly seek the edges of architecture, of urbanism, and of the tools for working in these disciplines. How have ideas about the edge of the city changed over the course of your career?

Well, they changed and they didn’t. They didn’t change in the sense that the avant-​garde ideas of the 50s, 60s, and early 70s are resurfacing, in publications and schools and projects. It supports my idea that it takes a revolutionary idea 35 or 40 years to become widely acceptable. It seems that it takes that much time, from the first phase when an idea is so strange and difficult that it can’t be accepted. Gradually, an idea takes hold, and after that period it becomes possible to recover the value in that original idea. In new projects, we can see a historic reflection; Team X, Superstudio, Structuralism, all of a sudden you see those images again, you see those ideas inspiring a new generation of students. And the “Edge Condition” is very much a part of that legacy.

It takes a revolutionary idea 35 or 40 years to become widely acceptable

Looking back at the Netherlands specifically, regarding the last century of urbanism and planning, there is a history of difficulty with the metropolis — let’s say a fear of the metropolitan condition. That fear was manifested in policy — the Netherlands is a totally policy-​driven society— and you can see policies that were meant to keep the metropolis from coming into existence. The solution was to focus on the places beyond the major city centers, beyond the edges of the cities as they existed Metropolis was actively prevented, through the creation of a totally distributed kind of urban fabric, the Randstad. The larger cities, Amsterdam, Rotterdam, The Hague, were forced to export part of their population to other, smaller cities. And it was forced, although not by any sort of totalitarian means, but rather through more intricate mechanisms for diminishing density, for building other cities.

In what ways was distribution of the population effected?

For instance, my grandparents were born and raised Amsterdammers. When they reached retirement age, they changed their lives and moved from Amsterdam to a smaller town because there they could live for a reasonable price in a nice environment, in better space. They moved into a new building, a new part of town. Before, in Amsterdam, they’d always lived in older parts of the city; at that time, the older city fabric was certainly not great, it hadn’t been maintained, and was to some extent in a state of decay. In some cases, in Europe, inner cities were derelict, in really bad condition. The city was a ruined project in some ways; people concentrated not on the city but on a periphery, on a village, on a countryside. For my grandparents, it was simply a question of improving their living conditions. It was easy to begin living in newly developed areas, through special financial projects and special policies. By creating new settlements and by extending smaller towns 20 to 50 km from main cities, the government persuaded parts of the concentrated urban population to move to these other cities and new towns. For younger people, these new towns were very boring. They were looking for another experience, and, being young, were willing to live in less comfortable situations. Since many people had left city centers, the real estate there was available at low prices. So in effect, the suburban youth, artists, students, they moved back into the cities, re-​inhabiting this older fabric, investing in it, continuing another phase of the cycle.

And now city and country have met in the middle?

Yes, now when we talk about the Netherlands, when we talk about cities and the countryside, we talk about one thing. The Netherlands is a metropolis, it is a nation in the form of a metropolis. It’s a metropolis between nodes, obviously, but actually it is one. Looking at the country today we can see it has a totally urban population.


Netherlands Density Map /​sedac​.ciesin​.colum​bia​.edu

For an urban planner now any urban condition is by now global

In this respect, we can see that ideas about the edges of cities have changed. In the past, even in the times of those avant-​garde projects I mentioned, there was a very strong inclination to think of the city in contrast to the countryside, to consider these as two different conditions. As an urbanist you dealt with the one condition, as a landscape architect you dealt with the other. That idea has gone. For example, for an urban planner now any urban condition is by now global. It’s not only that landscape architects have become successful urbanists, have occupied part of urbanism’s territory, but also that the divide between land and city has been replaced with “conditions.” Dense, less dense, mixed or not, more urban or more suburban. That understanding has changed the appreciation for the “edge.”

You mentioned avant-​garde projects of the past. Beyond influencing new student works, where do you see these ideas in play? You’re in Shenzhen now, for example; can you see evidence on the ground that these ideas are emerging?

Shenzhen is quite young, it’s existed as city for maybe thirty to forty years, but it has a population of 14 or 15 million people. Before, it was a collection of villages, rural by nature. You can already begin to see an older urban fabric that has to be re– used, re-​purposed, and in fact, it is being re-​used. The parts of town that were becoming derelict or marginal, the fringes or edges of the city fabric, these are being revived and new programs are being developed in these areas. So I think that does illustrate that a growing appreciation for these sites is not confined to Europe or the US but develops as places change from industrial production to post-​industrial production.

