Self Driving car / Photo:

Acupuncture for an Elephant. Big Data in Big Cities

Architect Philipp Kats discusses how Big Data is changing city planning

Read intro

An interview with Philipp Kats

An interview by Alex Karlinsky

We always believe in the promises of those who talk about a fabulous future; we are always disappointed when this future becomes our present. With all the sci-fi movies we watched and books we read in our childhood, we grew up to live in the world without flying cars and intergalactic planes.

Busy with our frustration, we miss the moment when the amazing future actually becomes our reality. Big Data is one of these miracles. The advent of Big Data has been forecasted by many, yet this phenomenon was not fully understood and recognized even when it became a fundamental part of our lives. We talked to Philipp Kats about how Big Data technologies change our cities and us.

An architect by education, Philipp Kats is also a prominent Big Data specialist. He graduated from Kazan State Architectural University and the Strelka Institute for Architecture, Media and Design. Philipp is a co-founder of the Branch Point project. He works as a data analyst and an editor for special projects at the Rambler&Co Studio for infographics. He also teaches at the Saint Petersburg National Research University of Information Technologies, Mechanics and Optics.
Hide intro

How are Big Data technologies used in architecture and city planning today?

First of all, I would like to say that three years ago, when I studied at Strelka, Big Data technologies had just become available. No one knew about them in Russia. One year later, many Russian professionals were already using the best of them and very soon they outgrew even the most advanced. I think it is a very common situation – new technology is being put on a pedestal, praised, but then fairly quickly skepticism appears.

Speaking about architectural or city planning data analysis, I think, nowadays it is a kind of a compromise between modern technologies and traditional analyses. For example, last year I was helping my friend with an architectural student competition in the USA. The city manager provided GIS1 files with very detailed data: transportation networks, volume of traffic, which areas get flooded every five years, high tax rate blocks, demographics, and even information about where puddles appear each year. The statistical accuracy in the USA is pretty high, and data is easy to work with, so we could use it directly without further checking, simply built our proposal on this information.

Big Data doesn’t give you the answers. It helps you ask the right questions

This is, in my opinion, the best way to work with data, when you can take information as a collection of facts and just create your proposal on its basis. It is amazing how differently people can interpret the very same data set and how different the projects based upon them can be.

Screen Shot 2015-12-16 at 15.43.14

Google states that their automatic driverless car system can reduce car accidents rate and, at the same time, help to use fuel as well as road space more effectively /​Photo: google​.com

How do you use Big Data in your own practice?

For a long time, my colleagues Eduard Haiman, Sasha Boldyreva and I have been working on a Branch Point2 project. We tried to work with parametric architecture and develop it further; we all dreamed about parameters-​based design. We hoped to create — on the basis of some tricky code — an algorithm, through iterations of which, some new formal solutions could emerge: not the designs we could make ourselves, but new, totally unexpected and beautiful ones.

We wanted to achieve sort of a Bjarke Ingels effect. His buildings look absolutely strange and crazy, but he can always demonstrate you – in a few simple steps – that this is the optimal and the most practical solution. There is always a good deal of speculation in his demonstrations, but his argumentation works.

At a later stage of the project, we realized that while being not entirely unrealistic, this idea does not seem that appealing anymore. We started doubting this design by algorithms. You probably could keep moving in this direction, but it will be hard to get a plausible result.

Here is an important dialectical issue. Imagine you want to write an algorithm, it always needs very basic formal parameters in the first place. In a complex system such as a building or an urban block, there will be very many parameters and you will always need an initial formal idea – a shape that only a designer can create.

Analyzing Zaha Hadid’s projects, for instance, we always see that an elegant formal concept lies at its core, all digital transformations are based on this initial design. The first idea of the author, the first gesture is fundamental. Any genetic algorithm can calculate which of the several ideas is optimal, but it cannot generate ideas on its own.

So the designer’s will is fundamental. How will the amount of human contribution to the design process change with further development of Big Data analysis methods?

I imagine an analytical machine of some kind – a big and complex quantum computer hidden somewhere in a secret chamber, making in the manner of telepaths and parapsychologists predictions and forecasts for mankind.

