Photo: Grant Hutchinson /

A city that sees you, a city that remembers you

An interview with the executive director of Russian Research Center on the Internet of Things Vadim Chekletsov

Read intro

An interview with Vadim Chekletsov

An interview by Varvara Nazarova

Internet of Things is a name for a network of technologies, physical objects and software. Russian researcher of this trend discovers what’s going on in the field now and when we should expect city environment to come to life.

Vadim Chekletsov is the executive director of Russian Research Center on the Internet of Things, and author of the book 'Sense of the planet. The Internet of Things and next technological revolution'.
Hide intro

What exactly is the Internet of Things nowadays?

Nothing. There is no Internet of Things. I want to point it out. At the moment there is no global network, only local ones with different protocols and languages. A united Internet of things does not exist yet. 

Is there any will to construct it? Was there any attempt to make it?

Definitely. Now there is a war of formats and protocols, so the big players have to come to an agreement and that is not easy.

There are a lot of technical questions in this area, our partners published the first book in Russian about it: Internet of Things by Alexander Roslyakov. It describes all participants and consortiums, despite the fact that the field is fluctuating and is complicated to analyze.


Mind map of mobile technologies. Photo: Dmje /​Flickr​.com

Does it mean that in the nearest time there will be a new format to conquer them all?

We expect this in five or maximum seven years. All principles and services already exist on a local scale and there is not much time left for a great explosion. The only struggle is to come to an agreement.

When Internet of Things becomes unified, what changes in society should be expected?

Basically, this is an endless topic. Let’s start from a big city scale. Internet of Things will affect practically all spheres of city technology, e.g. smart-​rows, electrical supply networks, hydropower engineering. Energy supply is a significant separate field, where power engineers work together with IT engineers.

There is no Internet of Things

Talking about urban life, first of all you should consider sensors. There are many types of wireless sensor networks which monitor data and changes of everything, including light, soil, noise, temperature, air etc. They are becoming cheaper at the moment. Actually, everyone can set up a wireless sensor network in an area where they live. Some time ago Google bought Nest, it is obviously a start-​up of Internet of Things. They sell thermostats which are a new source of information about people. Google also traces what data users are typing, geolocation, some minimal data from smartphone sensors, and there are a lot of sensors one can wear. That provides vast supervision facilities.

If we talk about society, it is better to start from the conscience. It can also be monitored, transmitted to various interfaces, and read, the same as geolocation data. Different interfaces provide abilities to communicate to oneself and to others at a non-​verbal, emotional level. In the field of Internet of Things there is communicative classification: one to oneself, one to the other, one to machines, machine to machine.

Talking about local communities, we vote for open communities! If people understand how to control data, they can remotely affect an environment. In those circumstances opportunities for local self-​administration grow significantly. For example, sensors can be used by social activists. Now there is a big demand for air analyzing equipment for two reasons, firstly, it’s cheap, secondly, people do not trust the government. Personally, I also wouldn’t trust the government, and examining the air pollution is a good idea, especially if you live next to an industry. So when people have access to data and can control it, they have more freedom from external control.

In that way Internet of Things seems to be a basis for democracy.

On the one hand, it is a basis for democracy, and on the other hand it provides opportunities for control. All technologies work both ways. In general, our data doesn’t belong to us but to the government, corporations or someone else. To anyone but the people. It can have a big impact, so we should fight for this information.

Everything invented by science fiction writers already exists

Which scenario is more likely to happen in Russia in twenty years?

I think it will be very different and depend on location. It also depends on people. Of course we have a great chance for total control, similar to China. We are already being monitored: smart-​cards, IP-​phones, I think this situation of freedom and non-​freedom exists now and it is very important.

What else can follow this rise of local communities?

Besides sensors there are two more interesting issues in the Internet of Things. Objects now can have memory and can be interactive. A book by Bruce Sterling, ‘Shaping Things’, describes this. It has poetic examples about objects as portals or objects as entries. Thus, Internet of Things provides us with sensors, remote actions, memory of objects and interactivity. Using all of this you can have vivid and unusual environment. In my opinion, it moves society back from rational to archaic perception of the reality. This world seems to be magical and poetic: speaking objects, sensitive trees etc.

Is there any forecasts that are embodying now? On the level that Internet of Things can provide at the moment?

All forecasts are translated into reality. Basically, everything invented by science fiction writers already exists, it just hasn’t come to the masses. It is also about psychological preparation. The contemporary situation is very similar to the pre-​Internet period of local networks. Mass usage happens when grandparents use services like mail​.ru and there are five – seven years for this with Internet of Things.