Shenzhen / Chris Master /

Shenzhen /​Chris Master /​flickr​.com

At the Shenzhen Biennale, Olé Bouman was selected as director for “Venue A,” which is a former float glass factory. He was able to persuade the owners of the building, China Merchants, not only to sponsor the Biennale but also to invest in the building. He persuaded them into the position where they would not want to erase that in which they had just invested. Instead they begin thinking beyond the Biennale, to invest in future programming, instead of the customary, finite formula. So there is a sense of easiness, flexibility, understanding that the mechanisms that exist for building cities are not the only way that things can be. There is space for negotiation, space for change, for ideas, there is a receptiveness. Not among everyone, of course, but it’s growing. This is reflected by this biennale: it’s focusing very much on potential for reuse, potential for reprogramming, potential for the future, in part to show that development can’t be done by only erasing what exists. It seeks to investigate the relationships between transformation in China, especially this part of China, which is founded on cheap labor and cheap production. The Biennale asks what will take place with the emergence of a ‘higher’ form of production, a more service oriented economy.

Do you see the pace of change being maintained, even as the region transforms to a different kind of economy?

Yes, it’s incredible. In terms of a European notion of how life functions, how politics functions, how countries develop, it’s really different. When I was first here fifteen years ago, on a sort of grand tour through South-​East Asia, we visited the university, which was eccentrically located in relation to the city center at that time. There was a show of graduation architecture projects, and there was one project of five apartment towers, five high-​rises, pink in color. And I looked out of the window, and in the far distance I saw five pink towers.

I said to the dean, ‘Hey that’s interesting, the student copied, more or less, the new project, the buildings that are there. How come, how can that be?’ And he said, ‘No, no, it’s the other way around. The student built those buildings, based on his graduation project.’

It illustrated exactly the kind of speed we’re dealing with here, in China. But I’m also impressed with their understanding of their own situation, they’re working in sophisticated ways with their condition. They’re generally well-​informed and quite aware of the mechanisms that are required of them, of the shortcomings in the country, and how to move in the directions that they want, to try to improve the situation. It’s a really interesting and challenging experience.

It makes me wonder where industry goes. For all of these creatively driven cities or higher economies, there must be a source of raw materials, an origin of the product. Will industry keep moving around, to the source of lowest wages, to the source of cheapest labor, forever, or do you imagine that somehow industrialization will settle at some point?

That’s a very tricky question and of course I’m not an economist. In the end, I can only tell you what I see. There is this shift, a drive of cities to initiate a higher level of producing. Industrial production keeps moving around, but I suspect that this cannot happen forever; eventually there must be a moment where either the entire system collapses, or it develops into a new system. There are alternate views on that. One suggests that production will become totally industrialized, totally mechanized, computer, remote driven. That would replace labor as such, which would open up all manner of other dimensions. I don’t know enough economy to judge, but that sounds unlikely, to me, as a final solution. I have a hunch that capitalism simply comes with poor people, that that is in the definition of the industrialized world, especially in the future. That within the capitalist system there has to be an upper and a lower class, that riches for all is not an option.

That relates to a question of measurement, is economic growth the only way we can measure the success, the thriving of a city. Tokyo is a good example of a so-​called Still City, and it’s the subject of an interesting project (MONNIK http://​www​.mon​nik​.org/, STILL CITY http://​still​city​.org/). That research proposes that growth is not the only way, that an urban society can achieve a level of dynamics without expanding. The project shows that it’s not only possible but actually visible. The Japanese society has existed with a stationary economy for a decade and a half, also without population growth. Suddenly now there’s growth again, but only of half a percent or maybe one percent, something really small, in terms of growth rates. So this rational, economic growth measure as a way of thinking for the future can be challenged, and it has to be challenged to cope with the conditions that we see emerging.

I hold the suspicion that there is an urbanization bubble. Can you anticipate the bursting of such a bubble as world cities develop and build, competing for a future?

There are whole buildings, whole neighborhoods, even whole cities that are newly built that are empty

Well, there are many bubbles. One of the things that strikes me is that here, in China, there are many people who will invest in a second home, in a third home, or apartment, as a kind of pension, because there is no stable financial system for that. Then, they don’t allow anyone to inhabit the apartment in order to preserve its value, to keep in in good condition. Especially because someone who might move in could be from the countryside, and wouldn’t know how to live in it properly, in a ‘modern’ way. This leads to an insane situation because it means there are whole buildings, whole neighborhoods, even whole cities that are newly built that are empty.

