3D Scan of Arctic Ice Floe: Floe A1006 in September 2011, Fram Strait, North West of Svalbard / photo: Scanlabprojects.co.uk

A hallucinogenic copy of reality

An interview with architect William Trossell by Guilherme Vieira on heritage preservation and 3D scanning

Read intro

An interview with William Trossell

An interview by Guilherme Vieira

William Trossell is an expert in capturing perfect 3D datasets of objects, buildings and landscapes for digital design and fabrication technologies. For him, the city of the future will be both physical and digital and the lines between those will become increasingly blurred. His work is a belief that the uses of augmented reality will allow us to walk around the physical city whilst also visiting the digital. This is an area where designers will focus on creating new virtual and augmented-reality experiences in the upcoming years. William shared his thoughts on heritage preservation and how we can use his expertise to preserve digitally more than memory or fragments of reality.

William Trossell is an architect with a background in digital fabrication and a unique insight into industries where 3D scanning can have a substantial impact. As the co-founder of ScanLAB Projects, that is the UK’s leading provider of large scale 3D scanning, he has been able to capture precise digital replicas of buildings, landscapes, objects and events through a series of commercial projects and research activities. He is also involved in teaching and research at the Bartlett School of Architecture, University College London, trying to constantly explore and expand the potential of this powerful technology.
Hide intro

To set a starting point for the conversation, could you define these two terms: Heritage and Preservation.

Heritage is something that has been handed down to you from a previous generation and it is something to be utilized. It is your decision as a generation to work out the best thing to do with that asset. Maybe it will be through a scan and its digital model that allows people to do something with such data, whether it will be a music video, an animation or an Oculus™ Rift environment. It is about taking it forward and making something exciting, passionate and new with it, rather than leaving it to rot. Preservation is something very different in my eyes. It is about capturing the past, seeing its layers and then choosing or freezing one moment in time which will therefore, then, suspend something within. Or preserve all its layers and try to fight the aging or the natural wearing of a material, a site or a location.

Would you say then that heritage is also something that is completely unique?

Yes. Heritage is individual to all of us. We all have a different idea about where things should go and where things have come from. So it is culturally a very rich area and quite humanistic.

ScanLAB projects utilise a range of laser scanning technologies with different capabilities, ranges, speeds and accuracies.

Do you think that 3D scanning is a way to preserve heritage or a way to preserve its memory?

A 3D scan has no volume, no surface and no weight. It purely sees the tiniest surface of something and it has no depth to it. It is a very technological response to a material. Whether you are looking at concrete, at a tissue or at a paper, they are all recorded in the same way. In this sense, you can preserve heritage only by extracting its shape and its singular view from it that preserves a moment in time. Such example is embodied in our work when we scan events where the only kind of recording of it is normally within the people that attended the show. To actually try to capture a 3D version of this entire show takes us to a different sort of realm. There is obviously the ability in this technology to become faster and it could record a fourth dimension of time and a movement much like we can with video.

Heritage is individual to all of us

It wouldn’t be possible to use the 3D scanning to capture a 3D moment like a picture by recurring to several scans in predefined places?

Currently no. And that is because it takes a minimum of 2 minutes to do a complete scan. Walking though the scene would have to be exceptionally slow for us to capture it. It’s like the photography of the 1800s where wet plates were put in the back of the camera and exposures of 4 to 5 minutes were needed for enough light to react with the silver compounds which were on the back of the negative. So the people that stood still were the first people to be photographed. We have the same kind of problem, the people that stand still are the ones we capture whereas the moving objects, at the moment, are simply just blurs or fuzz to us. Basically we will need a leap in the technology to be able to get the exposure of each scan down to seconds rather than minutes. But the high end of what we are doing, high resolution scans, each scan can take about two hours.

Are the technology advances of today going in that direction?

Yes. I think that is definitely the ambition of the big manufactures. To make it much faster, smaller and cheaper because they are chasing profits and to keep innovating ahead of their rivals is the classic thing to do.

Do you think that it is possible to use 3D scanning to preserve intangible heritage such as knowledge, artistic or cultural traditions?

