Space Neotopia, Countdown Plaza by Tony Nippel, 2007

Art is our only hope

Brain and cognitive science expert Tatyana Chernigovskaya discusses how communication with art can prepare humanity for a symbiosis with gadgets

Read intro

An interview with Tatyana Chernigovskaya

An interview by Mikhail Shiyanov

Professor Tatyana Chernigovskaya, a brain and cognitive science expert, sees more problems than opportunities in the future. Considering the increasing immersion of people in virtual worlds, how will they interact with each other? How will they manage their work and free time? Where is evolution going and should humanity be prepared for a symbiosis with gadgets and mechanisms? Tatyana believes that in any case we need to engage in the training of our brain – particularly through communication with art.

Tatyana Chernigovskaya, Ph.D., Sc.D., is a professor at St. Petersburg State University and the Head of the Laboratory for Cognitive Studies. She is a member of the Board of Science and Education under the President of the Russian Federation. She is a specialist in the field of psycho- and neurolinguistics, cognitive psychology, neuroscience, origins of language, evolution, artificial intelligence and other topics. She has published over 300 scientific papers in Russian and international journals.
Hide intro

From the perspective of brain science, how is a person’s life changing now and how it will it change in the future?

We have already entered into a new type of civilization. But our world has been changed not by a philosopher, nor the historical events or discoveries of science – the mobile phone has changed it. Because it’s not just a phone, it’s the whole world in your pocket. Our relations with geography have changed because now you can easily reach any distant place just in a second. We have gained access virtually to any information. All the talks about human symbiosis with smart technology is not about the future, it is about now. The only difference is that still nothing inserted inside our heads in a physical sense. In the end, is that important?

What does this mean to us? Of course, the type of reading has changed. Reading as a process ceases to be linear because of hypertexts. It is no longer like riding on the road, it’s more like diving into the ocean – including its deepest part. The situation has greatly changed in the sense that obtaining information has become an easy task. But it is so only at first glance. I mean, it’s not difficult to find simple information. But serious scientists would still not trust Google. If I need deep and rare information, I would look for consultant who tells me where to search. In other words, if I’m looking for a guacamole recipe, I’ll get it in a couple of clicks, but if I want to find out who translated some Sumerian texts, that’s completely different task.

So if couple of decades ago the main question was where to get information, now it sounds exactly the opposite way – how to reduce the data flow. In the future, the amount and the rate of information will continue to rise, and gadgets will become smaller. Apparently this will affect people dramatically.

Learning things physically improves the quality of your brain

We communicate via social networks where we feel comfortable, because at any moment they can be turned on or off, and in no way it can violate our physical safety. But in fact, these parallel worlds make people much more lonely because they are deprived of real social interaction. As my colleague, psychologist Sergei Yenikolopov, says: ‘Nothing can replace a good kick’. This is the actual real-​life moderation of human behavior.


Modern science still seeks to fulfill popular prophecies of 1950-​1960s sci-​fi © Smith​son​ian​.com

And how will technologies affect city dwelling?
We can now observe how intelligent technology penetrates life at the everyday common level. There are unmanned vehicles already. Robots are increasingly used in surgery: for example, a doctor is in Moscow, and the patient is in a completely different city, and first gives commands to machine, which obeys these orders. And it’s good if it obeys. But what if the robot decides somehow it knows how to do this operation better?

Sooner or later this will happen and we will have to deal with it. That means that the boundary between the living and non-​living is increasingly blurring, especially because the development of modern NBIC technologies [nanotechnology, biotechnology, information technology and cognitive science] is very much connected to the merging of organic matter with mechanics. This also refers to new types of prostheses, giving people substituted vision, substituted hearing, expanded memory, etc. This is the next stage of human evolution, the development of the very biological kind in the new kind of Homo Sapiens Autocreator. This creature will have a new consciousness – but how exactly should it be aware of itself, if its hands and feet are mechanical, it has artificial eyes and ears, and operates brain chips, which allow to make faster decisions, remembers things better and so on? We have to deal with the fundamental question of the boundaries of the individual.

If we are talking about the future of cities, most likely they will be inhabited by some kind of humans. But for example we have to decide at first if these people would occasionally go out or not. Or they will just use technically perfect device that would show them some paradise island on the ocean shore with all its sounds, smells, completely indistinguishable from reality? After all, we still do not know how our brain distinguishes between the impulses it receives from the real and the virtual world. I’m not sure that the brain reacts to them differently. This is an occasion to think about why we react so strongly to the cinema, music or books – which generally do not show anything. Yet they produce a strong impressions in our heads, which could determine the rest of our lives. More than a hundred years ago a great Russian scientist Ivan Sechenov wrote that the brain doesn’t care whether it receives something from the real world or just recalls things. That’s correct and now proven, although it’s quite a scary thought. Especially mysterious is how Sechenov came to it. Now we have powerful scanners that can show if it is true or not, but a hundred years ago such technologies didn’t exist.