I’m particularly interested in the relation of cities to land, and in the farm.

Koolhaas has an essay called Typical Plan in which he writes about the rectangular bays of American office buildings in the 20th century (Koolhaas, Rem, Bruce Mau, Jennifer Sigler, and Hans Werlemann. Small, Medium, Large, Extra-​large: Office for Metropolitan Architecture, Rem Koolhaas, and Bruce Mau. New York, NY: Monacelli, 1998. Print. P. 336). He describes the tiny labyrinths of services and toilets that remind us that we’re still human. It seems we see a similar phenomenon on the scale of an entire global landscape: there is a logic deployed by the nebulous mechanisms of capital, and even places like the farm where our most basic needs are satisfied are drawn into the system.

I think that’s fairly true, in the sense that the urban is everywhere, the farm is part of the city. Farmers today are graduated from university. They run a factory called “farm.” They are totally integrated into the urban project of production.

Intensive Farming / Urban grid by NASA /

Intensive Farming /​Urban grid by NASA /​eoim​ages​.gsfc​.nasa​.gov

In the future I think that there will probably be two different, maybe even opposing, developments. One is that in general, we’ll see developments in urban farming and the re-​arrangement of food production and distribution. That is clearly spatial, and thereby an architectural project. There are architects beginning to work on that, for example MVRDV. As that project evolves, it will bring a change in the way we do things, will change configurations, will probably mean, specifically, a change in the way animals are raised. Of course the other option is going synthetic. This would mean a total industrialization of food as well, the creation of food products from ingredients, processed in factories and labs, with even more distance from the land than we have now.

As I understand it, one of the Chinese government’s greatest priorities is food security. Do you see a difference in the way that that urban food landscapes have developed in China, as compared to the Netherlands?

Well, it’s hard, I don’t know that much of China and so can’t judge very well. What I have seen so far, is that there seems to be a contradiction in the way things are moving forward. Part of that contradiction is the system of Hukou. Hukou is a person registration system that says where you are from: a village (so countryman) or a city (so citizen). So if a country person, a farmer usually, looks for work in the city, he or she is a migrant without access to social security, healthcare or education. For those services, he or she has to return to the village of origin. These are the people who live in the urban villages in very cramped conditions. Second rate urbanites, not citizens proper. So Hukou is a rule for tying people to the place that they were born, to the land. It’s a means of creating a stable community, but it also means creating a static society of agricultural laborers. It means the creation of a split between who can prosper and who cannot, with the enforced division of the population into urban and rural. One could also, of course, argue that it’s a response to the reality of the situation; they can’t have the whole population move to the cities, and the cities can’t do without food produced in the countryside, so it’s simply a fact that has to be addressed. At the same time, China expands its territory far beyond mainland China, specifically to Africa, to secure food. So there are other, somewhat hidden dimensions to the question of edges of the city, and of the rural territory, and of the country.