No. I think that is going to be very hard. All those elements of cultural heritage will be relied on a different media, whether it will be film or audio or some other technology that is yet to be invented. I think laser scanning deals with the physical world and its ability to capture the state of objects and their positions in time.

You worked with leading art and social institutions but does UNESCO use your techniques or work as a resource in the preservation of heritage sites?

No. But I know that they use it regularly in all sorts of other jobs. The other body here in the UK is English Heritage and they do a lot of things very similar to this, whether it will be the capture of an iron bridge or the Stonehenge monuments. There was a lot of research done there recently. They uncovered additional circles of stones because the weather during the summer was so dry that the grass shrunk and since they got back and laser scanned it they can see the depression that were left on the ground.

ScanLAB Projects and Brigitte Stepputtis produced this video piece following a recent fashion shoot without cameras and using terrestrial laser scanning to capture the surface of the models, textiles and architecture with forensic precision.

Do you believe that the digital models created through scanning can be used to replace the heritage in case of permanent destruction?

Yes, and I believe that it has already been done by CyArk. They have scanned several huts in Africa and after some of them have burned down they were able to reconstruct the huts from the data. It is an interesting question, because in some ways by digitizing space we are kind of neglecting the reality. When we were going to the Arctic to scan the ice, people were worried that once we captured it, we wouldn’t need the real one anymore. In some way, it could be disposed of because we could always replicate it. On a philosophical level it is quite interesting, because then you are approaching this strange god-​like ability to control our climate, weather and physical surroundings.

Would you believe that whenever we preserve some heritage in a digital way,instead of engaging people we do the opposite?

Absolutely. I think there is always a danger that the digital is fantasized over more than the reality. It is an interesting philosophical aspect to look at it in terms of replicas and facsimiles. Like in the Valley of the Kings, in Egypt, where the facsimiles made of the tombs are able to be indistinguishable from the original and so allow people to visit them in order to not destroy the real ones. But then the user’s experience kind of waters down. Imagine a digital environment where the point cloud is such high definition that you wouldn’t be able to distinguish the difference between reality and virtual anymore. It is something that we are not close to yet, because of the resolution that we are able to capture, but maybe in 20 years’ time there would be such an indistinguishable line between the two that you wouldn’t know where you were, a sort of matrix almost.

3D scanning does a very good job freezing a moment in time, and that can be with people as well as with buildings

You are referring to the blurred line between the digital and physical city that you spoke about in some other articles?

Absolutely. And I think it is some way off in the future but before there will be a very grey area where things begin to be pretty bonkers. In animation there is something called ‘uncanny valley’ that is when people begin to create ever more realistic human animations in CTI (Computer Telephony Integration) and there is a sharp increase in what is perceived as real. Our human instinct to distinguish between CTI and what is real becomes very acute.

What do we actually lose in the experience of the digital models compared to the real and physical heritage?

I don’t think that virtual reality does a very good job in replicating where you should be with reality. I think the two are still very distinguishable, so when you place an Oculus Rift in the studio it is an additional environment but it is certainly not a replacement for the real world. There are so many aspects to our senses that fail to beat or even to compete. For us, it’s quite frustrating because we get to go visit all these physical places and then see them digitally. And although there is a little bit of déjà vu it is not quite the same as being there. Often our work is only still a screen based medium and it is quite rare that we have the opportunity to physically recreate an environment.

Future Perfect is a fictional city created in a think tank event titled Under Tomorrows Sky

Isn’t the non-​typical heritage in greater danger of disappearance than the considered heritage?

I guess it is down to governments or small NGO’s to really direct what is the cultural heritage that we should be preserving. I think that we are doing a very good job in capturing our heritage in photography. We are constantly sharing and updating information and as hard drives become better in their ability to save information we will never throw away much, digitally. In this sense, I think that we will always continue to add to this database. There was an interesting article the other day in the UK papers saying that The Sun has got a safe in their offices full of stories of the last 50 years which they deemed too controversial to publish. It is a hard piece of material archive that will live on as long as the paper can survive, but digitally things can potentially live on forever.

Do you believe that we will reach a point where we are able to preserve heritage in a faster pace than we actually lose it?