Mobile phones and web invaded our daily routine. Will there be any chance to deny technologies after the implementation of Internet of Things ?

It seems that to deny such technologies can be really hard. That’s why we support the idea of ‘media hygiene’. Digital, media, technology addictions already exist and in a society of information there should be a high level of media culture to prevent it. You shouldn’t deny this technology but learn to communicate with it. There is one important aspect of the systems theory. It says that in a process of construction of a more complex system, abilities and skills of the previous level should prolongate. Thus, having an e-​mail service, you have to provide a regular paper post, in a way rudimental but functional. The same works for Internet of Things, you should maintain minimum skills of ‘using a chisel’.

RFID-blocking passport wallet / Adafruit Industries /

RFID-​blocking passport wallet /​Adafruit Industries /​Flickr​.com

Back to the cities and urban planning. The most important technologies there are sensors and cities sensitive to their people. What else can be implemented there?

You should understand sensors in a wide way. They not only measure carbon dioxide, noise, light or heart beat, but they also can track work of any device. With common interfaces and protocols those devices can make contact and exchange information. It is not a simplicity of only sensors but a vast area for fundamental transformation of the world.

The other big issue of the internet of Things is geotargeting and all kinds of identification. It is connected to sensors and can be used everywhere. For example in industry it is called the fourth industrial revolution: 3d printers, parametric design, smart production, dispersed production. Industry always affected cities and now patterns of industrial distribution are changing a lot. In cities RFID-​tags are very popular. They are now used in Moscow metro tickets and contemporary smartphones can be programmed to use them for other purposes.

Data doesn’t belong to us but to the government, to corporations or to someone else. To anyone but the people

Internet of Things for industry is rails, smart-​codes, automatic assemblage and disassembling, marks and sensors for robotics positioning. Recently at INNOPROM industrial fair a loading machine without an operator was presented. It is based on the simplest camera technologies but several factories, warehouses and big clusters are standing in line for it.

Is there a place for people in such industry?

We dispute a lot about this. Companies buy a machine to replace a loader with a salary of 30000 rubles and we don’t know where people will work instead. Company leaders declare their motto: ‘People should not work, people should develop’. Maybe.

Society without loaders?

I don’t like to declare and this is too complicated to calculate beforehand. From the times of post-​graduate studies we called ourselves futurologists, but actually no one knows what will happen and why. It is based on a complexity of a system, and complex stochastic systems tend to generate unpredictable results. We can say something definite for next five – seven years. After this period everything is just fantasies. I’ve written a book with a description of thinking landscapes and body prolonging in space and time, I hope it will happen, but it is more likely to be science fiction than a forecast.

Should there be a lawful basis for digital development?

There are a lot of legal issues. European Union works with it quickly and processes standards for sensors and other things, many times faster than Russia. We are far behind this.

Can you compare Russia to other countries in this field?

Without doubt, the USA rules. They have Google, Cisco Systems, IBM, Intel – all giants. China has it’s own story, they definitely understand something. About 80% of its government are engineers and there is a national strategic program for the Internet of Things, this can lead to a big step forward. Also Japan and Korea. Of course, Apple, but they will have their own preset interface and users of iPhones will have no other choice. Russia has nothing comparable to this. We have several cool projects, working prototypes and interfaces (which are the most important) such as GO+. But it is not happening systematically and we don’t have the resources to do it.