How do you think the division of labor and leisure time could develop in the future?

Apparently more and more machines will replace people in terms of hard labor. There are already entirely automated factories, but there will be more and they will become increasingly complex. What people are supposed to do in that case? If they have 24 free hours in a day, and they would not depend on money, which machines would provide? Obviously, not all of us are creative persons, just waiting for an opportunity to create. What should all the others do? Will they quarrel and drink vodka? Or dig a canal along the equator? What do they do with their endless leisure? Imagine the city, filled with wandering bums, waiting only for their lives to end. Very much likely some people would say ‘Well, I’m tired of your technologies, I am going to the village. I will buy a cow, some goats, chickens, and I will deal with them all day’. I think a lot of people may follow that strategy. Now it is an exotic way to rest for intellectuals who lack simple life. In the future this trend may gain more power.

Imagine the city, filled with wandering bums, waiting only for their lives to end

However, if things continue as they are now, we could have no future at all – we would just blow ourselves with the planet, and that would put an end to our sufferings. But if people would somehow manage to come out of the unconscious state in which they are now, the new times have to be times of thinkers. We really need people who are able to think well. I want to say that we, the people, in recent years are overclocked. Things that used to take several years now take just a week. At the same time I look at the leaders of different countries and do not see in them neither responsibility, nor lack of hysteria, nor clarity of mind. Without this combination of qualities, our future is under great threat.

In addition to brain studies themselves, researches are actively trying to improve human race at the genetic level. Do we have any prospects on this front?

Unfortunately, we are not arranged that simply so that a single gene is responsible for reading and another for singing, the third for the friendship, and the fourth for the platonic love. We and many elements of our bodies are multifunctional and lots of things are going on at the same time within us. Our body is much more complicated, and our opportunities are still very far from unraveling the easiest of its secrets. But we must try, because it is obvious that if we understand at least a small part of our brain, that would change everything. Education, health, communication, technology – we can rebuild them on a fundamentally new principles. This game is worth the candle. But the question is whether the brain would allow us to its depths.


The last step for humanity on a way to the human-​machine symbiosis is a physical implanting of gadgets © Random house

Another important point: the brain evolves, it has been proven many times. Genes are important, but if people want to wake and use them, they should give themselves some intellectual food. Many things are considered, your neural networks, which are formed by the connection of your genetics and experience, depend on what you are doing and with whom are you talking, how complex is the life you live. Experience is writing the story on these networks. Education physically changes the brain – improving the quality of nerve fibers, their length, thickness, myelination. In short, the process of learning things is useful not only because it is better to be smart than stupid, but because it improves the quality of the brain. And this is a purpose that worth some sufferings.

So what is useful for a person to study, what to do?

I would say that it is very important to take up the arts somehow. Actually this is our only hope. Because the computers that we have constructed and with which we work, they simply arrange numbers – that’s all. And although their rates are rising, machines are not able to do anything more complex. After Aristotle all our thinking develops a line of causation. Anyone who has strong formal logic skills is a winner. But the great discoveries have never been made in this way. Discoveries are more likely to come as a sudden insight – either like a dream, or even as something that does not fit into the laws of logic. Where do they come from?

Machines don’t make discoveries

Or, can you tell me what music is? The sound wave that is hitting your eardrum. But why does it cause such an intense emotions? It has nothing to do with decibels, and it’s still a mystery to us. I believe that all people should be associated with art – or they just impoverish themselves. The most important zones of the brain will not function if you deprive yourself of art. I think that art in the foreseeable future will no longer be a dessert, something optional; otherwise, computers will make the discoveries instead of us. So far, machines are not able to do such things.