Probably yes. I think that we should be able to, eventually, with the speed of machines having a role in conserving things. You can imagine if your phone 3D scans without you needing to operate it and then through a mapping program you can track all the worlds’ phones and begin to map things. We will be walking around a scanless base and living like a second life.

Will it be the same as having a bubble around us that keeps on scanning and generating data?

Exactly. The first thing is to scan it once and then update it. That might take a while. It’s interesting to see that Google is continuously updating street view and they didn’t do it just once. And I think the same thing will happen in 3D. From the small scale we will watch things decay but on the city level, just like Google being able to update street view within 6 months, we will be looking to a 3D capture of the city on a weekly basis.

It is about human perception then?

Yes, absolutely. And usefulness. If it is not useful, no one is going to bother. But if people are interested and if there is a desire then they will continue to contribute.

How do you perceive the role of an architect in the creation of the future cities?

I think it depends very much on the culture. If you look at London, our planning laws are quite strict so things only get demolished when culturally we all agree that it can be better to remove it. So there is a kind of collective decision in removing and rebuilding it. I think that preservation plays different roles in different cultures. Perhaps in a different culture people are not so worried and they are more interested in layering and taking one down and adding another one up. It very much depends on who you are talking to.

In some ways by digitizing space we are neglecting reality

Can you imagine the idea of walking in a city that substitutes the physical for digital like in forms of holograms?

Yes. There is technology coming to us which will give us a holographic and virtual reality of the real world, like Magic Leap, which will be projecting directly onto your optic nerve, short cutting the need of your eye bulb and going directly to your brain to make things appear like they are in reality – sort of a hallucinogenic copy of reality. And that will be interesting. Looking at science fiction films is always a kind of interesting thought to where we might be in the future. Whether it is like the Minority Report (2002) or whether it will be Blade Runner (1982), such futures are possible, but they all demand an interesting kind of conversation.

What tools do you think will be used in the future to preserve heritage once 3D scanning becomes outdated?

I think that there will be an interest in seeing beneath the surface like a giant CT (Computerized Tomography) scanner that would be able to record far more information about the space than 3D scanning. Simply because it is looking at the atoms rather than simply the outer surface. We could build a building sized CT scanner and I think that will be pretty amazing.