how long does viagra last finasteride and enlarged prostate cialis discount viagra tablet levitra online lexapro dosage how does viagra work what is cipro levitra 20 mg cialis for bph is lexapro a controlled substance generic cialis at walmart levitra vs viagra levitra vs viagra lexapro coupons escitalopram 10mg lexapro generic name levitra 10 mg prezzo cialis for sale cialis medication zithromax dosage ciprofloxacin 500 mg ciprofloxacin 500 mg for urinary tract infection azithromycin side effects viagra price is tamoxifen chemotherapy tamoxifen bijwerkingen withdrawal from lexapro tamoxifen nebenwirkungen vardenafil vs viagra cialis coupon print ciprofloxacin eye drops levitra 20 mg precio farmacia tamoxifen and weight gain cialis pricing finasteride tablets tamoxifen side effects of lexapro in women viagra sex viagra cialis what is ciprofloxacin used for how does lexapro work cialis coupons zithromax side effects of viagra viagra coupon acyclovir 400mg azithromycin 500 viamedic cialis viagra 100 mg cialis coupons 2017 propecia side effects cheap levitra escitalopram 20 mg levitra generic viagra activate escitalopram oxalate azithromycin and alcohol how long for azithromycin to take effect finasteride long term effects sex viagra for women azithromycin pregnancy ciprofloxacin 500mg does lexapro cause weight gain viagra sans ordonnance cialis trial cialis for daily use levitra erfahrungen cialis 20 mg zovirax for cold sores cialis patent expiration lexapro side effects in men side effects of tamoxifen viagra ohne rezept auf rechnung azithromycin for strep throat buy cialis online lexapro vs celexa cipro side effects side effects of lexapro 10 mg viagra tesco viagra 50mg cialis side effects lexapro withdrawal what is ciprofloxacin azithromycin for pneumonia cialis reviews how to wean off lexapro online cialis cialis 5mg daily cipro and tendonitis what is acyclovir used for generic levitra viagra vs cialis levitra prezzo in farmacia buy generic levitra viagra coupons viagra pillen kruidvat what is lexapro for viagra for sale side effects of lexapro finasteride permanent side effects acyclovir dosage viagra ohne rezept aus deutschland buying viagra wholesale cialis buy levitra celexa vs lexapro lexapro vs zoloft ciprofloxacin bnf lexapro reviews cialis canadian pharmacy what is cialis buy levitra online lexapro side effects in women liquid cialis cialis effects cialis dosage recommendations azithromycin liquid ciprofloxacin cyalis finasteride for women cialis sample tamoxifen cost azithromycin for uti generic levitra vardenafil 20mg cialis website best price viagra cheap viagra 200 cialis coupon natural viagra viagra vs cialis vs levitra how to wean off lexapro without withdrawals tamoxifen citrate lexapro overdose tamoxifen and foods to avoid viagra for men acyclovir medication levitra vs viagra for hardness viagra online ciprofloxacin coverage what is ciprofloxacin prescribed for how to get off lexapro acyclovir cream cialis or viagra lexapro side effects men what does azithromycin treat tamoxifen and bone pain finasteride dosage how does acyclovir work acyclovir 800 mg 5 times a day lexapro and weight loss canada viagra viagra wikipedia how much does cialis cost side effects of acyclovir azithromycin 250mg first few days on lexapro ciprofloxacin dosage cialis patent expiration date extended what infections does ciprofloxacin treat cipro drug class ciprofloxacin hydrochloride ophthalmic cialis on line buy viagra common side effects of ciprofloxacin 500 mg zovirax ointment cialis patent expiration 2017 acyclovir ointment viagra tablets is ciprofloxacin a penicillin cialis dosage strengths generic cialis tadalafil what does ciprofloxacin 500mg treat cipro dangers levitra levitra bayer 20mg meilleur prix finasteride 5 mg tab viagra without a doctor prescription cialis for men azithromycin 500mg what is lexapro ciprofloxacin 250mg finasteride results ciprofloxacin drops what is cipro used for viagra costs erectile dysfunction cialis azithromycin without a doctor’s prescription cialis generic availability what is acyclovir ciprofloxacin uses finasteride side effects acyclovir for cold sores cialis 5mg azithromycin uses side effects of finasteride 5mg lexapro viagra generico lexapro 5mg viagra prices wellbutrin and lexapro viagra wiki ciprofloxacin side effects in women cialis pills for sale levitra 20mg cost per pill levitra without a doctor prescription cialis free trial cialis coupons from manufacturer ciprofloxacin ophthalmic solution azithromycin pediatric dosing viagra cost cialis price viagra side effects women viagra cipro dosage ciprofloxacin dose acyclovir 800mg what bacteria does ciprofloxacin kill cialis savings card azithromycin side effects of cialis cialis 30 day sample free cialis effects of stopping finasteride levitra rezeptfrei deutschland how to take cialis finasteride 5mg side effects mayo clinic finasteride side effects in men finasteride effets secondaires levitra dosage what is azithromycin viagra substitute post finasteride syndrome cipro antibiotic finasteride cipro uses what is viagra lexapro and weight gain what does viagra do escitalopram lexapro vs wellbutrin finasteride 5mg azithromycine