I personally think that people will always be part of the process. All this stuff [Big Data analysis methods] is called decision making helper algorithms, and the purpose of these helpers is to find flaws and errors in the process, correct them, and, also, reduce human labor. Man will always be a decision maker and algorithms will provide him with everything, except for the decision itself. You need certain technical knowledge to work in this field, but analytics is art and an algorithm is always like a painting.

Phantom/GoPro Camera Quadcopter Drone

Drone equipped with a camera can patrol a given territory independently and transfer images to the information center in real time /​photo: Kevin Baird /​Flickr​.com

But data is always incomplete. How can we rely on Big Data if we know that there will be always errors and gaps in our cloud of information?

It’s true. Analysts are often criticized, for instance, for taking into account only those users who are connected to the Internet. Those who do not have computers are not part of the data we work with. This is true, but frankly speaking, if we know nothing about the problems of one ‘babushka’ who is too shy to use Internet, we can simply ignore her. We have to be cynical to some extend: either this ‘babushka’ changes her attitude or her grandson teaches her how to go online.

Another issue which is always a subject of our discussions is that the technology we have for collecting and storing often cannot ensure the stable flow of information without glitches and errors. We also know that it is absolutely impossible to track everything. I mean, we can track some basic things, but the reasons of certain actions or phenomena often remain unclear. Big Data does not give you the answers. Data collection and analysis help you to ask the right questions.

How does the possibility to ask new questions change our idea of the city?

Eduard Haiman invented a term ‘Plagopolis’. The idea is that the contemporary city — and this trend is clear — becomes more proactive and dynamic. It is an environment in constant flux, which also constantly regulates itself. You can identify certain element and describe it with approximation, but it immediately changes and changes other elements around itself. The city cannot be seen as a mechanism anymore.

Is this idea accepted by Russian city planners?

In Russia, there is no clear understanding of what city planning is. We always draw roads and streets first and believe that everything stays exactly the way we envisaged it forever. At the very best, we start thinking about drawing the streets better – and then maybe it works or may be city dwellers rearrange everything according to their needs themselves.

The city reminds us of a proverbial elephant from the story about blind people. One blind man touches the elephant’s ear, another grabs his trunk, the last one grabs him by the ass

Architects and city planners drive me crazy sometimes with their very stereotypical thinking. They just say: “Pedestrians are better than cars!” or “Creative business will turn industrial parks into paradisiacal islands”. I would like to see some reliable data, some research or at least some basic calculations behind these statements, because these assumptions could be true but could be also very wrong.

How can Big Data help us to understand the city better?

The city is always a proverbial elephant from a story about blind people, who wanted to describe an elephant by touching his different parts. We usually work the same way — someone grabs the elephant’s ass, someone touches an ear, someone grabs a trunk. Each of the blind men thinks that he knows what an elephant looks like.

Big data gives us an overview. As a result, when we focus on one part of the city we know that there are also many other components to it – and all of them together constitute one whole. Yet Big data as such does not give us the understanding of all the complexities. And it will never give that understanding.

I regularly get new data on the city. I can always take a closer look into some specific pieces of data and ask: why? The data itself will not give the answer; it just gives you a good reason to start an exploration, a research, or a new story.

Do these explorations inspired by Big Data turn into real city projects?

There is a method of so called ‘city acupuncture’. You basically search for certain key points – places of energy in the city (it could be a block or a building or even a gap in between buildings), and then in these places make well calculated and well planned changes. The changes could be microscopic and require only a very small budget, but their effect to the city could be enormous. Big Data can help identify these key points.

City acupuncture is still largely a theoretical concept, but we have some examples of small scale spatial solutions with an enormous impaction our lives. For instance, the system of traffic lights, those react on the traffic intensity.

Also today, businesses and industries get robotized, and it creates value too. If now drones start transporting goods, city logistics will benefit immensely – working with data collected by them will be much easier than with real truckers.

Technology which inspires me now, and which I hope will have an impact on architecture, is a new project by Amazon. The idea is that a smart loudspeaker is positioned in the center of a house. It listens to all your questions and gives answers. It resembles Siri7 more or less, but in your home. And this technology would probably change our sense of space more than any algorithm.