viagra canada online cialis cialis pills ciprofloxacin nebenwirkungen ciprofloxacin hydrochloride ophthalmic lexapro 10mg side effects lexapro viagra without a doctor prescription usa viagra vs cialis antibiotic ciprofloxacin liquid cialis what does ciprofloxacin 500mg treat zovirax dosage buy cialis tamoxifen side effects acyclovir ointment azithromycin pediatric dosing cialis price cialis patent expiration date extended acyclovir 400 mg ciprofloxacin for dogs tamoxifen therapy escitalopram side effects lexapro generic name wholesale cialis viagra soft free viagra cialis on line what is tamoxifen used for finasteride long term effects revatio vs viagra ciprofloxacin drug class cialis 5mg lexapro withdrawal symptoms is lexapro a controlled substance tamoxifen side effects in women viagra vs cialis levitra online cialas azithromycin 250 mg treatment side effects of cialis viagra medicine canadian cialis utilisation viagra side effects of tamoxifen buy viagra online side effects of acyclovir ciprofloxacin class tamoxifen nebenwirkungen cialis 20 mg finasteride vs dutasteride escitalopram oxalate levitra viagra nebenwirkungen levitra coupon generic levitra cialis generic tadalafil ciprofloxacin 500 mg tabletten cialis reviews viagra wiki buy levitra tamoxifen langzeitfolgen cialis generic availability over the counter viagra azithromycin 250 natural viagra zovirax ointment sophia viagra cialis discount cialis for sale azithromycin vs erythromycin cialis dosage recommendations what does viagra do viagra kaufen cealis zithromax 500 mg zoloft vs lexapro lexapro and weight gain viagra receptfritt how does viagra work cialis coupons effects of stopping lexapro suddenly is tamoxifen chemotherapy viagra costs cialis cost side effects of lexapro 10 mg acyclovir 800 mg 5 times a day levitra prices viagra azithromycin 500 erfahrungen viagra sex escitalopram levitra 20 mg first few days on lexapro how to wean off lexapro without withdrawals tamoxifen cost lexapro vs zoloft lexapro para que sirve how to take cialis how to wean off lexapro side effects of finasteride levitra 20 mg von bayer finasteride lexapro 20mg acyclovir for shingles how much does cialis cost viagra tablets acyclovir side effects zithromax dosage lexapro withdrawal zovirax pills generic viagra azithromycin three times a week ciprofloxacin 500mg antibiotics lexapro vs celexa lexapro coupons escitalopram nebenwirkungen acyclovir 800 mg for shingles thuoc azithromycin ciprofloxacin 500mg tablets generic cialis vardenafil vs viagra acyclovir ointment 5 generic cialis at walmart cialis canadian pharmacy acyclovir for cold sores finasteride 5mg side effects mayo clinic viagra vs cialis vs levitra side effects of ciprofloxacin 500 mg azithromycin liquid levitra prezzo in farmacia viagra coupon zovirax cream does lexapro cause weight gain finasteride 5mg tab levitra 20 mg cost walmart levitra rezeptfrei deutschland viagra 100 side effects of azithromycin cheap cialis viagra en ligne livraison 24h zovirax what is azithromycin used for viagra online viagra vs cialis vs levitra weaning off lexapro cialis 30 day trial coupon azithromycin side effects what is tamoxifen stopping lexapro levitra 20 mg precio farmacia azithromycine 250 mg tamoxifen and foods to avoid cialis online cialis cheap celexa vs lexapro buy cialis online viagra on line levitra generic herbal viagra pfizer viagra ciprofloxacin side effects finasteride side effects in men viagra dosage best price viagra when will cialis go generic ciprofloxacin side effects in women cipro drug class what is lexapro for finasteride reviews viagra activate ciprofloxacin 500mg antibiotics side effects cialis pharmacy prices what is acyclovir used for ciprofloxacin 250mg viagra pill viagra from canada what is cipro usually prescribed for escitalopram 10mg what does azithromycin treat ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg side effects viagra for women ciprofloxacin ophthalmic solution canada cialis lexapro medication how does lexapro work azithromycin medscape acyclovir dosing lexapro overdose side effects of lexapro in women cialis tadalafil lexapro side effects men cialis generic viagra generic lexapro weight gain lexapro side effects in women cialis for bph cipro for uti levitra erfahrungen escitalopram 20 mg azithromycin for strep throat tamoxifen and bone pain ciprofloxacin hydrochloride cost of cialis azithromycin coverage finasteride hair loss lexapro generic levitra 10 mg prezzo ciprofloxacin eye drops cialis trial viagra sans ordonnance cialis vs viagra tamoxifen ciprofloxacin dose lexapro and weight gain in women cipro antibiotic lexapro dosage ciprofloxacin 500mg ciprofloxacin bnf cialis patent expiration 2017 viagra prices azithromycin 500mg finasteride 1mg finasteride 5mg lexapro escitalopram 10 mg finasteride permanent side effects azithromycin drug class tamoxifen citrate sex viagra for women how does acyclovir work viagra cost cialis canada cialis for daily use what is finasteride propecia side effects cilias finasteride for hair loss azithromycin pregnancy ciprofloxacin drops buy viagra cialis side effects cialis pricing where to buy viagra buy levitra online viagra 50mg acyclovir 