cialis sample how to get off lexapro finasteride effets secondaires viagra medicine viagra samples free viagra finasteride 5 mg zovirax dosage cheap levitra levitra without a doctor prescription lexapro vs wellbutrin how does acyclovir work ciprofloxacin hydrochloride ophthalmic azithromycin vs erythromycin discount cialis cialis generic tadalafil azithromycin class cipro and tendonitis what is azithromycin lexapro dosage what is lexapro for tamoxifen langzeitfolgen what is ciprofloxacin prescribed for cipro drug class escitalopram effets secondaires viagra single packs effects of stopping lexapro suddenly cialis online azithromycin z pak cialis medication what bacteria does ciprofloxacin kill acyclovir cream cialis patent expiration azithromycin dosage cialis alternative cialis for women viagra 100 mg azithromycin 500 erfahrungen viagra activate azithromycin liquid what does viagra do levitra bayer 20mg meilleur prix cialis website best price viagra how much does cialis cost cealis cilias viagra for women ciprofloxacin side effects in women side effects of lexapro cialis cost lexapro 5mg cheap cialis viagra 100 viagra from canada viamedic cialis what works better than viagra what is tamoxifen used for levitra generic discount viagra viagra on line no prec viagra without a doctor prescription zithromax ciprofloxacin class acyclovir ointment finasteride 5mg tamoxifen citrate acyclovir ointment 5 lexapro 20mg acyclovir 800 mg 5 times a day viagra sex how to wean off lexapro azithromycin 500 mg cialis copay card women viagra viagra for sale tamoxifen and foods to avoid lexapro reviews cialis vs viagra lexapro vs zoloft viagra nebenwirkungen does lexapro cause weight gain azithromycin three times a week cipro lexapro manufacturer website ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg tab cialis coupon cialis 20mg directions viagra alternative finasteride vs dutasteride ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg side effects how to take cialis levitra 20 mg antibiotic ciprofloxacin herbal viagra azithromycin 250 finasteride 5mg side effects cialis prices levitra 20mg cialis for men buy levitra online azithromycin 500mg tamoxifen interaction finasteride and enlarged prostate acyclovir for shingles viagra soft sophia viagra levitra 20 mg cost walmart acyclovir dosage for cold sores cialis testimonials side effects of finasteride lexapro overdose viagra pill ciprofloxacin 500 mg for urinary tract infection cialis trial cialis 30 day sample escitalopram ciprofloxacin 500 azithromycin pregnancy category cialis 5 mg escitalopram 10mg levitra 20 mg von bayer generic for lexapro lexapro and wellbutrin combination therapy levitra coupons finasteride results acyclovir side effects cialis pricing tamoxifen generic levitra azithromycin medscape ciprofloxacin side effects after age 60 lexapro generic name what does ciprofloxacin 500mg treat buy levitra 200 cialis coupon viagra cost finasteride medication viagra sans ordonnance ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg withdrawal from lexapro cost of cialis utilisation viagra price cialis cialis coupons printable azithromycine 250 mg ciprofloxacin dosage ciprofloxacin zovirax cheap viagra how does cialis work post finasteride syndrome side effects of finasteride 5mg cialis savings card ciprofloxacin 250mg where to buy viagra lexapro side effects revatio vs viagra escitalopram 20 mg cialis coupon 20 mg acyclovir 400mg canada cialis levitra dosage cialis professional ciprofloxacin 500 mg cialis dosage strengths over the counter viagra generic cialis at walmart cialis reviews tamoxifen nebenwirkungen what is cipro vardenafil 20mg lexapro dosages azithromycin for pneumonia ciprofloxacin 500mg antibiotics side effects levitra online cialis 5mg daily online cialis azithromycine cialis or viagra azithromycin 250 mg treatment viagra wikipedia propecia side effects cialis generic cialis price tamoxifen and weight gain erectile dysfunction cialis acyclovir 800 mg viagra uk ciprofloxacin eye drops ciprofloxacin nebenwirkungen how long for lexapro to work lexapro benefits for women lexapro vs celexa zovirax for cold sores what is azithromycin used for generic viagra 100mg what does azithromycin treat cialis tadalafil ciprofloxacin drops cialis daily buy viagra free cialis cipro side effects online viagra canadian viagra escitalopram oxalate cipro uses cialis coupons from manufacturer azithromycin cost azithromycin 5 day dose pack azithromycin side effects finasteride for women escitalopram nebenwirkungen ciprofloxacin uses ciprofloxacin 500mg antibiotics viagra wiki cialis on line cialis effects cialis for daily use lexapro for anxiety acyclovir dose buy cialis is azithromycin penicillin sex viagra for women daily cialis what is finasteride liquid cialis viagra online viagra tablets levitra 20 mg precio farmacia side effects of lexapro in women escitalopram side effects lexapro para que sirve viagra dosage cipro for uti lexapro 10mg tamoxifen and bone pain celexa vs lexapro cialis canadian pharmacy what is cialis azithromycin 250mg tablets 6 pack nolvadex what is viagra azithromycin eye drops viagra 50mg escitalopram 10 mg para que sirve buy cialis online