herbal viagra finasteride 1mg lexapro 20mg generic lexapro cialis pharmacy prices what is tamoxifen equipe argentine viagra cialas azithromycin 250mg tablets 6 pack azithromycin 500 erfahrungen cialis samples overnight ciprofloxacin 500 how long for lexapro to work cialis coupon 20 mg viagra vs cialis viagra without a doctor prescription usa cheap cialis what is lexapro used for cipro side effects in elderly cost of viagra ciprofloxacin 500mg tablets zoloft vs lexapro lexapro dosages lexapro withdrawal symptoms lowest cialis prices acyclovir for shingles viagra alternative ciprofloxacin dosierung female viagra over the counter viagra azithromycin drug class azithromycine 250 mg lexapro manufacturer website viagra soft viagra kaufen cialis coupon generic for lexapro viagra 100mg tablets retail price tamoxifen langzeitfolgen azithromycin dosage azithromycin 250 thuoc azithromycin viagra from canada is azithromycin penicillin lexapro benefits for women finasteride 5 mg nolvadex buy viagra online tamoxifen side effects ciprofloxacin side effects after age 60 cialis alternative generic for cialis ciprofloxacin class ciprofloxacin 500mg antibiotics side effects what works better than viagra viagra alternatives acyclovir dose pfizer viagra coupons from pfizer finasteride hair loss viagra dosage finasteride medication cialis testimonials stopping lexapro cipro antibiotics ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg tab cialis 30 day trial coupon acyclovir 200mg ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg escitalopram effets secondaires lexapro dosing 9 levitra at walmart canadian viagra acyclovir 800 mg for shingles ciprofloxacin 250 mg cialis canada where to buy viagra lexapro para que sirve viagra pills ciprofloxacin 500 mg tabletten lexapro and wellbutrin combination therapy viagra on line viagra effects side effects of azithromycin 250 mg levitra coupons lexapro and weight gain in women viagra for sale uk side effects lexapro what is azithromycin for viagra samples escitalopram 10 mg what does finasteride do side effects of azithromycin what is azithromycin used for cipro for uti ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg side effects azithromycin tablets azithromycin 5 day dose pack canadian cialis acyclovir side effects viagra single packs order viagra acyclovir ointment 5 viagra 100 discount cialis viagra viagra 100mg cilias cialis dosage cipro cialis online acyclovir dosage for cold sores azithromycin 500 mg cialis prices tamoxifen interaction finasteride 5mg side effects cialis 10 mg what is escitalopram what is finasteride how does cialis work zovirax cream ciprofloxacin for dogs escitalopram nebenwirkungen lexapro for anxiety cialis 20mg directions revatio vs viagra cost of cialis side effects of ciprofloxacin azithromycin 250 mg azithromycin coverage ciprofloxacin spc buy cialis propecia cialis zithromax antibiotic canada cialis cialis generic lexapro weight gain cialis otc lexapro generic price cialis escitalopram 10 mg para que sirve utilisation viagra ciprofloxacin hcl lexapro 10 mg cialis coupons printable zovirax ciprofloxacin hydrochloride finasteride 5mg tab azithromycin z pak levitra coupon viagra on line no prec finasteride for hair loss cialis vs viagra side effects of ciprofloxacin 500 mg zovirax dosage ciprofloxacin 500mg antibiotics cialis copay card ciprofloxacin drug class lexapro side effects finasteride reviews lexapro 10mg weaning off lexapro is azithromycin cialis for women finasteride vs dutasteride lexapro bula acyclovir dosing levitra 20 mg cost walmart ciprofloxacin side effects what is cipro usually prescribed for cialis cost what is finasteride used for viagra nebenwirkungen acyclovir 400 mg azithromycin eye drops sophia viagra zithromax z-​pak cialis vs viagra cialis daily azithromycin three times a week acyclovir 800 mg discount viagra azithromycin pregnancy category what does ciprofloxacin treat azithromycin medscape generic viagra viagra natural tamoxifen therapy cialis 20mg how to use viagra azithromycin tablet azithromycin 250 mg treatment acyclovir cealis levitra prices cialis voucher levitra 20 mg von bayer effects of stopping lexapro suddenly viagra uk pfizer viagra viagra canada buy generic viagra what is acyclovir for cipro 500 online viagra finasteride efectos secundarios levitra 20mg viagra generic cialis from canada cialis professional generic viagra 100mg ciprofloxacin nebenwirkungen viagra en ligne livraison 24h what is tamoxifen used for azithromycin class cialis generic tadalafil vardenafil 20mg cialis without a doctor’s prescription cialis tadalafil tamoxifen side effects in women acyclovir vs valacyclovir generic cialis when will cialis go generic cialis cheap viagra medicine escitalopram side effects cialis 5 mg viagra pill free viagra azithromycin cost azithromycine eg 500 mg bijsluiter antibiotic ciprofloxacin zithromax 500 mg cialis pills cialis samples lexapro medication azithromycin vs erythromycin viagra vs cialis vs levitra tamoxifen lawsuits viagra bestellen daily cialis ciprofloxacin used for zovirax pills side effects of finasteride viagra for women viagra receptfritt tamoxifen side effects in women over 55