800 mg azithromycine eg 500 mg bijsluiter pfizer viagra coupons from pfizer azithromycin 250mg tablets 6 pack cialis coupon levitra without a doctor prescription cialis from canada effects of stopping finasteride cialis otc viagra 100mg tablets retail price cialis coupon print cipro uses what is cialis acyclovir vs valacyclovir viagra cialis generic levitra vardenafil 20mg acyclovir 400mg what is acyclovir what is ciprofloxacin tamoxifen side effects in women over 55 finasteride side effects lexapro for anxiety cialis voucher zithromax z-​pak viagra pills finasteride tablets tamoxifen and weight gain viamedic cialis women viagra cialis effects lexapro manufacturer website cialis testimonials online viagra ciprofloxacin 250 mg azithromycine what does finasteride do cialis 20mg cialis for women azithromycin 250mg levitra bayer 20mg meilleur prix cialis coupons from manufacturer viagra without a doctor prescription cyalis ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg generic lexapro cialis pills for sale lexapro reviews what is azithromycin side effects of ciprofloxacin cialis 5mg daily what bacteria does ciprofloxacin kill viagra wikipedia cialis 20mg directions vardenafil 20mg viagra for sale viagra 100mg azithromycin side effects of azithromycin 250 mg what is viagra what works better than viagra what infections does ciprofloxacin treat cialis 30 day sample cialis or viagra 200 cialis coupon how long for azithromycin to take effect cipro and tendonitis viagra samples cipro antibiotics finasteride 5 mg tab viagra on line no prec ciprofloxacin coverage azithromycin for uti cialis dosage withdrawal from lexapro viagra price azithromycin dosage finasteride for women what is cipro used for cialis 10 mg lexapro bula azithromycin 500 escitalopram 10 mg para que sirve ciprofloxacin spc ciprofloxacin 500 zithromax antibiotic viagra coupons generic cialis tadalafil viagra uk azithromycin pregnancy category azithromycin tablets acyclovir medication cialis what is cipro acyclovir 800mg lowest cialis prices zovirax for cold sores levitra vs viagra viagra for sale uk levitra dosage zithromax levitra coupons azithromycin for pneumonia viagra substitute cialis medication acyclovir dosage for cold sores viagra ohne rezept aus deutschland viagra side effects finasteride 5 mg female viagra cialis coupons printable tamoxifen interaction ciprofloxacin dosierung viagra bestellen what is ciprofloxacin used for cialis samples cialis sample side effects of viagra is azithromycin ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg tab is azithromycin penicillin how long for lexapro to work lexapro and weight loss cialis for men cipro side effects in elderly levitra 20mg cost per pill levitra vs viagra for hardness viagra ohne rezept auf rechnung what is ciprofloxacin prescribed for what is azithromycin for what does ciprofloxacin treat azithromycin cost viagra 100 mg ciprofloxacin uses finasteride results ciprofloxacin hcl side effects of lexapro buy generic levitra lexapro and wellbutrin combination therapy cost of viagra free cialis viagra effects lexapro side effects cipro dangers discount viagra buying viagra common side effects of ciprofloxacin 500 mg cialis alternative cialis 5 mg cipro how does cialis work lexapro 10 mg what is escitalopram ciprofloxacin viagra natural azithromycin z pak azithromycin tablet what is lexapro used for acyclovir dosage azithromycin 250 mg azithromycin 500 mg cialis prices cheap levitra equipe argentine viagra how to use viagra cialis copay card side effects of finasteride 5mg cipro side effects cialis coupons 2017 cialis samples overnight what is lexapro wellbutrin and lexapro price cialis erectile dysfunction cialis cialis professional cialis dosage strengths acyclovir azithromycin 5 day dose pack levitra 20mg cialis savings card lexapro dosing cialis website lexapro side effects in men viagra generico lexapro 5mg order viagra finasteride medication finasteride efectos secundarios cialis coupon 20 mg tamoxifen bijwerkingen azithromycin uses acyclovir 200mg buy generic viagra cialis without a doctor’s prescription daily cialis generic for cialis ciprofloxacin dosage viagra for men viagra tablet nolvadex cialis free trial lexapro dosages finasteride dosage discount cialis finasteride 5mg side effects canada viagra escitalopram effets secondaires cheap viagra is ciprofloxacin a penicillin 9 levitra at walmart lexapro vs wellbutrin canadian viagra generic for lexapro cipro 500 viagra alternative what is finasteride used for finasteride effets secondaires tamoxifen lawsuits ciprofloxacin 500 mg acyclovir dose azithromycin class ciprofloxacin side effects after age 60 cialis daily how long does viagra last viagra tesco azithromycin and alcohol viagra pillen kruidvat generic viagra 100mg cipro dosage lexapro benefits for women levitra vs viagra viagra alternatives viagra single packs ciprofloxacin 500 mg for urinary tract infection how to get off lexapro acyclovir cream cialis patent expiration post finasteride syndrome azithromycin without a doctor’s prescription cialis vs viagra propecia finasteride and enlarged prostate ciprofloxacin used for azithromycin eye drops what is acyclovir for