GIS data combined with spatial modeling algorithms can help forecast the level of insolation on a chosen territory /​photo: Trevor Patt /​Flickr​.com

In other words, the city will depend more and more on the software?

Exactly. Today, the input/​output systems and different city interfaces change a lot institutionally. I think that a cheaper and better taxi service could change my life much more effectively than 90 percent of the decisions made by city planners.

For instance, Über and Yandex.Taxi affect my perception of the city enormously. With all this competition between various taxi services, it turned out that taxi in Moscow could be fast, efficient and relatively cheap — much better than in New York, for instance.

A cheaper and better taxi service can change my life much more effectively than 90% of decision made by city planners

Another service which can benefit a lot from «uberification» is, of course, prostitution. Some clients are shy and don’t use prostitutes’ services because of that. To look for a prostitute in the street could be also dangerous and unpleasant. With a phone it is much easier. Of course, pimps will be out of business, but it is a fair deal, I guess. Someone will definitely do it — and soon — in one of the more liberal countries.

Do you think users will be able to manage Big Data technologies on their own in the future?

The complexity of technology will keep growing exponentially, but we will also learn how to pack it properly. Sleek interfaces make it simple. You do not need to think about what is actually happening. You touch here, press the button there and it works. The more you can hide from a user today – the better. People are now a bit scared of all these incomprehensible processes. There is still no technology as the one we have seen in the film ‘Minority Report’, but I think it describes what is going to happen in the future pretty accurately.

What do you think is the next Big Data challenge?

At the beginning, Big Data was just a fancy concept. It is now slowly but surely falling out of fashion, because the most obvious things have been already done. The next important step is to develop technical algorithms in a very utilitarian way. In five years, the position of a digital analyst (quite well paid and quite boring, I guess) will become a standard position at municipalities, governmental offices and business companies.

And the last problem with Big Data is pretty obvious. There are people who know what they are doing and there are people who do not know how Big Data works but make money on it. The gap between professional technologists who work and experiment in their small world, and people who know how to make real projects for the city always existed. We need to find ways for better communication between analysts and practitioners – this is the key to Big Data success in the future.