azithromycin z pak discount viagra ciprofloxacin 500mg antibiotics tamoxifen interaction canadian viagra ciprofloxacin 500mg tablets what does finasteride do cipro antibiotic azithromycin medscape azithromycin for strep throat side effects of lexapro 10 mg buy cialis buy viagra levitra 20 mg von bayer lexapro medication levitra prezzo in farmacia acyclovir ointment generic levitra ciprofloxacin hcl finasteride for hair loss viagra costs ciprofloxacin side effects after age 60 what does ciprofloxacin treat finasteride efectos secundarios finasteride vs dutasteride azithromycin cost lexapro side effects over the counter viagra viagra 100mg tablets retail price lexapro and weight gain in women side effects of cialis is lexapro a controlled substance levitra online escitalopram 20 mg what is lexapro azithromycine ciprofloxacin uses side effects of acyclovir what is cialis zovirax for cold sores zovirax dosage viagra tablet azithromycin pregnancy levitra erfahrungen withdrawal from lexapro cost of cialis ciprofloxacin for dogs what is viagra acyclovir 400mg buy generic levitra best price viagra escitalopram side effects finasteride 5mg side effects escitalopram 10mg azithromycin side effects free viagra azithromycin three times a week ciprofloxacin dose cialis canadian pharmacy lexapro withdrawal symptoms cialis pills buy levitra online utilisation viagra cheap viagra cialis for sale cipro side effects levitra 20 mg precio farmacia generic cialis acyclovir 800 mg 5 times a day finasteride hair loss levitra vs viagra ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg side effects viagra ohne rezept aus deutschland cialis effects side effects lexapro ciprofloxacin 250mg azithromycin for pneumonia cialis pharmacy prices acyclovir for cold sores tamoxifen what is azithromycin lexapro weight gain levitra vs viagra azithromycin 250 natural viagra side effects of ciprofloxacin 500 mg levitra generic canadian cialis zithromax 500 mg azithromycin eye drops zovirax ointment cialis for men viagra wiki cialis coupons cialis voucher viagra for sale viagra 100 mg acyclovir dose sophia viagra ciprofloxacin 500 generic cialis at walmart vardenafil 20mg tamoxifen and bone pain lexapro side effects in men ciprofloxacin drops cipro dangers finasteride medication zovirax cream finasteride cialis vs viagra side effects of viagra tamoxifen cost viagra tablets cipro side effects in elderly cialis on line what is azithromycin used for cialis dosage strengths how to take cialis viagra online finasteride 5mg tab buy generic viagra online viagra liquid cialis cipro antibiotics cost of viagra viagra en ligne livraison 24h finasteride 5 mg tab cialis cheap lexapro cialis free trial levitra prices what is ciprofloxacin prescribed for discount cialis acyclovir vs valacyclovir how much does cialis cost sex viagra for women finasteride side effects in men lexapro generic name ciprofloxacin 500 mg for urinary tract infection ciprofloxacin class what infections does ciprofloxacin treat viagra without a doctor prescription usa tamoxifen side effects in women cialis otc acyclovir 800mg cialis pricing finasteride and enlarged prostate how does acyclovir work levitra 20mg cost per pill women viagra zithromax z-​pak cipro and tendonitis viagra bestellen lexapro para que sirve cyalis ciprofloxacin bnf weaning off lexapro finasteride dosage ciprofloxacin nebenwirkungen cialis generic availability cialis generic tadalafil escitalopram how to use viagra cialis samples overnight zovirax cialis coupon 20 mg pfizer viagra acyclovir lexapro generic lexapro vs celexa generic cialis tadalafil viagra for women cialis savings card first few days on lexapro equipe argentine viagra ciprofloxacin used for finasteride reviews levitra 20 mg viagra tesco ciprofloxacin 500mg antibiotics side effects finasteride tablets cialis cost ciprofloxacin 250 mg how does cialis work acyclovir cream propecia side effects stopping lexapro viagra pill what is acyclovir for viagra coupon how to wean off lexapro lexapro reviews how to wean off lexapro without withdrawals cialis 20mg directions side effects of azithromycin azithromycin tablet viagra vs cialis levitra 20 mg cost walmart azithromycin viagra wikipedia free cialis azithromycin tablets levitra coupon cialis side effects cipro 500 post finasteride syndrome propecia azithromycine 250 mg lexapro overdose levitra rezeptfrei deutschland acyclovir dosing cialis 5 mg levitra without a doctor prescription ciprofloxacin antibiotic ciprofloxacin viagra sex cialis 10 mg tamoxifen bijwerkingen viagra samples escitalopram 10 mg para que sirve azithromycin dosage side effects of finasteride cialis 20 mg viagra on line no prec generic viagra acyclovir 800 mg for shingles canada viagra what is cipro viagra for sale uk cialis for women acyclovir ointment 5 zoloft vs lexapro cialas viagra dosage vardenafil vs viagra azithromycin for uti cialis 5mg cialis copay card cialis without a doctor’s prescription cialis side effects of lexapro in women generic levitra vardenafil 20mg what is finasteride used for tamoxifen side effects in women over 55 cialis medication viagra 100mg what does azithromycin treat cialis dosage recommendations viagra