buy generic levitra ciprofloxacin bnf acyclovir dosing canadian cialis levitra prices lexapro weight gain cialis for sale azithromycin coverage levitra coupon levitra vs viagra azithromycin pediatric dosing ciprofloxacin spc cialis 20 mg viagra for men finasteride side effects cipro side effects in elderly side effects of azithromycin cialis voucher is azithromycin acyclovir 400 mg what is ciprofloxacin thuoc azithromycin cipro dangers cialis patent expiration date extended cialis pills for sale cialis side effects lexapro and weight gain in women azithromycin 250 mg cialis 20mg zithromax 500 mg canada viagra viagra coupons how does lexapro work ciprofloxacin used for finasteride for hair loss cipro antibiotic what does finasteride do azithromycin for strep throat zovirax cream viagra ciprofloxacin drug class azithromycin tablet what is lexapro cialis generic availability cialas levitra vs viagra lowest cialis prices generic cialis tadalafil viagra alternatives viagra price viagra ohne rezept auf rechnung lexapro side effects men cialis from canada viagra side effects viagra vs cialis vs levitra azithromycin tablets viagra cialis propecia finasteride efectos secundarios what is finasteride used for weaning off lexapro viagra ohne rezept aus deutschland cialis patent expiration 2017 ciprofloxacin for dogs cialis pills zithromax z-​pak viagra vs cialis vs levitra ciprofloxacin coverage side effects of cialis acyclovir 200mg is tamoxifen chemotherapy vardenafil vs viagra ciprofloxacin dose lexapro side effects in women zoloft vs lexapro lexapro generic how long for azithromycin to take effect viagra natural ciprofloxacin 500 mg tabletten generic levitra vardenafil 20mg cialis otc finasteride 5mg tab ciprofloxacin 250 mg acyclovir 800 mg for shingles tamoxifen side effects cialis samples overnight acyclovir vs valacyclovir acyclovir for cold sores cialis coupons cipro antibiotics viagra prices generic viagra ciprofloxacin dosierung viagra vs cialis acyclovir 800mg cialis 10 mg cialis 30 day trial coupon zithromax dosage viagra costs what is ciprofloxacin used for cyalis viagra tablet cialis dosage levitra what is acyclovir for natural viagra ciprofloxacin 500mg tablets buying viagra cialis pharmacy prices pfizer viagra finasteride tablets side effects lexapro cialis free trial what infections does ciprofloxacin treat tamoxifen bijwerkingen azithromycine eg 500 mg bijsluiter tamoxifen side effects in women viagra without a doctor prescription usa cialis cheap lexapro and weight loss cialis vs viagra stopping lexapro what is lexapro used for what is acyclovir cialis without a doctor’s prescription equipe argentine viagra what is cipro usually prescribed for viagra generico how does viagra work viagra substitute lexapro ciprofloxacin 500mg buy viagra online viagra 100mg what is escitalopram viagra generic azithromycin 500 azithromycin 250mg cialis finasteride hair loss viagra en ligne livraison 24h wholesale cialis cialis coupons 2017 cialis coupon print what is cipro used for viagra on line what does ciprofloxacin treat cost of viagra tamoxifen side effects in women over 55 tamoxifen therapy how long does viagra last generic for cialis what is azithromycin for levitra vs viagra for hardness cialis canada side effects of viagra viagra receptfritt lexapro 10 mg is lexapro a controlled substance lexapro withdrawal symptoms viagra 100mg tablets retail price finasteride dosage viagra canada ciprofloxacin hydrochloride tamoxifen lawsuits zovirax pills ciprofloxacin hcl acyclovir dosage viagra coupon pfizer viagra coupons from pfizer azithromycin uses azithromycin without a doctor’s prescription levitra 10 mg prezzo is ciprofloxacin a penicillin acyclovir medication escitalopram 10 mg viagra vs cialis how to use viagra cipro 500 viagra for sale uk levitra erfahrungen 9 levitra at walmart finasteride azithromycin drug class side effects of ciprofloxacin lexapro bula viagra tesco cialis discount ciprofloxacin side effects side effects of acyclovir lexapro and weight gain zovirax ointment buy generic viagra viagra pillen kruidvat finasteride 5mg side effects mayo clinic levitra prezzo in farmacia what is tamoxifen cialis for bph viagra kaufen viagra bestellen finasteride long term effects finasteride 1mg side effects of azithromycin 250 mg tamoxifen cost acyclovir generic cialis side effects of ciprofloxacin 500 mg viagra pills side effects of tamoxifen zithromax antibiotic azithromycin finasteride side effects in men azithromycin pregnancy what is acyclovir used for first few days on lexapro finasteride permanent side effects levitra rezeptfrei deutschland wellbutrin and lexapro levitra 20mg cost per pill order viagra common side effects of ciprofloxacin 500 mg when will cialis go generic cipro dosage ciprofloxacin ophthalmic solution lexapro coupons lexapro withdrawal viagra effects lexapro medication lexapro side effects in men finasteride reviews finasteride 5 mg tab lexapro dosing effects of stopping finasteride azithromycin for uti female viagra cialis samples side effects of lexapro 10 mg generic lexapro azithromycin and alcohol cialis dosage recommendations how to wean off lexapro without withdrawals cialis 5mg