buy generic viagra finasteride 5 mg tab finasteride effets secondaires cialis tadalafil buy viagra online propecia buying viagra viagra effects tamoxifen interaction how to wean off lexapro without withdrawals what does ciprofloxacin 500mg treat female viagra utilisation viagra azithromycin three times a week lexapro dosages pfizer viagra coupons from pfizer escitalopram effets secondaires viagra vs cialis free viagra ciprofloxacin hydrochloride viagra 100mg azithromycine eg 500 mg bijsluiter lexapro overdose ciprofloxacin drug class where to buy viagra lexapro benefits for women ciprofloxacin side effects ciprofloxacin buy levitra ciprofloxacin dosierung escitalopram 20 mg how long for lexapro to work viagra 100mg tablets retail price cialis dosage strengths ciprofloxacin dose cialis 30 day sample buy levitra online viagra tesco cipro 500 azithromycin 500 mg viagra bestellen online cialis what is acyclovir used for ciprofloxacin 500mg antibiotics side effects cost of cialis cialis vs viagra lexapro 10mg finasteride vs dutasteride lexapro medication what is finasteride used for cialis coupons from manufacturer viagra receptfritt what is lexapro used for effects of stopping finasteride how does acyclovir work effects of stopping lexapro suddenly lexapro vs celexa lexapro withdrawal symptoms how to take cialis cialis sample ciprofloxacin eye drops ciprofloxacin ophthalmic solution acyclovir for shingles viagra samples finasteride how does lexapro work acyclovir 800 mg cipro uses does lexapro cause weight gain finasteride and enlarged prostate ciprofloxacin 250mg cialis free trial viagra wiki escitalopram 10 mg cheap levitra tamoxifen nebenwirkungen viagra alternative azithromycin and alcohol nolvadex order viagra zovirax for cold sores cipro for uti cialis 20 mg how long for azithromycin to take effect over the counter viagra cialis otc what does finasteride do azithromycin medscape what does azithromycin treat cialis samples levitra rezeptfrei deutschland side effects of finasteride finasteride 1mg what is azithromycin ciprofloxacin class 200 cialis coupon when will cialis go generic finasteride efectos secundarios ciprofloxacin 500 9 levitra at walmart ciprofloxacin hydrochloride ophthalmic how long does viagra last cialis dosage viagra coupons zithromax antibiotic azithromycin drug class azithromycin pregnancy category lexapro vs wellbutrin lexapro side effects men price cialis levitra bayer 20mg meilleur prix viagra vs cialis side effects lexapro cipro lexapro reviews pfizer viagra cialis prices how to get off lexapro azithromycin uses cialis price wellbutrin and lexapro tamoxifen acyclovir ointment 5 weaning off lexapro cialis medication ciprofloxacin 250 mg acyclovir vs valacyclovir acyclovir 400 mg what is viagra zithromax dosage generic cialis at walmart lexapro and weight gain azithromycin vs erythromycin levitra 10 mg prezzo acyclovir for cold sores azithromycin tablet azithromycin pediatric dosing viagra wikipedia finasteride side effects viagra tablet viagra sans ordonnance cialis pills cialis for daily use escitalopram 10mg cialis patent expiration date extended side effects of tamoxifen cialis effects viagra ohne rezept aus deutschland ciprofloxacin drops cialis website lexapro coupons azithromycine cyalis cipro drug class cialis without a doctor’s prescription natural viagra ciprofloxacin 500 mg for urinary tract infection viagra pillen kruidvat viamedic cialis acyclovir 800mg side effects of ciprofloxacin 500 mg viagra medicine ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg tab canada viagra levitra viagra ohne rezept auf rechnung wholesale cialis what is azithromycin for cialis daily viagra price is ciprofloxacin a penicillin tamoxifen langzeitfolgen viagra activate levitra without a doctor prescription acyclovir zoloft vs lexapro cialis 5mg levitra coupon cialis voucher discount cialis viagra substitute azithromycin 5 day dose pack levitra 20 mg von bayer azithromycin side effects cipro antibiotic tamoxifen and weight gain side effects of lexapro 10 mg levitra prices viagra costs what is ciprofloxacin used for ciprofloxacin 500mg tablets viagra kaufen what does viagra do cialis discount daily cialis acyclovir side effects how to use viagra tamoxifen and bone pain finasteride for women viagra for sale thuoc azithromycin viagra 50mg is azithromycin cialis side effects what is tamoxifen how to wean off lexapro finasteride hair loss best price viagra viagra coupon levitra vs viagra how does viagra work tamoxifen side effects in women what is lexapro for acyclovir cream zovirax pills generic cialis tadalafil sophia viagra what works better than viagra cialis professional cialis 20mg zithromax z-​pak azithromycin 250 mg treatment viagra uk levitra coupons cheap cialis ciprofloxacin hcl levitra 20 mg cost walmart side effects of azithromycin side effects of finasteride 5mg acyclovir dosing ciprofloxacin nebenwirkungen viagra alternatives azithromycin 250 mg cipro dangers zovirax ointment cialis patent expiration 2017 vardenafil vs viagra common side effects of ciprofloxacin 500 mg escitalopram free cialis viagra canada cialis generic azithromycin 500 erfahrungen finasteride for hair loss