canada azithromycin pregnancy category ciprofloxacin hydrochloride ophthalmic escitalopram oxalate finasteride 5 mg finasteride for women cialis tadalafil viagra vs cialis cialis for daily use does lexapro cause weight gain finasteride long term effects ciprofloxacin drug class tamoxifen langzeitfolgen azithromycin 250 mg what is ciprofloxacin viagra 100 celexa vs lexapro side effects of lexapro cialis daily 200 cialis coupon lexapro dosing finasteride permanent side effects generic for lexapro azithromycin liquid order viagra lexapro benefits for women buy viagra online cialis or viagra zithromax what is ciprofloxacin used for ciprofloxacin 500 mg tamoxifen citrate canada cialis lexapro coupons what does ciprofloxacin 500mg treat azithromycin 500 erectile dysfunction cialis viagra prices cipro uses cilias effects of stopping lexapro suddenly what bacteria does ciprofloxacin kill ciprofloxacin side effects generic for cialis what is tamoxifen viagra receptfritt lexapro dosage side effects of ciprofloxacin viagra without a doctor prescription viagra alternatives ciprofloxacin dosage lexapro withdrawal tamoxifen and weight gain viagra nebenwirkungen acyclovir medication lexapro vs wellbutrin where to buy viagra finasteride results escitalopram 10 mg generic viagra 100mg ciprofloxacin ophthalmic solution ciprofloxacin 500mg azithromycine eg 500 mg bijsluiter ciprofloxacin coverage online cialis lexapro bula cialis coupon wholesale cialis zovirax pills viagra uk azithromycin vs erythromycin lexapro vs zoloft lexapro side effects men viagra vs cialis vs levitra cialis coupons printable what is lexapro for acyclovir 400 mg herbal viagra azithromycin 500 mg ciprofloxacin eye drops cialis generic escitalopram effets secondaires tamoxifen nebenwirkungen acyclovir dosage for cold sores lexapro and weight gain tamoxifen and foods to avoid ciprofloxacin side effects in women viagra cost ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg what works better than viagra cialis samples viagra ohne rezept auf rechnung viagra 50mg cialis professional cialis 30 day sample how to get off lexapro lexapro for anxiety cealis azithromycin uses what is finasteride viagra activate cialis patent expiration date extended effects of stopping finasteride viagra effects lexapro manufacturer website acyclovir for shingles ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg tab azithromycin pediatric dosing viagra medicine cialis dosage zithromax antibiotic acyclovir 800 mg levitra 20mg viagra vs cialis vs levitra levitra cialis discount lexapro and weight loss how long for azithromycin to take effect what is lexapro used for side effects of finasteride 5mg lexapro dosages cialis 30 day trial coupon cheap levitra lexapro 5mg lexapro 20mg what is tamoxifen used for tamoxifen therapy ciprofloxacin hydrochloride ciprofloxacin spc is tamoxifen chemotherapy acyclovir 200mg viagra from canada price cialis viagra for men what does viagra do viagra on line what is cipro usually prescribed for generic lexapro viagra generico revatio vs viagra viagra pillen kruidvat viagra 9 levitra at walmart cialis coupons 2017 buy cialis online side effects of azithromycin 250 mg acyclovir side effects viagra soft tamoxifen lawsuits common side effects of ciprofloxacin 500 mg cialis online what is acyclovir used for cialis alternative cipro dosage is ciprofloxacin a penicillin daily cialis levitra dosage what is acyclovir what is cipro used for levitra bayer 20mg meilleur prix cialis patent expiration ciprofloxacin 500 mg tabletten lexapro side effects in women azithromycin 500 erfahrungen azithromycin 250mg tablets 6 pack what is escitalopram how does lexapro work how long for lexapro to work lexapro 10 mg finasteride 5mg cipro azithromycin without a doctor’s prescription finasteride 1mg viagra cialis nolvadex lowest cialis prices pfizer viagra coupons from pfizer when will cialis go generic azithromycin 250 mg treatment azithromycin 500mg finasteride side effects zithromax dosage viagra natural buy levitra viagra substitute viagra generic viagra pills azithromycin drug class what is azithromycin for cheap cialis is azithromycin viagra sans ordonnance cialis for bph viagra single packs finasteride effets secondaires buying viagra levitra 10 mg prezzo wellbutrin and lexapro cialis price viamedic cialis cialis patent expiration 2017 lexapro 10mg levitra vs viagra for hardness is azithromycin penicillin cialis coupons from manufacturer how long does viagra last acyclovir dosage female viagra tamoxifen side effects azithromycin class viagra alternative azithromycin coverage escitalopram nebenwirkungen how does viagra work azithromycin 5 day dose pack cialis prices cialis vs viagra cialis from canada viagra side effects cialis coupon print lexapro and wellbutrin combination therapy azithromycin and alcohol cialis trial thuoc azithromycin viagra price viagra coupons cialis testimonials ciprofloxacin dosierung cialis pills for sale cialis 5mg daily cipro drug class levitra coupons cipro for uti cialis 20mg cialis website finasteride 5mg side effects mayo clinic viagra kaufen side effects of tamoxifen cialis sample azithromycin 250mg cialis reviews cialis canada