escitalopram oxalate side effects of cialis cialis online stopping lexapro cipro dosage cialis for sale lexapro manufacturer website viagra online cialis or viagra azithromycin pregnancy cialis trial viagra 100 acyclovir medication cialis cost finasteride 5mg levitra 20mg cost per pill finasteride 5mg side effects mayo clinic generic levitra cialis canada cialis coupons 2017 azithromycin for uti sex viagra for women cialis coupons printable side effects of lexapro in women cialis 30 day trial coupon viagra sex tamoxifen side effects in women over 55 ciprofloxacin 500mg antibiotics azithromycin without a doctor’s prescription lexapro and weight gain in women viagra 100 mg cialis savings card cost of viagra levitra vs viagra for hardness canadian viagra lexapro side effects how much does cialis cost buy viagra cialis copay card cialis for women withdrawal from lexapro cialis 20mg directions azithromycin 250 what is ciprofloxacin prescribed for viagra without a doctor prescription usa viagra for sale uk lexapro vs zoloft viagra generic cialis 10 mg cipro side effects viagra without a doctor prescription lexapro and weight loss cilias side effects of viagra cialis coupons cialis coupon escitalopram nebenwirkungen cialis cheap acyclovir ointment women viagra viagra nebenwirkungen what is cipro used for lexapro for anxiety zithromax tamoxifen bijwerkingen cialis pharmacy prices finasteride long term effects acyclovir 800 mg for shingles what is lexapro levitra 20 mg precio farmacia what is escitalopram cialis generic tadalafil viagra vs cialis vs levitra is lexapro a controlled substance online viagra canadian cialis lexapro and wellbutrin combination therapy viagra for women viagra soft viagra generico zovirax cialis reviews cialis on line acyclovir dosage for cold sores azithromycin 500 cialis pricing generic lexapro levitra vs viagra what is acyclovir what bacteria does ciprofloxacin kill zovirax dosage azithromycin eye drops what is cipro zovirax cream what infections does ciprofloxacin treat finasteride 5 mg levitra online viagra on line ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg lexapro bula finasteride tablets ciprofloxacin 500mg azithromycin class is azithromycin penicillin viagra prices levitra erfahrungen azithromycin lexapro weight gain ciprofloxacin coverage cialis coupon 20 mg what is finasteride what is cipro usually prescribed for lexapro 5mg viagra for men tamoxifen lawsuits levitra 20mg buy generic levitra azithromycin liquid cialis 5mg daily levitra generic lowest cialis prices azithromycin 500mg buy cialis online cialis vs viagra lexapro generic name cialis testimonials lexapro dosage finasteride 5mg tab azithromycin coverage ciprofloxacin for dogs herbal viagra generic viagra ciprofloxacin dosage acyclovir 400mg lexapro 10 mg azithromycin dosage ciprofloxacin side effects after age 60 what is azithromycin used for cipro antibiotics post finasteride syndrome azithromycin for pneumonia acyclovir 200mg lexapro withdrawal viagra on line no prec azithromycin 250mg tablets 6 pack cialis from canada viagra cialis tamoxifen and foods to avoid viagra dosage antibiotic ciprofloxacin finasteride 5mg side effects cialis for men zithromax 500 mg celexa vs lexapro ciprofloxacin side effects in women canada cialis generic levitra vardenafil 20mg how does cialis work cialis dosage recommendations vardenafil 20mg what does ciprofloxacin treat cialis pills for sale generic viagra 100mg side effects of ciprofloxacin acyclovir dosage finasteride side effects in men lexapro viagra natural levitra 20 mg lexapro dosing what is acyclovir for cialis generic availability lexapro para que sirve liquid cialis ciprofloxacin spc escitalopram 10 mg para que sirve lexapro side effects in men erectile dysfunction cialis viagra single packs azithromycin 250mg side effects of acyclovir tamoxifen cost ciprofloxacin uses lexapro generic cipro and tendonitis buy cialis generic cialis first few days on lexapro viagra generic for cialis cialis finasteride dosage ciprofloxacin used for cialis patent expiration ciprofloxacin 500 mg cialis for bph what is cialis ciprofloxacin bnf viagra cost side effects of azithromycin 250 mg cipro side effects in elderly finasteride reviews viagra en ligne livraison 24h propecia side effects viagra tablets cealis lexapro side effects in women azithromycin cost viagra side effects lexapro 20mg azithromycine 250 mg viagra pill side effects of lexapro finasteride permanent side effects ciprofloxacin 500 mg tabletten ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg side effects cialis alternative escitalopram side effects finasteride medication finasteride results azithromycin for strep throat azithromycin z pak what is tamoxifen used for azithromycin tablets cialis samples overnight tamoxifen citrate viagra vs cialis vs levitra generic for lexapro tamoxifen therapy cialas revatio vs viagra cialis 5 mg viagra from canada levitra prezzo in farmacia is tamoxifen chemotherapy tamoxifen side effects cialis coupon print cialis canadian pharmacy equipe argentine viagra acyclovir dose cheap viagra what is ciprofloxacin acyclovir 800 mg 5 times a day levitra dosage viagra pills discount viagra